Re: ~ Plomb tool picture thread - show your stuff!
The question was is it wrong of me to put a buffing wheel to this plomb wrench
Actually, doing a very high quality of polishing on wrenches and other small tools was an 'old-timers' tradition, amongst machine folk generally, and, to some lesser extent, amongst automotive mechanics.
It may be that their motives varied to some extent, with some expressing a 'pride of ownership' and others, particularly small shop owners in the tooling field, wishing to impress clients and source-inspectors with an elegant display of tooling, such as racked sets of wrenches.
A significant percentage of automotive mechanics, even today, will invest very large amounts of $$$$$ in sets of the highly-polished and chromed 'Snap-On' wrenches. These, of course, are no more effective at turning a fastener than are plain unpolished, unplated wrenches, yet are very much a 'pride of ownership' display of 'mechanics' jewellery'.
As a generality, nickel or chrome plating would be considered 'cheap glitter' by the old machinists and toolmakers, who appreciated a 'high finish' in steel, and, of course, knew to keep polished surfaces from rusting. This is purely a particular aesthetic tradition, to be sure, and, rarely, one might see tooling which had been well-polished and then nickel-plated.
As to whether its 'wrong' to polish one's wrenches, well, if one chooses to develop the skill set involved in doing it well, its certainly no worse a form of amusement than might be, for example, knocking a little ball around a golf course, or shooting down utterly inedible clay pigeons. (shooting down tasty edible birds is a practical venture, on the other hand)
I have some small number of wrenches and other small tools which I've polished, one time and another, really just for amusement. It is, for me, a sort of 'soothing' pastime to work the part, or tool, through the various grits of abrasives, whilst carefully maintaining the flats and radii. Any good steel will eventually come to the old-style 'lime-polish' with an accurately reflective surface, if one has the skill and patience to do it.
Whether its 'worth the time and effort' to do aesthetic work on relatively simple and common basic tools is, of course, an intensely personal choice. If you enjoy doing it, and find some enjoyment in 'pride of ownership' of the finished product, that's really all that matters......well, to me, anyway.... : )
It occurs to me that you may be asking regarding 'preserving originality' as a 'collector's issue'. Well, 'nuts'.......some tools may have historical value, to be sure, if owned by, say, Henry Ford or John Browning, and should be carefully preserved as historical artifact.
As to such as common wrenches, well, there are plenty to go around....if some wish to collect them as the stamp collectors collect stamps, that's their choice, if others wish to enjoy polishing them, or to just turn fasteners with them, that's an equally valid choice.
cheers
Carla