I disagree. A ratchet can be just as strong as a breaker bar. In fact, long 24"+ ratchets are often called breaker bars... You have to consider the weak points which is usually the anvil. The ratchet mechanism vs. no ratchet mechanism is usually a moot point. All the force is on the anvil, the weak point, and that will break first. A ratchet also allows you to readjust, a breaker bar can't do that.
I don't understand the mentality of not wanting to use expensive tools (or "abuse" depending on your situation or definition of abuse). Yeah, Snap On tools are beautiful, but they are meant to be used. I don't buy tools to be displayed, I buy them to use them. I'm also one of those guys who will wipe down my tools after a job with a dry rag, but I don't go beyond that. I don't care if they get dirty, because again, they are meant to be used. I only care if they are wet with oil or some form of fluid, especially ATF or brake fluid.
Tools have warranties for a reason. Use the damn tool. If they break, use the damn warranty. Which brings me to my next rant...
As for Craftsman, I don't trust them nor will I ever buy another Craftsman tool. But more important all the Sears stores in my state are closed and gone, the only place you'll find Craftsman are Lowes and Ace. They have limited stock and a questionable warranty process. And you don't know what you'll get if you do use the warranty. Will it be the same tool you are trying to warranty? Probably not. Will it be an inferior and even cheaper version? Most definitely.
