Only need 3 wires, you will need to put in separate grounding rod(s) out at the new building. You need 2 hots and a neutral from your meter. I just did this same setup for my shop. From my meter i ran into a 200 amp square D disconnect box. From there i ran 120 ' of 2" conduit out to the shop and put in a 200 amp square D breaker box. I drove 2 10' long grounding rods in the ground and bonded one to the other and ran #4 solid copper in its own conduit into the breaker box. I then ran 2 runs of 4/0 wire and 1 2/0 wire. My 4/0 are my two hot leads for 220 and the 2/0 is neutral back to the grid and the separate ground rods and #4 copper is the new mechanical ground. I also weld but am only on a 100 amp for the welder but also run a 7.5 hp quincy compressor and plenty of light and other equipment and haven't had any issues at all. My main house feeder is 4/0 wire as well.
What is your location? NEC code only requires 8' 1/2" rods and max #6cu for the GEC and can be run unprotected as long as it follows the contour of the building(no conduit needed). And its 3 wires to the first disconnect and then 4 after that!
My understanding is the service from the meter to the first disconnect box can be 3 conductors, but from the first disconnect box to the breaker panel it should be 4 conductors. The neutral and ground bonding is done in the disconnect box. I forget the details on this, but this is what I'm thinking.
That's how I understand it as well and how I've wired this scenario before. 3 wires to first disconnect, 4 wires after that!
Code wise, a detached garage or shop should not be bonded to your homes ground. You can bond your disconnect by the meter with your homes ground but you cannot bond a detached building to a home. The shortest path to ground will always be taken, so if your building is 100 feet from your home and you bonded it to your home then the extra distance could be an issue. Code says detached garages or shops need its "own" 10' rod (actually says to use 2 or more) and space them 8' apart i do believe and bond one to the other and then run into your new panel. This way in a shortage or anything then the breaker will sense the short and trip much faster then if it was bonded 100' away or so. Plus you cannot have a ground wire in the same conduit as your power feeds.
So much wrong here aside from it not being US code!
First bold text(I'm too lazy tonight to copy and paste the html code for quotes over and over): you contradicted yourself!
2nd: US code is 2 8' rods and spaced 6' apart
3rd: Ground rods have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with a breaker tripping to clear/interrupt line to line shorts! And can u give us a code cite that says an EGC(aka ground wire) can not run in the same conduit as the hot legs? Never heard of this! Many SE cables have the EGC bundled with the hot legs!
(U just gotta love the novices!)
And so starts another debate of the NEC "lawyers".
Pass the popcorn.
Remember, in the end, the only person you have to satisfy is the local inspector !
LMAO
