To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Mini or central?

jjrbus

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 8, 2018
Messages
609
Location
Florida
Musing this over. 8 years ago at age 70 I DIY installed 3 Daikin mini splits in the house, 2 9K and a 12K. At 4 years the 12k evaporator coil leaked and I diy replaced, at the same time a 9K pcb failed and had to be replaced by me of course.

Now 4 years later the pcb board in the same 9K unit has failed again, same as last time code L5. Due to being baffled I called in a tech who confirmed a bad board. Seems odd 2 boards. The board is custom order from Daikin and tech wants $830 to replace. Board is in the $600 for me to order, if Daikin will sell to me. I do not see me spending $830 on an 8 year old unit I paid $900 for that has already cooked one board. I suspect something damaging the boards but above my pay grade, yes I have surge protection.

2 of my units are up high 10'. They require deep cleaning once a year and at 78 I do not envision climbing ladders to clean for many more years. If I croak the wife will be unable to maintain the units and have to pay as I might have too also. Inter net search looks like a deep clean is in the $250 range per unit, 3 @ $250 is $750 a year.

So I could replace and relocate the 9K to where it is easier to service, new 9K Daikin about $1200 or 2 Whofungpoo china units for far less and have one for parts. If the 12k unit fails I could put the evaporator in a more serviceable place.

Or I could replace the central AC, 8 years ago the bid to replace the central and duct work was $6K I guess it would be over $10K today. In my experience central does not require the maintenance a mini does and there are far more techs that work on central than minis. The local Daikin dealer is a gas and go specialist who does not want to look for leaks! The air handler is in a labyrinth of trusses that is like a jungle gym getting to.

If I replace the mini I think I should replace the O rings in my tools as they have had no use and will have to check if they are compatible with the new gas's. What to do?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Fav Onefour

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2022
Messages
693
Location
MN cold and hot
Three units replaced with one?
I like to keep things simple.

My days are busy enough. I have twelve AC units right now. If I went against the advice of my HVAC guy I would have done a couple of those as mini splits. Thank God I listened. It would be another six units for the same buildings.
I know there is a lot of love for the mini split systems, but wait until those things start breaking down. The dirty little secret is that most are designed to last right until warranty expires. That is a lot of extra fixing if you're at 3 to 1 or higher ratios vs central systems.
 
OP
J

jjrbus

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 8, 2018
Messages
609
Location
Florida
Three units replaced with one?
I like to keep things simple.

My days are busy enough. I have twelve AC units right now. If I went against the advice of my HVAC guy I would have done a couple of those as mini splits. Thank God I listened. It would be another six units for the same buildings.
I know there is a lot of love for the mini split systems, but wait until those things start breaking down. The dirty little secret is that most are designed to last right until warranty expires. That is a lot of extra fixing if you're at 3 to 1 or higher ratios vs central systems.
I like redundancy, single unit goes out and it is an emergency. I also keep my office much warmer than the living room and the bedroom cooler than the living room.
 

CraigStu

Well-known member
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
4,014
Location
Blacksburg, Va
Do you need to replace the ducts in the old central unit. Between myself and friends I am aware of 4 central AC replacements and none changed ducting. The installers just made up and adapter to connect the indoor unit to the existing duct.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom