To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Quality made, small, portable, hydraulic, floor jacks

diyer999

Banned
Joined
Jul 16, 2010
Messages
84
Hello guys, does anyone know of any quality made, small portable, hydraulic, floor jacks, and if possible affordable, made in either the USA, Canada, Europe or Japan? Below are the details of my reasons and issues about these jacks if you care to read it.

I decided to get one of these for a few reasons: 1) To avoid having to wait on AAA if I get a flat tire. 2) To avoid having to use the scissors jacks that come with vehicles. 3) To do some current work on a car needing its brakes bleed before it can be moved, and there is virtually no other choice. I have a sedan sitting in front of my house on a slight incline, front of vehicle pointing downward, (weight all toward the front). A small portable jack is the quickest and easiest solution. My bottle jacks either dont fit or can tip over.

Previously, I had purchased one of those small aluminum racing jacks from HF (Harbor Freight). It was lightweight for a floor jack and it was fairly small. But, after I checked the hydraulic oil level and bled the air out, as I started to work the jack, to make sure it worked before using it, I heard a screeching sound and it started leaking oil. I found a small ball bearing blew out the back of the jack. Of course, I returned it. So, now I was one of the many people that got a lemon jack. Btw, these all look identical except for color, brand name, etc. And I confirmed that from research and talking to mfrs. Btw, the tool truck versions are the same exact thing. They are all made in China. I read tens upon tens of bad reviews about these jacks, warning potential buyers to avoid them. I don't know why so many of them fail, other than the obvious, China is not a country of craftsman, and I think that they just pump these out of their factories, without any regard to exact tolerances and machining. But the odd thing is there are way more good reviews than bad. However, some of them are suspicious, like shills. Some bad reviews mentioned the frame twisting), but that's a separate issue.

I used a bottle jack a few days ago to rotate the wheels, but it eventually failed. The only thing I found that might work, is two possible Craftsman jacks from Sears, only a few pounds heavier than the aluminum racing jacks. Both have steel frames (maybe its wise to avoid all aluminum framed jacks -- but I do like the light weight). The one is a 2 1/4 ton, and the other a 2 1/2 ton. The 2 1/4 comes in a case (nice feature for storage in my trunk). Looking at the design the 2 1/2 ton jack, just looks more stable. however, both jacks have plenty of bad reviews, just like the HF jacks.

For the bad reviews, there seemed to be only two issues: the frames twisting or the jacks not working at all. I only found one other guy that had the screeching sound and subsequent leaking oil.

So, back to square one, does anyone know of a brand or model with the features I want without a high failure rate?

For any replies thank you in advance.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Coach James

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 24, 2005
Messages
8,933
Location
Sandhills of North Carolina
I picked up a trolley jack from Auto Zone to support the control arms when I changed ball joints. I also used it once to change a tire with no trouble. When I do brakes, I put the vehicle on jack stands, never just on any type of jack.

Coach
 

gdocktor3

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2015
Messages
5,419
Location
Connecticut
This meets your criteria, minus the COO, I think. It's Husky from Home Depot. I picked one up for like $20 because of broken box a few years ago. I've used it to jack my 1993 F250 diesel more than once to do tire change. I also use it as a back up jack when doing jobs on suspension, fuel tanks, etc. Stuff that needs to be lifted/lowered, while the other jack is being used. For the price, it is a perfect jack to use for side of the road tire changes. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Husky-2-1-2-Ton-5-000-lb-Low-Profile-Jack-HD7024A/204079069

The reviews aren't great, but you've got to realize this isn't a jack that is intended to be used regularly lifting heavy cars and trucks. I treat it like a scissor jack and use it for emergencies and small jobs. Only a buffoon would buy a jack like this with intensions of using it as a full time service/repair tool.
 
Last edited:

T45

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2014
Messages
3,253
> Originally Posted by thecj3man
> The Milwaukee model 20 is a nice made in the USA jack.

Model 20 and the Hein Werner 2T jacks are 300-400 dollars and weigh 90 pounds. They are service jacks, niether small nor light. That doesn't mean you shouldn't consider them. Its just that you need to understand the nature of these things.

(The HF daytona jack is similar in size and $180-200 if that style is appealing but the price is not.)
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

paulsomlo

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
3,904
Location
Northern Colorado
The Milwaukee model 20 weighs about 70 lbs.

What you're looking for, really doesn't exist. If you want high quality USA, you're going to get large and heavy. If you want small and portable, to keep in the trunk for emergencies, you're stuck with China. One thing to think about; some jacks have problems lifting in very cold weather - not what you're after when you're stranded. Also, the seals tend to go bad more quickly when the jack is unused for long periods - like sitting in the trunk of your vehicle. I've thought about keeping a small floor jack in the car, but dismissed it for the above reasons.
 

redmondjp

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 25, 2014
Messages
2,318
Location
Redmond, WA
What you need is a good-quality scissors jack. I have several of them that I have collected over the past few decades.

American-made: US Jack Model SJ2

Catalog here: http://www.ohiohydraulic.com/pdfs/US JACK CATALOG.pdf

The ATD7462 is similar although I am not sure where it is made.

And for emergency use, you need WHEEL CHOCKS too - very important and I always use them when jacking up anything in my driveway.

EDIT: OK, the jacks that I have are older US-made jacks made originally for the US army - the following from a review of the ATD jack on Amazon:

"This is a shamelessly dumb Chinese clone of a circa-1960s scissor jack produced for the M151-A2 U.S. Army Jeep, which can still be obtained for a comparable price from military surplus dealers, and this is the way to go. The army jacks are real gems; the makers of this thing obviously never handled the real thing."

The army jeep scissors jacks are the good ones - look for one or more of those.
 
Last edited:
OP
D

diyer999

Banned
Joined
Jul 16, 2010
Messages
84
The Milwaukee model 20 weighs about 70 lbs.

What you're looking for, really doesn't exist. If you want high quality USA, you're going to get large and heavy. If you want small and portable, to keep in the trunk for emergencies, you're stuck with China. One thing to think about; some jacks have problems lifting in very cold weather - not what you're after when you're stranded. Also, the seals tend to go bad more quickly when the jack is unused for long periods - like sitting in the trunk of your vehicle. I've thought about keeping a small floor jack in the car, but dismissed it for the above reasons.

I had come to the same conclusion . . . BUT I wasn't sure what I concluded was correct. Figured I would starts asking around. One thing I didn't mention, trying to give a complete picture of what I was looking for, and a few reasons why, is that I have a Lincoln 93642, two ton very heavy duty jack in my garage, but that is in the back of the house and the car that needs the brakes bled is on the front of the house and there are two sets of steps on the side of the house that is too heavy and awkward to move without a helper (don't want to screw up my back). Its the kind of heavy duty jack that you only move if you must. I was thinking of strapping it to a dolly, but I still need a jack for on the road.
 
Last edited:

thor80

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 13, 2014
Messages
93
I love a good 'merican tool as much as the next guy but no options led me to a little hf unit and mine works great. I would just return them until you get a good one and never be dumb enough to get under a car supported completely by it (should never do that anyway). No reason to pay double for another brand thats the same and cant be returned as easily. I have a big arcan for big jobs but the little guy gets a lot of use on the small ones.
 

bczygan

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2009
Messages
22,002
Location
DETROIT! Arsenal of Scrappers
We keep the 1 1/2 ton HF alum. racing jack in the trunk with a couple of HF jack stands and a piece of 2x4 and a piece of 4x4. Also a 4 way wrench. Now we need a spare.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom