To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

multimeter question

CatKid

Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2011
Messages
19
Location
NW Iowa
Get a fluke for one reason: Safety.

That might be the best answer in this entire thread!

If i'm troubleshooting in an electrical cabinet with 230v or working on a 3~ 690v motor I'm going to make damn sure I have the best equipment money can buy me to make sure I don't get lit up.
So yes, I've got a fluke. My life is worth alot more to me than a cheap 30 dollar meter from sears.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

route246

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2007
Messages
816
Location
NorCal
I'm old school and I still go to one of my Triplett 310 analog VOMs move of the time. I have three or four of them that I've collected during the past 30+ years. I don't really like the 15V battery requirement but other than that, this meter is one of the best. See this link.

BTW, I have plenty of Fluke and other digital meters, too. I just like analog for some reason.
 

Sick Puppy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2010
Messages
869
Location
Sydney
It's hard for me to answer your question because what is available to me in the US may not be available to you. Certainly Fluke, Agilent and Tektronix are all competitive brands. (With Fluke and Tektronix being Danaher owned for those who care.)

Do you want analog or digital?

I had not priced multimeters in years because my employer provided Fluke and I have two personally owned Flukes. This thread caused me to research multimeter pricing and I was quite shocked. I also was suprised to see most of the low end Fluke models discontinued.

The intent of my original message was not to discourage buying used Flukes off Ebay but rather to caution that Fluke warranty is no longer lifetime and does not pass from the original owner. If you find a used Fluke on Ebay and then should have need for repair, many repair services charge a flat rate repair price of $198 (US) for Fluke 87 and $145 (US) for Fluke 79. I have seen new Fluke 115 pricing of $159 (US). Why repair used when new (with warranty) is cheaper? Granted the Fluke 115 does not have all the bells & whistles.

There is a new Agilent display technology called OLED that does not require a backlight. It will be interesting to see if this catches on with the other manufacturers. This may be why Fluke is discontinuing so many models.

Right now it's auto diagnostics for a car project I have yet to start, and hobbyist electronics; no mains electrics, or hybrid batteries, or anything else that can turn me into a smoking cinder.

I'm figuring (having done the reading only) that I'd need something digital that can do both auto and manual ranging, and 15-20A. There are other features I could probably do with, but accuracy and reliability are what I guess I'm paying for.

Thing is that Fluke are considered the snap on of multimeters, and it's like no one knows of anything else here, which is why I asked in the first place. With tools like ratchets and screwdrivers you have snap on and the decent japanese, german and other makes. Lots of people use them, and while they look the same, and do the same thing, between experience and branding, people know about them. On the other hand though, if you knew nothing about them, they all look the same... so how do you tell?

Unless you're a pro who has worked with heaps of brands etc. (which I'm not), multimeters are literally the same to me, and if anything, more generic, just a dial and display since they come from the same factory. So after that it's features, accuracy and reliability/toughness, but again, how do you tell? Ask around though, and all I hear is fluke fluke fluke, everything else is Chinese rubbish that will **** out (apart from the Fluke 115's and 116's that are manufactured in China for the Asian market).

I've no issue with buying a used fluke off of eBay, but if it breaks though, I imagine I'll have to biff it, as it looks like it will cost as much to repair as to buy another used one (and no, buying a new one is not an option for me!). But I'd like to find out about other decent makes - I cannot believe that Fluke are the only decent brand on the market...

On the one hand, I would like to know if there is any decent reliable brand that isn't going to cost me a kidney to buy, so I can learn this stuff on something good, and trust the results. On the other hand I'm thinking that I'm over-thinking things, should just settle down and buy a halfway decent one from the local electronics store.

While it's my first port of call, I'm not worried about what I can get here in NZ, I'm considering overseas too if I can get a really good one. I want what everyone wants, as much as I can get for as little as possible! lol :bounce: (note the smiley face, I realise that quality costs!)

[goes off to have a sit down and a cup of tea, as his head hurts with all this talking and whatnot]
 
Last edited:

les_garten

Banned
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
660
Location
PSL, FL Next door to Megan FOX, and down the stre
Right now it's auto diagnostics for a car project I have yet to start, and hobbyist electronics; no mains electrics, or hybrid batteries, or anything else that can turn me into a smoking cinder.

I'm figuring (having done the reading only) that I'd need something digital that can do both auto and manual ranging, and 15-20A. There are other features I could probably do with, but accuracy and reliability are what I guess I'm paying for.

Thing is that Fluke are considered the snap on of multimeters, and it's like no one knows of anything else here, which is why I asked in the first place. With tools like ratchets and screwdrivers you have snap on and the decent japanese, german and other makes. Lots of people use them, and while they look the same, and do the same thing, between experience and branding, people know about them. On the other hand though, if you knew nothing about them, they all look the same... so how do you tell?

Unless you're a pro who has worked with heaps of brands etc. (which I'm not), multimeters are literally the same to me, and if anything, more generic, just a dial and display since they come from the same factory. So after that it's features, accuracy and reliability/toughness, but again, how do you tell? Ask around though, and all I hear is fluke fluke fluke, everything else is Chinese rubbish that will **** out (apart from the Fluke 115's and 116's that are manufactured in China for the Asian market).

I've no issue with buying a used fluke off of eBay, but if it breaks though, I imagine I'll have to biff it, as it looks like it will cost as much to repair as to buy another used one (and no, buying a new one is not an option for me!). But I'd like to find out about other decent makes - I cannot believe that Fluke are the only decent brand on the market...

On the one hand, I would like to know if there is any decent reliable brand that isn't going to cost me a kidney to buy, so I can learn this stuff on something good, and trust the results. On the other hand I'm thinking that I'm over-thinking things, should just settle down and buy a halfway decent one from the local electronics store.

While it's my first port of call, I'm not worried about what I can get here in NZ, I'm considering overseas too if I can get a really good one. I want what everyone wants, as much as I can get for as little as possible! lol :bounce: (note the smiley face, I realise that quality costs!)

[goes off to have a sit down and a cup of tea, as his head hurts with all this talking and whatnot]


I think everything has been answered in this thread. If you buy a used Fluke and it breaks, you're not any worse off than if you bought a used anything else and it breaks. I had a $25,000 Fluke Network analyzer as well as my current little 87. IME they don't break. Pretty solid stuff, that's why they are Loved so much!


Did you bother to watch these videos referenced in this thread?

http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showpost.php?p=1442061&postcount=35
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Sick Puppy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2010
Messages
869
Location
Sydney
Did you bother to watch these videos referenced in this thread?

http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showpost.php?p=1442061&postcount=35

No, for the reasons I stated in my post - with the exception of the UniTrend/UNI-T ones and the rebadged Jaycar, I've not heard of any of them. That is why I was asking about decent makes other than Fluke - if they're in that shoot out, I will look them up and do some digging. :thumbup:

I'll have a look today, but between buying unknown brands from the states, or unknown brands here and they're of similar quality, I'll choose here!
 
Last edited:

les_garten

Banned
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
660
Location
PSL, FL Next door to Megan FOX, and down the stre
No, for the reasons I stated in my post - with the exception of the UniTrend/UNI-T ones and the rebadged Jaycar, I've not heard of any of them. That is why I was asking about decent makes other than Fluke - if they're in that shoot out, I will look them up and do some digging. :thumbup:

I'll have a look today, but between buying unknown brands from the states, or unknown brands here and they're of similar quality, I'll choose here!

Those are the usual suspects, and I've heard of all of them. That review was of the only alternatives to Fluke
 

Sancho

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 5, 2011
Messages
162
Location
The backwoods
If jaycar in NZ is anything like inOZ its akin the a radioshack back when they sold actual electronics. Their kit is so so, but its not somethong to use everyday. Id even opinion most of it is junk.

Maybe try researching EZ? Its no fluke, but all of the field kits at my office use those for strain gage checks. I know the reason they were chosen was lower cost if lost during transit
 

ourkid2000

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
927
Location
Nova Scotia
I work for a major airline and 99% of the meters we have are Flukes.......we have Fluke 87's, 179's, Meggars, Scopemeters, you name it.

Still, we have to break out our Simpson 260 from time to time. That meter movement catches things the others just do not (some of our maintenance manuals actually state that the 260 be used due to the load it places on the circuit)........it's still a great meter and it has its uses.
 

Sick Puppy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2010
Messages
869
Location
Sydney
Sorry to resuscitate a dead thread (well, six weeks, I've seen and done worse! lol), but has anyone used Sanwa or Hioki multimeters from Japan? Any good? And what about GW Instek apparently Taiwanese, but have at least one unit that is the same as a Uni-T one (no pun intended).

At this time a Fluke is out for me - it's like me splashing out on Snap-On, simply overkill.

So far there is Jaycar, Uni-T and **** Smith (that also sell Uni-T). I'm looking at the vids tomorrow, and might ask around forums in NZ to see what people use. Since I'm visiting the UK at some point in the near-ish future, I may look at a cheap-ish one now, and a decent one over there... fingers crossed!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom