To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

need 1 breaker bar

SC-AW11

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 23, 2012
Messages
463
I need 1 breaker bar for my engine class. I'm gonna include it in my first snap on student order.

If you were to have only 1 breaker bar (especially for tearing down/rebuilding a pushrod v8, if that purpose makes a difference), what would it be?

3/8" longest I think around 12" $32

1/2" 18" long $52

1/2" 24" long $57
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

kunkernator

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
2,438
Location
US of A
I would get the 24'', but that's just me. You can always adapt up or down in drive size, but I think the length is a plus considering it is a "breaker" bar.
 

Super Sport

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
4,081
Location
West Michigan
I'll be honest, if I only had one breaker bar it wouldn't be a Snap On. No need to spend that kind of money on a breaker bar, even at 50% off.

Out of the options, I'd go with the longest 1/2" drive. Although, a long 3/8 drive is nice. I bought one from HF (16" ? long) and I absolutely love it. Unfortunately I can't find a USA made one that long. I broke a number of 1/2-3/8 reducers using a 1/2 breaker, so I wanted a long 3/8.
 

greasegorilla

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
86
1/2 drive 18"

3/8 is too small, you can always adapt down. 18" is just right, 24" can be to long sometimes. You can always put a cheater bar on an 18" to make it longer, but you wouldnt want to cut the knurled handle off a 24" to make it shorter.

Also, I've recently picked up a 18" 3/4 drive breaker bar, which I plan to use on 3/4 stuff, as well as with a 3/4x1/2 impact adapter for the really difficult stuff when I use a cheater pipe.
 

shockwave

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,125
Location
Marietta,ga
I would go with the big 24 1/2 breaker bar and get the others when needed but 18 will give u more versatility
 

rshadd

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2009
Messages
1,598
Location
Doylestown, PA
I recently bought the 18" Snap-On SN18B. I went with the 18" over the 24" because the 24" wouldn't fit in any of my drawers.
 

MattPersman

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 1, 2009
Messages
1,656
Location
Indiana
I have all of these (well the 24" is a matco the other 2 are snap on but anyways) to just pick one I would start with the 24" 1/2 drive

Great pricing
 

BDT/NWMN

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 22, 2012
Messages
3,762
Location
Erskine, Mn
If you don't plan on buying 3/4" drive, buy the toughest, longest 1/2" drive breaker bar you can find... That 24" SnapOn would be a good choice...
 

Chadwilliam1

Well-known member
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
2,788
Location
Cincinnati
24" but really you want both. I plan on buying the hf 16" 3/8. its unfortunate I cant find one made in use. I despise putting adapters on breaker bars.
 

Justin1776

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 28, 2012
Messages
286
Location
SW Florida
24" 1/2 inch drive for sure. The extra 6" comes in handy when working on bigger engines like BBC's with main caps torqued to around 100 ft. lbs. Tearing down engines can be kind of wonky because they like to bounce a little on the engine stand, and the the stand wants to roll around too so you end up bracing against the engine to keep it still. The extra 6" helps a lot considering those factors.

On a somewhat related note, 3/8 drive speed wrenches are awesome for putting engines back together, not sure if it is on your list or not but I would recommend one :beer:
 

dirtydogintex

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
927
Location
inner looper-3rd Div Houston w & n
They don't give the same deal/discount on Williams do they?
That'd be a real sweet deal!!

You'd be better off w/a 3/4" beaker but most'll settle for a 1/2".
18" handle would be most versatile as somone's already mentioned.

All breakers should have at least one fairly close fitting cheater.... square tubing or pipe subject to availability/user's preference.

I prefer square tubing.... allows a more secure grip when covered in grease and less pursuit across the shop....
 

Jason280

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2012
Messages
3,164
24" 1/2" breaker bar, no question about it...except, it would be a HF and not a Snap On. A breaker bar is one of those tools you really don't need to drop the extra cash on, and I'm as big a Snap On homer as anyone else.

For around $30 you can have one of each from HF, a 25" & 18" 1/2" bar, and a 17" 3/8 breaker bar. No reason to limit yourself to just one, especially when you can have all three for $30.

http://www.harborfreight.com/catalogsearch/result?q=breaker+bar
 

MattPersman

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 1, 2009
Messages
1,656
Location
Indiana
Problem with the HF is it flexes when really pushed I ran in to that problem recently and I loved the HF till that point still is good for 90% of jobs I bought a matco and it has been better for that last 10%
 

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
For around $30 you can have one of each from HF, a 25" & 18" 1/2" bar, and a 17" 3/8 breaker bar. No reason to limit yourself to just one, especially when you can have all three for $30.
I hate to break any news but in reality this is the case.. Take a 15$ breaker bar arm oneself with a set of 1/2 sockets from Walmart for 18$, find an extension or 2 and for a couple of 20's as far as anone would notice you would be a bad mofo.

I love heat and beat but it proves it out. I got to wonder,, and consider when I say ruff service I mean by multiple men in many cases where we use common size and hi repetition only second to a tire store the life I get from a 4$ off the shelf cheap socket, branded,,, by the parts store or Walmart now,,, but this socket, thousands,, ok,, maybe hundreds and hundreds of wheels over years and years is still in service to who knows what limit,,,, how could I have been helped by using a 40$ socket???

When I think about this,,, have broke about 3 or 4 brand wchich were 12 a piece and 3 or 4 generic import which were under 4 a piece,,, all this under similar circumstances way beyond what any one given man would naturally occur, some of it on second generation and used in constructionj etc.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Thumper

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 5, 2005
Messages
2,209
Location
N.E.Ga
The 24 inch 1/2 inch drive........in case you run into some really tight bolts.
 

bczygan

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
22,002
Location
DETROIT! Arsenal of Scrappers
Ahhhh....there is no hope for you. You are already showing a lack of judgement by drinking the SO Cool-aid. Go get a HF breaker bar and put the money in your pocket or better yet, invest it.

Student pricing is a lure. Resist it.
 

NineFingerFury

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 4, 2013
Messages
206
Location
Kent, WA
Problem with the HF is it flexes when really pushed I ran in to that problem recently and I loved the HF till that point still is good for 90% of jobs I bought a matco and it has been better for that last 10%

When using the HF one to take off a stuck ****** fill bolt on a Honda, it flexed so much I couldn't use it. There wasn't enough room to mess around. It also had a fair amount of slop in the head after about a year of periodic use in the home garage mostly used to loosen lug nuts.
 

Pumpman1968

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Messages
1,520
Location
Upstate, NY
24" but really you want both. I plan on buying the hf 16" 3/8. its unfortunate I cant find one made in use. I despise putting adapters on breaker bars.

The first time you bust your hand open will be the last time you use a 3/8" x 1/2" adapter on a 24" breaker bar. Buy a few less expensive ones first then trade up to the brand you want later....the used tools will hold their value and you'll almost always get your money back.
 

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I wonder what the warranty numbers are,,, in all the years,,, several socket sets, have got one bad product from HF, a metric deep well that was junk, I used what worked and what didn't I just replaced from the jobber as described above off the shelf 4$ a piece, I bought 2 18's and a 15 which I couldn't find,,, so will get another, then the one will show up.

For 8 extra dollars I split the load and reduce the risk by using second unit,,, not only am I insuring against breakage in event I need this but against loss,,, 4$ wont break me and I can find another one if I need it. So for 16$ I get 4 sockets I can use in sizes I need and have redundancy. Half the money of one 40$ socket I got to worry about and has been severely stress tested and proven satisfactory is beyond statistical fact.

Back to numbers, wonder how many Stanley sockets returned by retarded hillbillies armed with a 24 inch breaker bar, a case of beer, maybe a metric electric impact. Never see it on threads? Only reliable testimony to it working says it works,,, how many,,, bought 40$ set of impact sockets for truck shop, beat the **** out of them, still work.

I am a flat rate whiz is ********, there are a few that are brutal, but many I don't want to hurt my tools and scuff the wax while I polish and fuss to no end. I am about having it all at hand,, the high numbers stuff, sometimes less is more, learn to do a common task with a common tool masters have used for years.

I use a 24 inch breaker bar, I use a 24 inch extension on occasion, I got to have one, most people should eventually but never have broke one, none of my men have broke one of mine, the 2 I have are old, they are not polished chrome but from Cman sets I bought when starting out, there was absolutely no none reason t replace them especially if I was hiding them in a drawer all but a couple minutes a week.

As far as I can recall 1 broken breaker bar, I must own about 6, the one wasn't faulty, any higher level of quality tool would have been a waste offer last 30+ years, not once did they fail, not do what was expected, survived some abuse, paying 50 a piece for them (vs the 10) would not have helped one thing.

Not only that in the end rarely use one, worked my way out of the need for lots of them, I got to have one,,,, or need to do something out of the way on occasion, on the road etc but use impact daily,, bar rarely.
 
Last edited:

I van putski

Banned
Joined
Jan 9, 2013
Messages
453
Location
In northwestern PA
I don't think HF was one of the options he was considering as he didn't mention them in his post.

Get the 24" 1/2 drive you won't be disappointed, it will last a lifetime and you can be proud to own it.
 

refried

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2013
Messages
2,037
Location
San Juan Islands, WA.
Get the Snap On 24" 1/2 inch. If your going to make this a career get professional tools, HF and Craftsman are ok to use if your a homeowner but they have no place in a shop (exept the custom bent wrench draw). Your going to break tools, why get the easiest to break? I went thru my broken tool bucket yesterday and found 2 Snap On breaker bars (one broken head, one snapped shaft) how many HF breaker bars do you think would be in there. Craftsman breaker bars are no better, I keep a supply of sheer pins (from sears) on hand because they break so easily.
 
Last edited:

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I was in an Amish welding shop, they made wood stoves, you want to see some brutalized tools, they had about half enough, maybe 14 of what they need so it was well shared by a whole shop full of wild kids. man that stuff was pounded,,, literally.

But,,, having seen the frenzy at auction I am convinced you could buy a HF 44 inch box, drag it brhind the pickup, get some wrenches, arc strike and let a bunch of kids work on them with 4 pounders, maybe toss them thru the rock crusher, put wrenches in tool box and get more than you paid for it.

It appears you can brutalize a HF, terrorize it for 10 years and get back all your money even with a couple "good" sizes missing.
I suspect prior to this sale someone came thru and cherry picked all the common branded stuff to make a set, what was left was China polished Chrome and some snappy pieces that looked like it did a couple tuff tours.

The snap brought 20 cents mabe 30 but who would a thunk that a selection of random scrap would have done so well.
 

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I went thru my broken tool bucket yesterday and found 2 Snap On breaker bars (one broken head, one snapped shaft) how many HF breaker bars do you think would be in there.
So far none,,, Like I said, we broke one, it would have broke a good one. Stupid operator. Look at the threads here, constant warranty so this and that, how many testimonials of stuff that worked, I see a lot of reliable stuff here from we bought set of Cman impacts etc for 40$ that have worked for them good long time until this point.

Generic breakers and impact sockets have prove themselves out in my class 8 shop, ha I fired someone for breakage, must have been a nightmare where ever he worked, next guy didn't so much as break a bolt in 5 years let alone a tool. We got enough stuff there is an easy right way. It sounds far fetched but lots of people that work as mechanics,,, some of them real smart never really learn how to be proficient with hand tools.
 
Last edited:

shocksandstrutz

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2012
Messages
699
Location
Wentzville, MO
ive got 2 HF 24" 1/2 drives, 18" 1/2 drive SK and a 16" 1/2 drive craftsman, the 24's are my go to's....i like the length and i get plenty of leverage to bust axle nuts and yoke bolts!!

buy the brand that makes you happy, have fun!!
 

ex-x-fire

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 10, 2012
Messages
3,749
Location
Sheboygan Falls Wi.
This is the HF breaker bar to get, I haven't seen one break or bend yet. I don't know about the other hf (older style) breaker bars.
 

Attachments

  • 30395.gif
    30395.gif
    10.8 KB · Views: 38

I van putski

Banned
Joined
Jan 9, 2013
Messages
453
Location
In northwestern PA
I need 1 breaker bar for my engine class. I'm gonna include it in my first snap on student order.

If you were to have only 1 breaker bar (especially for tearing down/rebuilding a pushrod v8, if that purpose makes a difference), what would it be?

3/8" longest I think around 12" $32

1/2" 18" long $52

1/2" 24" long $57

Hey dude, I'm sorry. Next time you are thinking of buying a snap on tool just go with your gut feeling of what you will need. Do not ask the garage journal as you now know how that will turn out.
Again I'm sorry. Enjoy which ever snap on breaker you choose. It will last you a lifetime.
I van
 

bcradio

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
6,017
Location
New Mexico
I don't use a breaker bar really anymore having impact guns now, but I'd go with a 24"er if I was getting one. You don't want to worry about it being to short. And no, I don't use cheater pipes. If that is too short, its time for the 40" 3/4 drive
 

dirtydogintex

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
927
Location
inner looper-3rd Div Houston w & n
Get the Snap On 24" 1/2 inch. If your going to make this a career get professional tools, HF and Craftsman are ok to use if your a homeowner but they have no place in a shop (exept the custom bent wrench draw)....
goodgoshalmighty....someone said it best some time ago
There is a fifth dimension beyond that which is known to man. It is a dimension as vast as space and as timeless as infinity. It is the middle ground between light and shadow, between science and superstition, and it lies between the pit of man's fears and the summit of his knowledge. This is the dimension of imagination. It is an area which we call the Twilight Zone.
 

Bikes&Bowties

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
337
Location
Washington
Im not a harborfrieght fan but $9.00 for a24inch breaker is unbeatable, I never use it but I have it. Honestly with the long fine tooth ratchets, theres no need for a breaker

tools012.jpg
 

Hyster Gareth

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2011
Messages
434
Location
Ottawa ON
Absolutely agree with these comments. I would not use an adapter your health is important.


The first time you bust your hand open will be the last time you use a 3/8" x 1/2" adapter on a 24" breaker bar. Buy a few less expensive ones first then trade up to the brand you want later....the used tools will hold their value and you'll almost always get your money back.
 

kossuth

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
1,787
Would you trust a doctor or dentist who didn't use the best tools available? What's the difference?
Yes I would. Because the hack with subpar skills and the latest technology will kill you. A skilled doc will do the absolute best they can given the tools they have to work with. And if the task exceeds the ability of their tools (or knowledge if they are good) will refer you to a counterpart whom has the skills and the equipment.

Mechanics are no different really. The man holding the wrench is the 95% of the equation.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom