Oil Drain Pan that does not leak?

[David9726]

I've had this one for over a year it worked okay but it just started leaking from a seam in the plastic. I liked it since i could take it up town and recycle oil from multiple vehicles. It needs to be low profile.

 

[M6erfan]

Where is it leaking from? If the screw cap, a simple nitrile gasket should set it right.

 

[RAS61]

I have a round pan like yours but the cap at the spout drips so I can't use it for transport. These are all cheaply made, best system I've ever used is a Lisle 4.5 gal. pan that is only for collection, no transporting. Thick plastic that doesn't flex, and a great spout that fits nicely inside the mouth of the 5 qt jug the new oil came in - no need for a funnel. I then use the old jug for recycling transport - easy to handle and has great cap and seal that won't leak even if it falls over. That's my recommendation.

 

[white91formula]

I have a round pan like yours but the cap at the spout drips so I can't use it for transport. These are all cheaply made, best system I've ever used is a Lisle 4.5 gal. pan that is only for collection, no transporting. Thick plastic that doesn't flex, and a great spout that fits nicely inside the mouth of the 5 qt jug the new oil came in - no need for a funnel. I then use the old jug for recycling transport - easy to handle and has great cap and seal that won't leak even if it falls over. That's my recommendation.

Replace the cap with one off a anti freeze or washer fluid bottle and it wont leak anymore.

 

[Rick B.]

I've been using one like this for about 10 years and it doesn't leak.

View media item 78738

 

[CJM8515]

I have a round pan like yours but the cap at the spout drips so I can't use it for transport. These are all cheaply made, best system I've ever used is a Lisle 4.5 gal. pan that is only for collection, no transporting. Thick plastic that doesn't flex, and a great spout that fits nicely inside the mouth of the 5 qt jug the new oil came in - no need for a funnel. I then use the old jug for recycling transport - easy to handle and has great cap and seal that won't leak even if it falls over. That's my recommendation.

Same one. LOVE it.

 

[xin]

I've been using one like this for about 10 years and it doesn't leak.

View media item 78738

You got a link to this one?

 

[Super Sport]

It's pricey (I got mine on sale cheap) but I really love this one from OTC: https://www.tooltopia.com/otc-tools...xeL8N-Mw5U1-G8eEW8rrAK3hZ1tvP5hRoCTfMQAvD_BwE

It's big to prevent spills, but that could be a downside if transporting it. All of the caps have o-rings to prevent leaks, and so far they have done just that.

 

[RAS61]

Replace the cap with one off a anti freeze or washer fluid bottle and it wont leak anymore.

I did, still leaks, threads are total sh!t, if you tighten too much it slips off, not enough it leaks - drips either way. The jug the oil came in works best for me, drain pans have oil splatter and film on them, don't want that in my car, especially with a cheap cap and design that could fail. My 2 cents.

 

[M6erfan]

Hopkins makes a Heavy Duty model but it's not low profile like the OP needs. I typically just use the old oil containers for transport. If you want something fancy you could always get something like this...https://www.amazon.com/Hopkins-FloTool-11849-Dispos-Oil-Recycle/dp/B0014FKI1Q/ref=pd_sbs_263_11?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B0014FKI1Q&pd_rd_r=R412PY2J2E788SQ6FDYQ&pd_rd_w=h8tOZ&pd_rd_wg=UUIVm&psc=1&refRID=R412PY2J2E788SQ6FDYQ

 

[Lynden]

I use a metal pan which I empty into a 5-gallon bucket and take to the recycling center when it's 3/4 full.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000BOB7RU/?tag=atomicindus08-20

 

[Tonyuk]

I use a large aluminium roasting tray from a catering supply shop, if hammered one of the corners to a point so i can pour the contents out easily, hold about 8 - 10 litres i think.

 

[David9726]

It's leaking from a seam in the plastic and yes that screw on cap pops off if you tighten it to much.

 

[NUTTSGT]

I'd consider getting both a new drain pan and a jug to transport the used oil in.

 

[firworks]

You might just get another one of the one you've got. I've got that same one and it just sits with oil in it most of the time. It hasn't leaked out in a few years so far. Maybe yours just had a manufacturing defect. If I remember correctly they were very cheap so it's not high risk to grab one more.

 

[dogdog]

Hopkins makes a Heavy Duty model but it's not low profile like the OP needs. I typically just use the old oil containers for transport. If you want something fancy you could always get something like this...https://www.amazon.com/Hopkins-FloTool-11849-Dispos-Oil-Recycle/dp/B0014FKI1Q/ref=pd_sbs_263_11?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B0014FKI1Q&pd_rd_r=R412PY2J2E788SQ6FDYQ&pd_rd_w=h8tOZ&pd_rd_wg=UUIVm&psc=1&refRID=R412PY2J2E788SQ6FDYQ

used the same container for transport, That is a great container, it is rugged and sturdy (don't remember where I got it from), I left it outdoors and still in good shape for years..... . For draining oil I just use anything from oil pan to IKEA plastic bin.....

 

[atikovi]

I've had this one for over a year it worked okay but it just started leaking from a seam in the plastic. I liked it since i could take it up town and recycle oil from multiple vehicles. It needs to be low profile.

I hate those integrated drain pan/container combos. The pan is too shallow so the draining oil splashes all over the ground and bottom of the car. Use a separate drain pan and container. I have this pan:

and a 4 gallon plastic container to take to the dump.

 

[Alpine4x4]

I hate those integrated drain pan/container combos. The pan is too shallow so the draining oil splashes all over the ground and bottom of the car. Use a separate drain pan and container. I have this pan:


and a 4 gallon plastic container to take to the dump.

Agreed. I have the same pan as the OP and it is a mess doing oil changes on our trucks. Mine doesnt leak, but I promptly empty it into the jugs the new oil came in. I'll be going to a deep pan like you showed.

 

[visionguru]

I've had this one for over a year it worked okay but it just started leaking from a seam in the plastic. I liked it since i could take it up town and recycle oil from multiple vehicles. It needs to be low profile.

I would just repair it with super glue.

Mine was the cap that cracked. I super glued it about 3 years ago, no more leaking.
I only use it to drain oil and pour the oil into a milk jar for recycling. Don't want to risk a mess in the trunk.

I've noticed that almost all the oil pans in stores are "Made in USA". The quality is definitely not better than stuff from Walmart.

 

[RAS61]

I hate those integrated drain pan/container combos. The pan is too shallow so the draining oil splashes all over the ground and bottom of the car. Use a separate drain pan and container. I have this pan:

and a 4 gallon plastic container to take to the dump.

This is the one I use and recommended, easy to drain and transfer w/o splatter

 

[wkndwarrior29]

I use a metal pan which I empty into a 5-gallon bucket and take to the recycling center when it's 3/4 full.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000BOB7RU/?tag=atomicindus08-20

+1

Get a leak proof lid for a bucket and use it for transport and collection. I had a pan like yours and cut the top off to make changes cleaner then just dump it in the bucket.

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

 

[hautpot]

i use a large 22 gauge stainless food service tray (doesn't have a lid) then i dump that into a 5 gallon bucket (has a lid) when i am done. I also have a plastic one made in canada that i got from homedepot

I got a couple sizes and the biggest can hold 21 quarts. Best part is that if the oil isn't black i can see if i dropped parts into the shiny stainless bottom. Doesn't have a spout like these fancy ones, but my bucket is 12" diameter how can you miss?

 

[gregpack]

I use a plastic mixing tub that they sell over by the quickcrete in Home depot. It is designed for on site mixing of small batches of concrete mix. Its very sturdy, low profile, and cost less than $10.

 

[G1K]

No leaks with this container - been in use for several years now.

http://geoplastics.com/oil-recycling-containers-15-qt

Ryan

 

[mrborohachi]

This is the one I use and recommended, easy to drain and transfer w/o splatter

+1 and I

I always get these containers for free from a restaurant my friends dad owns. You will also find these all day in the dumpsters at a movie theater. Do not let the cardboard get wet, they made the plastic bottle as thin/cheap as they could using the cardboard as support.

I throw the container out, actually most of the time the auto part stores throw the container out for me. If your city has a fire dept sponsored hazardous waste dumping day they will definitely throw it out for you and you don't have to lug anything home.

 

[apollo11]

holds 20 gallons
I put all my drain pans in it
13 bucks
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Large-Mixing-Tub-26101/300488529?keyword=cement+trough

 

[gregpack]

holds 20 gallons
I put all my drain pans in it
13 bucks
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Large-Mixing-Tub-26101/300488529?keyword=cement+trough

I use the little brother of that one.

 

[mfewtrail]

I have the typical round 15qt pan and a square around 10qt(?) pan - neither leak. I always throw a piece of cardboard under my pans so that if I spill a drop or two of oil it doesn't get on my floor. As a side benefit, the cardboard is being abraded when sliding the pan into place rather than the pan itself. I have seen a few pans that were used daily in shops develop leaks from being abraded over time against the concrete floor.

edit: Added pictures of the styles I have. For some reason, you have to click on the link for the second attachment I added - it was a PNG file originally, so maybe that makes the difference.

A link to the rectangle style I have. The round one is from Walmart. The rectangle one was as well, but I don't think they've had them in quite a few years.

http://www.landmsupply.com/search-results/midwest-closed-top-oil-drain-pan-9-qt

 

[Qualitytools]

This is the one I use and recommended, easy to drain and transfer w/o splatter

Got a link for that one? Thanks!

 

[Captain Spaulding]

I've been using one like this for about 10 years and it doesn't leak.

View media item 78738

Problem I have with pans like this is that low viscosity oil shoots out horizontally so far that you have to guess where to put the pan for it to hit the opening, then as the oil starts to drip you have to move the pan so it's under the drain. 3 times out of 4 I end up with oil on the floor or the side of the pan.

 

[Captain Spaulding]

No leaks with this container - been in use for several years now.

http://geoplastics.com/oil-recycling-containers-15-qt

Ryan

Looks interesting, but the site doesn't have the dimensions of the thing anywhere, which is baffling, they don't have anything about where you can buy it, and Google shows no hits for it but the manufacturer's site. Apparently they don't want to sell them.

Any idea where to get one?

 

[RAS61]

Got a link for that one? Thanks!

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000JFHMVQ/?tag=atomicindus08-20

The real benefit of this pan over mason tubs and other open trays is the spout, so easy and clean to transfer to a transport container. Note it gets 4 1/2 stars from 414 reviews.

As for the container recommendations to transport the used oil -
* I wouldn't want a canola/food oil jug if the plastic is thin, why risk a disaster in your car or elsewhere?
* Large 5 gal buckets and drain and transport pans seem heavy and cumbersome. One slip (we are dealing with oil that splatters) or trip and you have a messy disaster. Drain and transport pans also have 3 potential failure points - the inlet plug, drain cap, and vent (usually a cheap snap plug that easily pops open).
* Purpose built oil disposal jugs are fine, but the original jug works just as well, is very safe and easy to handle, and is already purchased. I keep a few on hand marked "Old Oil" with a Sharpie, and when I get 3 or 4 full I take them to the recycle yard. Fine if you prefer another method, but to me some are overthinking this.

 

[scubadoober]

Had this one at my last house and left it there. Bought the typical Blitz screw on ones and hate it. This thread reminded me I need to pick one back up. Thanks GJ!

 

[6PTsocket]

I would just repair it with super glue.

Mine was the cap that cracked. I super glued it about 3 years ago, no more leaking.
I only use it to drain oil and pour the oil into a milk jar for recycling. Don't want to risk a mess in the trunk.

I've noticed that almost all the oil pans in stores are "Made in USA". The quality is definitely not better than stuff from Walmart.

It is probably polyethelene and greasy to boot. Virtually no glue works on that stuff. It probably could be plastic welded if it wasn't all greased up, but definitely not worth the trouble. Another vote for separate pan and jug.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

 

[signcrafter]

holds 20 gallons
I put all my drain pans in it
13 bucks
https://www.homedepot.com/p/Large-Mixing-Tub-26101/300488529?keyword=cement+trough

I use the little brother of that one.

I have one of each of these also and like them for oil changes but they **** to try and pick up to empty into a different container. You guys find any tricks to doing this? I had thought about heating up one corner with a heat gun and try to shape or form it into a spout of some sort but not sure if that would affect it and maybe when I pick it up to empty it the whole thing fold in half and oil everywhere?

I used to have a few of these 5 gallon buckets with lids on that have a pour spout built in that worked great for taking oil to the dump sites. Only difference was mint had a vent cap also which is a must. I forgot to open it a few times when filling the bucket from a drain tray and it would burp all over the place. Mine got old and had to throw them away but would love to find some more. Think they came from a friend that worked in a place that used printing ink but he doesn't work there anymore.

https://www.usplastic.com/catalog/item.aspx?itemid=43954&catid=752


Anyone use a 5 gallon gas jug for transporting oil to the recycling place? I have a bunch of them and could spare one or two for this and they seem like they might work good for this purpose. Have a screw on lid and also a funnel so should be easy to fill and empty. Seems pretty logical but never seen anyone do this so maybe I'm missing something?

 

[RAS61]

It is probably polyethelene and greasy to boot. Virtually no glue works on that stuff. It probably could be plastic welded if it wasn't all greased up, but definitely not worth the trouble. Another vote for separate pan and jug.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

Why Risk It? If that glue seal fails, especially with the flexing plastic as the oil sloshes around - Oh Boy!!! Imagine opening your trunk at the recycling center and finding several gallons of dirty oil everywhere. (hopefully you put it in the trunk and not on the floor or back seat)

 

[G1K]

Looks interesting, but the site doesn't have the dimensions of the thing anywhere, which is baffling, they don't have anything about where you can buy it, and Google shows no hits for it but the manufacturer's site. Apparently they don't want to sell them.

Any idea where to get one?

oilfiltersonline.com used to carry them, but I don't see it currently listed on their site.

I just called Geo plastics, and spoke with the same person I spoke with a few days shy of 2 years ago when looking for a replacement plug for the container-
https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=320671


She recommended oilfiltersonline or matrix racing concepts.


As mentioned, oilfiltersonline.com doesn't how it on their site. I just sent them an email to see what's up.

Matrix racing has the 11qt shown:
https://www.matrixracingproducts.com/m28-oil-drain-container/

Ryan

 

[David9726]

Why do some of these cost so much? It's plastic that may leak.

I wanted a all in one drain and transport to the recycle place. I used to just drain into a pan then refill the bottles it came in but i'd end up with 30 quart bottles and always over fill them.

 

[atikovi]

Why are you buying quart bottles of oil? The 5 quart jugs are a lot cheaper per quart.

 

[RAS61]

Why are you buying quart bottles of oil? The 5 quart jugs are a lot cheaper per quart.

And all the old oil from one change will fit in one jug for most cars, can't overfill. If you like buying oil in quarts use empty windshield washer fluid jugs for transport, they work great too, 4 fit perfectly in a plastic milk crate, won't tip over or roll around during the ride.