Pick One: T-handles vs. Long Socket Bits

[Can I try?]

I've encountered an application where I need to work with Torx fasteners recessed in narrow holes. My round shank Torx screwdrivers work fine for removal, but for reinstallation I can't get the torque needed on the fastener without chewing up the driver shank with pliers.

So, it seems I have an excuse to grow the tool collection! Should I get t-handle drivers, or long socket bits? I don't have either currently, Torx or hex. I can only justify buying one or the other since they're so near in functionality. I'd prefer to buy a set rather than singles

T-handles seem like they'd offer comfort and convenience of use. Socket bits seem like they'd offer versatility in the use of drive tools, including torque wrenches.

For t-handles, I am considering Bondhus or Wiha. For long socket bits, I am considering Bondhus, SK, or Koken. Although I do earn my living with tools, this purchase will primarily be for frequent diy use. When tool buying I consider quality first, brand second. I can't justify the expense of Snap On. I prefer to support tool companies that manufacture in their home country. That's why I didn't mention Husky, Gearwrench, etc.

Do you have hands-on experience with these tools? Which would you choose?

 

[BottomLineReviews]

I would buy one of each in your most common size, and try them both out. Personally, I would get the socket bits though more torque, and can be used with a variety of ratchets (or impact drivers)

 

[Ainsley]

If you can get enough torque for removal with a screwdriver I'd go with the t-handles. They'll be faster than using a ratchet with a square drive bit... Unless you can use a cordless impact wrench to speed the whole process up, then go with the socket bits.

 

[raiderhillbilly]

All Wiha tools that i have are very nice. Bondhus are good too. I would prefer the T handle over the socket bits. They are lightweight and usually cheaper. Those socket replacement bits are very expensive. On the other hand, you can use the socket bits with a torque wrench if needed.

 

[ToolmakerCT]

I have both hex t handles and long sockets. Both have their place but I reach for the t handles first if I have the room. I have Eklind Bondhus and Whia at work and each one will serve you well and are all quite affordable.

Anothor option would be something like the Williams ratchting t handle and a 1/4 or 3/8 drive bit socket with your bits of choice.