To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

opinion needed on a Husky box...

nicksnothereman

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2013
Messages
3,608
Location
In the Mojave
Hi folks, a new member jumping in with his first question. Yes, I did do quite a bit of searching before making this post...

Without going into to much detail about my decision making process, I've been shopping for the past couple of months for the best deal I could find on a nice rolling cabinet. I want something in the 52-56 inch range, wood top preferable, and I'd like a full width top drawer.

A friend told me about the 46 inch Husky, which has gotten some lukewarm reviews here. While checking it out online, I happened upon a super nice-looking 52 on the HD site that fits my needs. Unfortunately not one of the stores in my state stock this thing, so I can't see it in person. I would like to hear what folks have to say about it:

Husky 52 inch 11 drawer mobile workbench

Its only $398, delivery is free to the store.

I've also spotted an Excel box at Sams (once again, online only). Its $646, and Sears sells the exact same box for $200 more.

Excel Heavy Duty roller cabinet 12 drawer

It looks good, but I've never heard of the brand before. I'd also have to make my own top for it.

Has anyone here had any experience with either of these boxes?

Don't know about that cart but saw something at sears outlet that was a "heavy duty" cart and it was well built so maybe look there if you want to go that route. If they're well built (thicker steel) then it's a good option if you don't got that much stuff. Otherwise you won't do better than harbor freight honestly. It is what it is.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

ProCharger

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 2, 2015
Messages
69
Also, just looking at the Extreme Tools site, their regular 56 inch box has 100lb drawer ratings for the single roller drawers. Technically, the HF box is better then? I doubt it.
I would be curious to see one in person. The extreme box is listed at 309 pounds, the Harbor Freight is over 400. Their dimensions are near identical with the Harbor Freight being slightly deeper at 22" vs the extremes 20". I would still vote to find a used 4s if you can get one in your price range. I just can't find that unicorn in my price range or I would have one without a doubt.
 

XxToolAholicxX

Well-known member
Joined
May 28, 2014
Messages
1,449
Location
SF **** Bay Northern California
Husky boxes are very poorly made and very thin sheet metal. If I were you I would go to Harbor Freight and buy one of their boxes and don't look back. You will not regret it as they are built just as well as truck brand boxes for a whole lot less.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am a ToolAholic,Sometimes I regret it,Especially when the Toolman wont give me no credit
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
Husky boxes are very poorly made and very thin sheet metal. If you were me you would go to Harbor Freight and buy one of their boxes and don't look back. You will not regret it as they are built just as well as truck brand boxes for a whole lot less.

Fixed. Otherwise you'd be doing exactly what I'm doing, which is looking at the HF stuff and saying "meh", and then shopping for a box that fits my needs better. :D

The HF box isn't built just as well as truck brand boxes. Not even close. That has been discussed in far too many threads here and elsewhere. I'm not about to sink $3000-5000 on a truck box so I shouldn't waste our time having a discussion about this, but just for the sake of the conversation:

Truck boxes have full welded seams, not spots, stitches, or snot welds, like what I found holding the bottom panels in on these boxes.

Truck boxes have excellent casters compared to the HF boxes.

Truck boxes don't twist out of shape if you drop them on a corner. Read the reviews of the HF boxes where people have had to go through three or more boxes to find one that laid flat on the floor at the time of purchase.

Truck box drawers don't shimmy and wiggle like the HF boxes.

Truck boxes don't have burrs on the handle edges, or in other less-expected places.

Here's a big one: truck boxes have excellent warranties. Spare parts are available too. Harbor Fright? A whole 90 days to catch any problems. Plus their reviews complain about parts not being available. I've personally had broken items from that store that could have been fixed with a new part, but they don't do that. You return it and get a new item - if you're in the 90 day warranty - or live with it.

This is a minor point, but one that bugs me: Truck boxes don't have that odd, cheap latch hidden under the right side of the drawer handle. If I bought one of these HF rolling boxes this means I can never approach the box for a tool unless I have my right hand free, or else I have to cross over with my left hand and open the drawer at an awkward angle.

For my uses... The HF44 is too small. The HF56 is the exact width I want but the entire right bay of drawers is useless to me. Its not just my perception - I just showed the pic of the 56 to my woman (she was on her way between the laundry and the kitchen), and asked her what her thoughts were about it. The first thing she said was "the drawers on the right side are tiny!".

The 72 is gigantic at first glance, but when I take a good look at it, its so poorly configured I don't know where to start. Out of the 18 drawers available, 10 of them are 12 inches wide. They could have put the two outboard bays together and given me at least three 24 inch drawers, and rearranged the rest to accommodate that. Then it would be usable to me. It seems that they just wanted to cram as many drawers in there so they could get the people who equate "number of drawers" with "with this box I now magically have the skills to build a Death Star in my garage". Also - no center casters? Really? The better box builders put center casters in starting with their 56 inch boxes.


Plus all of them are a hideous red color. Yes I could paint them and void that outstanding 90 day warranty, or I could wrap them in vinyl. But for $799 (on sale from $1199!!!!) I should get a box that appeals to me without having to do customization.

HF may be a great "deal", if you put cost at the top of the scale, but it pales in comparison to the big three. I can't justify even the used price around my neck of the woods for one of those truck boxes, so I have to hunt for a good value that meets my needs.
 
Last edited:

1982fxr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2012
Messages
10,011
Location
Phoenix
Husky boxes are very poorly made and very thin sheet metal. If I were you I would go to Harbor Freight and buy one of their boxes and don't look back. You will not regret it as they are built just as well as truck brand boxes for a whole lot less.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am a ToolAholic,Sometimes I regret it,Especially when the Toolman wont give me no credit

please put the crack pipe down:3gears:
 

AceofSpad3s

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 1, 2014
Messages
1,808
Husky boxes are very poorly made and very thin sheet metal. If I were you I would go to Harbor Freight and buy one of their boxes and don't look back. You will not regret it as they are built just as well as truck brand boxes for a whole lot less.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am a ToolAholic,Sometimes I regret it,Especially when the Toolman wont give me no credit

I like US general as much as the next guy, but jesus tapdancing christ saying they are just as good as truck brands quality wise is nuts.
 

stikman56

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2014
Messages
3,127
I will say though, if the 52" is like people are saying it is, and not like that 40" POS they were selling, then it's a very good deal at that price. I'd consider that for a home box in a minute, and it's the cheapest price for a combo of that size I have ever seen. It would be enough for the average guy, without a doubt. Seriously though, that 40" thing was a total toy. Thinnest, lightest tool box I've ever seen. I have a co-worker who bought one and brought it to work. Why?.... Because he so very cheap. He treats it like fine china, because he knows how lightly it's made. Strange how there's such a quality difference in the same brand of boxes from the same box store.
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
Strange how there's such a quality difference in the same brand of boxes from the same box store.

On the surface, yeah, because innately we forget that these are boxes made by a contract manufacturer and not the retail store. One brand might have several different price points with each price point being made by a different contractor.

Doing a search for Waterloo earlier today, I found that they make a lot of boxes. They make sturdy DIY/Home boxes, they make enthusiast stuff and they make pro stuff. They also, apparently, make cheap **** for brands like Craftsman, Husky, Dewalt, and others. The point is, they'll make what they're paid to make.

I remember looking at some tools at an expo about 15 years ago. They were completely perfect in every detail. Probably the best I'd ever seen in that category. On the back... Made in China. My ingrained knee-jerk xenophobia caused me to nearly fling the pieces back on the table like they were venomous spiders. Then I took another look. Perfect machining, the right steel, even the handles were flawless. That was when the proverbial light went on for me regarding imports, especially Chinese.

The Chinese factories make exactly what they are told to make. No more, no less. Tell them to make a turd of a certain color and length and taper, they'll do exactly what you want. Just don't blame them for making a piece of **** to spec. :D

So, I bought two, just in case one broke. Neither did. They are till this day some of my most prized pieces, and they rival German and Italian machining in their perfection.

So back to my point, which was the answer to your observation; HD probably delivers a list of features and a price point to their contractor, who in turn tries their best to satisfy their contract while making the box as cheaply as possible.

Its unfortunate that no HD store will stock the Husky 52/11 but they'll carry the 52/9 for sales. Its also unfortunate that Harbor Freight no longer offers any of their bottom boxes in black onyx, even though one shows up in their ad under a black onyx top box, the only black box they still offer. If they did that, and fixed a few other things (the casters, the finish, the drawer shimmy, etc), I'd reconsider their offerings.
 
Last edited:

bobemmerich

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
1,611
Location
Middletown, Ct.
I will say though, if the 52" is like people are saying it is, and not like that 40" POS they were selling, then it's a very good deal at that price. I'd consider that for a home box in a minute, and it's the cheapest price for a combo of that size I have ever seen. It would be enough for the average guy, without a doubt. Seriously though, that 40" thing was a total toy. Thinnest, lightest tool box I've ever seen. I have a co-worker who bought one and brought it to work. Why?.... Because he so very cheap. He treats it like fine china, because he knows how lightly it's made. Strange how there's such a quality difference in the same brand of boxes from the same box store.

^^True!^^ I was looking at the 40" combo until i saw it in person. Much more flimsy construction than the 52" I had. And the drawers are only 12" deep!
I can only advise to get what's right for you. If you want the Husky, get it. To me it seems like a lot of box for the $$.
 

slomatt

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2010
Messages
63
Location
Bay Area, CA
Coincidentally, I also ordered a Husky 52/11 workbench yesterday. Ideally I would have bought a used professional level box, but nothing has shown up locally for a reasonable price.

I ruled out the HF 44" because the 16.5" drawers are too shallow, and I ruled out the 56" because it felt a bit flimsy and I want a full-width top drawer. I also don't like the drawer latches on my HF tool cart and want to avoid those on a tool bench.

The Husky 52/11 has great reviews on homedepot.com and the 22" depth and full width top drawer appeal to me. As Spider Curry mentioned the problem is that this seems to be an online-only item which is not visible in stores, and there is limited information on the interweb from people who have bought this box.

After thinking about it for a week or two I ordered the workbench yesterday and had it shipped to my local store. According to HD customer support I can check it out at the store before taking it home, and return it on the spot if it doesn't meet expectations.

So, the box should arrive sometime next week. I'll post up a review and photos when I have time.

- Matt
 

lilcraigford

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2014
Messages
348
Location
Portland, ME
I'll be interested to hear your feedback. My box (described earlier in the thread) really turned me off from Husky. It'd be great to hear that, with discretion, you can still get a decent product from them!
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
the Husky box has arrived

I received my new 52/11 box this past Wednesday, but I've only just started loading it up and organizing my tools. This Husky chest is the beginning of my efforts to get my garage set up for working on my vehicles.


Previously, I had three full sections of Edsal shelf units (24"x48"x72H) which were great for long term storage but not great to work out of. I've torn down the first two shelf units and I'm still moving things around. The Husky has a great, very usable drawer layout that has taken every tool I possess and still has room left. Once I get some proper wrench holders and toss out the plastic cases from my CM and GearWrench sets I'll free up room so I can buy more tools.

Even with all the stuff stacked on the floor in my single bay shop space at my house, its looking better. Once I get things set up a bit better I'll provide some pics.



Initial observations:


- made in Vietnam, not China

- the wood top is amazing, really really nice. Its almost furniture quality. I have to get some kind of rubber sheet or something to protect it.

- the casters bolt on without too much trouble. A GearWrench worked on three of the four bolts for each caster, and my Wera Zyklop 3/8 ratchet took care of the remaining bolt

- the drawer detents require a VERY firm push to shut the drawer. I found that it eased up a bit when I loaded each drawer.

- the finish is not glossy, but not dull either. Its allegedly powder coat but if it is I'd say its the thinnest powder coating I've ever seen. Its ice milk compared to the ice cream you'd see on a truck box, if that makes sense.

- the packaging was very sturdy, a heavy gauge box lined with slab and corner styro, banded to a pallet. (Save it all - if you ever need to ship anything UPS/Fedex/Postal, you'll have enough packing material for the foreseeable future.) Not a mark on the box, nothing wrong with any part of the finish or drawer slides, and no parts missing. The entire unit was enclosed in a plastic bag, which makes a cheap and convenient cloak for the cabinet until you can get a decent one made/bought.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
Unfortunately, no. The garage is so cluttered while I'm in this transition phase that I can't even back up enough to get a decent pic. Give me a couple of days so I can do a proper set of shots and good review.

In the meantime... I need to get that last Edsal out of there, and 3 of the 5 shelves are full of chems. Rattle cans, detailing supplies, gallons of house paint, etc. I need to come up with a decent set of wall-mounted shelves 12 inches deep or less, maybe 3 feet high, and up to 10 feet wide. Any ideas? :D
 

mrvm

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
3,839
Location
PA
For those interested:

$298.00 / each
Visit or call your local Home Depot store to confirm availability.
Item must be purchased in store.

OUT OF STOCK ONLINE
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
Yup, I forgot to mention that. The day after I took the box home, the friend who helped me get it home was impressed enough with it that he decided to order two of these boxes for himself. He told me the price had dropped and they were out of stock.

I called HD for him and found that they weren't discontinued - they're on backorder. They will be back within a month. I also took advantage of the price guarantee and got the difference refunded. So far, HD is impressing me. Their customer service has rebounded nicely from their dark days a few years back.

I may buy a second one of these. I like this one that much. I was ready to spend $1500 on a Matco 4S, and while I may do that some day I just can't beat the value on this box.
 

mrvm

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
3,839
Location
PA
Yup, I forgot to mention that. The day after I took the box home, the friend who helped me get it home was impressed enough with it that he decided to order two of these boxes for himself. He told me the price had dropped and they were out of stock.

I called HD for him and found that they weren't discontinued - they're on backorder. They will be back within a month. I also took advantage of the price guarantee and got the difference refunded. So far, HD is impressing me. Their customer service has rebounded nicely from their dark days a few years back.

I may buy a second one of these. I like this one that much. I was ready to spend $1500 on a Matco 4S, and while I may do that some day I just can't beat the value on this box.

Noticed they were out of stock online last week. Thats good to know that these Husky work benches may be back, especially at 298. Never knew they made a deeper than 18" Husky box so thanks for posting. Each generation of black Husky tool boxes have seen some improvements in drawer strength and metal stiffening folds/bends. The early versions of the black Husky tool boxes did not make a good impression.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

s2ked

Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2015
Messages
9
Location
socal
Hi folks, a new member jumping in with his first question. Yes, I did do quite a bit of searching before making this post...

Without going into to much detail about my decision making process, I've been shopping for the past couple of months for the best deal I could find on a nice rolling cabinet. I want something in the 52-56 inch range, wood top preferable, and I'd like a full width top drawer.

A friend told me about the 46 inch Husky, which has gotten some lukewarm reviews here. While checking it out online, I happened upon a super nice-looking 52 on the HD site that fits my needs. Unfortunately not one of the stores in my state stock this thing, so I can't see it in person. I would like to hear what folks have to say about it:

Husky 52 inch 11 drawer mobile workbench

Its only $398, delivery is free to the store.

I've also spotted an Excel box at Sams (once again, online only). Its $646, and Sears sells the exact same box for $200 more.

Excel Heavy Duty roller cabinet 12 drawer

It looks good, but I've never heard of the brand before. I'd also have to make my own top for it.

Has anyone here had any experience with either of these boxes?

I was looking into purchasing the same box but ultimately got the 41 inch 16 drawer. I did not like the wood top and for 498, you get a lot more room!
20150224_173355.jpg

heres the husky box i ended up getting, dont mind the cornwell badge lol. The leds i added on my own.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
That is a very nice column. I looked at it when I was shopping but found it too shallow for my needs, and there's no work surface. Adding a second 52/11 to my garage will give me over 8 feet of work surface while giving me plenty of room to add new tools.
 

ninjamunky85

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 22, 2015
Messages
63
I like that 41" 16 drawer combo, looks nice. I know the general consensus on this forum is that the Husky boxes are ****, but I've been happy with mine so far.

I've only had mine for a few months so I haven't used it a lot yet but I think they should be fine for the average weekend warrior. Definitely not a pro box but for the price I think they are a good value.

Here's my 46", a few weeks after I bought it I added the 26" top box.



I've got a decent amount of weight in the full length drawer and it seems to handle it just fine. Would be nice if it had four slides like the HF one though.

 

stage20

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 5, 2013
Messages
3,722
Location
pcola FL
LOL at the cornwell badge. would look more genuine if you cleaned off those cheap ball bearing stickers.
 

mrvm

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
3,839
Location
PA
FYi: the 52 in. 11-Drawer Mobile Workbench is back for online ordering. Not to be mistaken for lesser Huskys, this one is 52 x 38 x 22 (22" depth) and the price dropped to $298

Model # HOTC5211B1QBD Internet # 204765860

8980e8fa-ead7-4b54-b5fa-2b5ba4d70d4b_400.jpg

aef6b677-8600-4b13-80b7-9306eb2bec80_400.jpg

p.s.: spider curry, any quick review of your Husky 11-drawer work bench? Interested in information of the overall frame construction, welds and caster mounting area.

Update: unavailable again on 3/14/15@1800
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
p.s.: spider curry, any quick review of your Husky 11-drawer work bench? Interested in information of the overall frame construction, welds and caster mounting area.

My work schedule has been extremely demanding so I haven't even had much daylight time in my garage in the 9 days since I got the box home, and after 12 hour days, not much desire to approach anything in the garage after dark. I've been whittling down the debris, including stacks of tires and wheels, sorting through the remaining boxes of hardware and tools, and just trying to regain some sanity.

I will say that every single tool I own - as far as mechanics tools - is now inside this box. It took every wrench, every socket, diagnostic tools, even my Comp Cams degree kit. And I didn't have to take anything out of their boxes. My Craftsman combination wrench sets are sitting there taking up a lot of room in their hardshell cases. I still have room left.

The finish is decent, and will probably look better once I get a coat of some wax or whatever on it for protection. I have a huge selection of various car waxes and polishes that I'll try out soon.

The drawers slides nicely, the lone exception being the top drawer, which is slightly notchy within a couple of inches of full closure. I'm figuring it just has to break in a bit,.

I still can't get over how good the thing looks, especially the top. Give me till Sunday and I'll get some pics posted.
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
I forgot to ask - can anyone recommend some decent socket trays and combination wrench racks? I currently have Craftsman socket trees which are good for a tool box but not as convenient for a big drawer. I'd prefer to simply pick up my socket off a tray rather than have to grab the tree and hold it while pulling off a socket. Likewise, for wrenches I'd like to have them all laid out in some nice holders instead of these hardshell cases.

No Harbor Fright pieces, please.
 

slomatt

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2010
Messages
63
Location
Bay Area, CA
My workbench was delivered to the local Home Depot last week and I picked it up on friday. In our area it's a hassle to dispose of Styrofoam because it cannot be recycled, so I ended up unpacking the workbench at Home Depot and leaving the packaging materials there (with their ok of course). As mentioned earlier in this thread the packaging is quite impressive with over an inch of Styrofoam on all sides. The workbench fit in the back of my 4runner, but it took 4 of us to lift it in there. When I got home I removed most of the drawers and then a friend and I were able to lift it out.

I'm really impressed with the quality, especially for $299. In my opinion it seems as well built as my HF rolling cart and the 56" HF tool chest I checked out at the store, but of course the price is much lower. The wood top is flawless, and overall the powder coating is well done, though I did find one small ding (1/8") and a place on the side where there is some touch up paint, but again we're talking $299 here so I'm not concerned. The full-width top drawer and the two deep bottom drawers have rolled edges, the rest of the drawers do not. The slides all work well, it takes a little bit of a tug to get the drawers past the indents but that should loosen up quickly. Structurally it is well built, the only negative I found is that the top of the support for the center column of sliders flexes a bit. Since I had the drawers out I screwed in a wood brace for peace of mind.

Here are some photos.

The workbench in the back of my 4runner.
IMG_2385.jpg


I'm going to put this against a wall and will not be using the castors, so I added an aluminum railing around the back to prevent things from rolling off and getting lost.
IMG_8130.jpg


With all the drawers out it's pretty easy to move the bench around. Here you can see the wood insert I added between the two pieces of sheet metal that support the center slides. The top ~3" of metal was unsupported, so I thew this in quickly while the drawers were out.
IMG_8131.jpg


The sliders are of good quality and are held in place with rivets.
IMG_8132.jpg


IMG_8133.jpg


IMG_8134.jpg


The workbench comes with a nice set of drawer liners that are cut to fit.
IMG_8137.jpg


Here is the Husky 52" workbench next to my HF rolling cart. I put the workbench on a 12" tall stand to make it easier to reach all the drawers. The stand is made out of scrap wood I had around with a poplar face frame. When I have time I'll make two drawers for it.
IMG_8138.jpg


The short middle drawers have single slides and do not have rolled top edges.
IMG_8139.jpg


The bottom drawers have double slides and do have rolled top edges.
IMG_8140.jpg


The top drawer has single slides and rolled top edges. That is a 24" framing square in there for scale, this workbench has a ton of room.
IMG_8141.jpg


So far I'm really happy with this product. Over the next few days I'll migrate my tools over and see how it holds up with some weight in the drawers. Let me know if you'd like any additional details or photos.

- Matt
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
I finally got my pics taken but you posted first...

Nice work on the drawer base, I never thought of doing that. Still, I like mine being mobile. When I get all my shelves and wall cabinets built and hung up, I won't have very much on the floor so I'll be able to keep the garage clean much more easily.

Did your carton show Vietnam or China as the COO?
 

slomatt

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2010
Messages
63
Location
Bay Area, CA
I finally got my pics taken but you posted first...

Nice work on the drawer base, I never thought of doing that. Still, I like mine being mobile. When I get all my shelves and wall cabinets built and hung up, I won't have very much on the floor so I'll be able to keep the garage clean much more easily.

Did your carton show Vietnam or China as the COO?

Unfortunately I didn't look that closely at the packaging before leaving it at Home Depot. I've looked on the work bench and don't see any marked COO.

- Matt
 

mrvm

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
3,839
Location
PA
So far I'm really happy with this product. Over the next few days I'll migrate my tools over and see how it holds up with some weight in the drawers. Let me know if you'd like any additional details or photos

Thanks Matt for the pics and review of the 11-drawer Husky work bench. Great idea using a raised platform to raise the unit to a more comfortable level. Overall structure of the work bench looks great and shows Husky offers a lot of work bench for the $
 

99_xc600

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
176
I just picked up the 52" combo chest this past weekend. (Vietnam Version). My initial impressions are spot on with what you mentioned.

As far as the stiff detents, I sprayed down all of the sliders with some dry lube and it made a huge difference in reducing the effort in the detents. It seems that the rails are shipped with a coating of cosmoline or something. :)

http://www.homedepot.com/p/Blaster-5-5-oz-Graphite-Dry-Lubricant-8-GS/202597501



 

hancock1701

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
187
Location
Orange, CA
I was watching this thread and decided to get this 52/11 Husky box as well. Had it shipped to store, took about 5 days, got it today. My first impression is that it' doesn't feel extremely heavy duty or anything like that, but it's very sturdy and will very likely last through anything I need it to. A couple things about this box that got me compared to other popular, similarly priced boxes (HF 44) are the color, black, and depth (22"). I was able to fit my Mountain Double Flex Ratcheting set with tray in that direction with no problem. At least now I have a reason to buy more tools to fill my not-yet-full box without feeling guilty. Here're some pictures!
 

Attachments

  • IMAG0339.jpg
    IMAG0339.jpg
    144.1 KB · Views: 86
  • IMAG0344.jpg
    IMAG0344.jpg
    139 KB · Views: 88
  • IMAG0345.jpg
    IMAG0345.jpg
    137 KB · Views: 77
  • IMAG0346.jpg
    IMAG0346.jpg
    157.5 KB · Views: 106
  • IMAG0348.jpg
    IMAG0348.jpg
    155.6 KB · Views: 110
  • IMAG0350.jpg
    IMAG0350.jpg
    150.5 KB · Views: 89
  • IMAG0358.jpg
    IMAG0358.jpg
    148.8 KB · Views: 85

hancock1701

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Messages
187
Location
Orange, CA
More pictures!
 

Attachments

  • IMAG0351.jpg
    IMAG0351.jpg
    149.5 KB · Views: 59
  • IMAG0352.jpg
    IMAG0352.jpg
    147 KB · Views: 54
  • IMAG0353.jpg
    IMAG0353.jpg
    151.1 KB · Views: 60
  • IMAG0354.jpg
    IMAG0354.jpg
    148.5 KB · Views: 68
  • IMAG0355.jpg
    IMAG0355.jpg
    146.1 KB · Views: 55
  • IMAG0356.jpg
    IMAG0356.jpg
    146.9 KB · Views: 56
  • IMAG0357.jpg
    IMAG0357.jpg
    144.7 KB · Views: 54

PCO6

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 25, 2008
Messages
4,573
Location
Newmarket, Ontario
I've owned this Husky box for about 8 years and I have no complaints. It has good capacity and the drawers work fine. It stays in one place - not sure if I'd want to be moving it around a lot. It's no better or worse than some of the other boxes I own (International, Waterloo, Craftsman). I do like my Beach and Snap-on boxes better but the Husky box does all I ask of it.

View media item 37495
 

michiganman18

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
174
I bought the husky one because I have a very limited depth requirement and wanted taller rather than deeper for a spare box. I had low expectations and even for my low expectations its still a bit flimsier than I would like. I would listen to the general consensus of everyone on here. Look and strongly consider the HF ones (and thats rare coming from me) and then follow logic and reason.
 
OP
S

Spider Curry

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 5, 2015
Messages
103
Location
Florida
I bought the husky one because I have a very limited depth requirement and wanted taller rather than deeper for a spare box. I had low expectations and even for my low expectations its still a bit flimsier than I would like. I would listen to the general consensus of everyone on here. Look and strongly consider the HF ones (and thats rare coming from me) and then follow logic and reason.

Wait... you bought the Husky one because you wanted taller rather than deeper? Are you talking about the same box I describe in the beginning of this thread? At 22 inches deep, this is one of the deeper boxes available to the casual mechanic. I think its an inch or two deeper than the Harbor Freight boxes. The 52/11 is also among the shortest boxes available. I think mine topped out under 39 inches after I put it on wheels. It sounds to me like you're talking about a different Husky. They have three different 52 inch benches available, and two of them are very cheap.

About two weeks ago I took a trip to Harbor Fright with a mechanic friend, the same guy I mentioned in my earliest posts that doesn't like his Husky box. He spent quite a bit of time pawing at the HF boxes and his conclusion could be summed up as "joke". The drawer layout, especially on the biggest box, was completely useless to him. He felt the welds were subpar. He regressed back to his childhood and played with the drawer shimmy on the biggest bench for quite a while. His major complaint was with the drawer latches.
 

michiganman18

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
174
I did not articulate very well. In one application of that box I wanted something that overall box depth was narrow and not the drawers but the actual box bc garage space is very limited and I didn't want a tool box that sticks way out into the room. I was speaking more in general of the huskys that they are pretty cheap even for my light duty use in this application. Taller overall box rather than just a bench. The hf ones were too deep amd took too much space. Think shelf vs counter. Any way not the point. Point: my experience is they are flimsy and I'd go hf for a budget box if space allowd
 

Ponchoguy

Banned
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
3,399
Husky boxes were in the past made in Canada by Stanleyworks and they were excellent. I got a floor model several years ago and they gladly sent me the missing parts, including locks and keys at no charge by calling the customer service number.

SW no longer makes the Husky boxes. They are Geelong (spelling??) or something like that and typically made in China. I do think on some models I thought I saw assembled in the USA though??
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom