To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Quality Vehicle Fire Extinguisher

Grimpala

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
1,406
What's the general consensus for a decent extinguisher for vehicles that won't break the bank? I need about a half dozen for various cars(classic and new). I have one from Academy Sports for the boat, but I'm not sold that that is the best choice for a 1 ton truck or a vintage corvette.

Thanks.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Jlarson

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2015
Messages
738
Location
AZ
Amerex. Get the biggest unit you can fit too, those little dot min 2.5# units go quick especially considering most just dump it all at once.

It's funny doing a training with the 2.5s and someone dumps it in under 2 seconds and then I just go now what's your plan?

Find a local extinguisher place, ours sells refurb units at a decent cost, that's what I usually buy for ours that sit on sites.
 

4xdog

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Messages
5,632
Location
Santa Fe, NM
I use Amerex Halotron extinguishers in my vehicles, mainly because I don't want the corrosive mess of a dry powder discharge on electronics. @Jlarson is right in going as big as possible. My 2.5-lb extinguishers are probably in the barely-or-not-quite-adequate category, but they're what I have.

Zoro has the best prices I've found. Although the last one I got a few months ago was a LOT more expensive -- like twice -- the ones from a few years ago. I still couldn't find a better price, and with the right coupon it can help.

 

kabinenroller

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
908
Location
S.E. Wisconsin USA
I have two in my Comet, a small chrome unit mounted on the tunnel between the seats and an Element on the roll bar. Both within easy reach of the drivers seat. I also carry an Element in my everyday driver.
4740931F-A9AE-4452-A838-CB2373053FFA.jpeg
 

rlitman

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2010
Messages
24,688
Location
Long Island
Not the cheapest but these seem to be gaining popularity with car owners. Small, no maintenance, non toxic, low mess when used.
The Element carries no rating, and puts you dangerously close to the fire. There's no way I'd touch them.
I use Amerex Halotron extinguishers in my vehicles, mainly because I don't want the corrosive mess of a dry powder discharge on electronics. @Jlarson is right in going as big as possible. My 2.5-lb extinguishers are probably in the barely-or-not-quite-adequate category, but they're what I have.

Zoro has the best prices I've found. Although the last one I got a few months ago was a LOT more expensive -- like twice -- the ones from a few years ago. I still couldn't find a better price, and with the right coupon it can help.

Again, not the best idea.

That 2.5LB Halotron has a 0A and 2B rating. 2.5LBS of ABC dry powder has a 1A and 10B rating. So, you'd need 5 of those Halotron units to match the ability of one home kitchen disposable can on a liquid fire, and the Halotron will do NOTHING if your upholstery caught.

As for the mess, any electronics under the hood should be weather sealed, and the ash from burning plastics is FAR more corrosive than ANYTHING from an ABC drychem. Plus if you're THAT worried about it, get a Purple K drychem and simply hose off what it leaves behind.

I keep a 1A:10B:C 2.5LB drychem extinguisher in my Jeep. Yes, they're still limited in what they can do, and without a hose you need to pay attention to keep them upright to feed the siphon, but they're still several times better than anything else the same package.

In my shop (and house), I have several 3A:40B:C 5lb drychem extinguishers. A few years back, I used one to put out a fire on a neighbor's deck. It had consumed a potted plant on his deck and at least a square yard of astroturf was a burning "tar" puddle as the flames climbed his siding. 5lbs of drychem MOSTLY put it all out, but I ran home and got a second one because there was enough heat left that a vinyl gutter with some dry brush in it re-ignited. I can assure you that standing there with too little of an extinguisher is not a good feeling.
 

4xdog

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Messages
5,632
Location
Santa Fe, NM
...That 2.5LB Halotron has a 0A and 2B rating. 2.5LBS of ABC dry powder has a 1A and 10B rating. So, you'd need 5 of those Halotron units to match the ability of one home kitchen disposable can on a liquid fire, and the Halotron will do NOTHING if your upholstery caught.

As for the mess, any electronics under the hood should be weather sealed...

Good advice, @rlitman. I have 5lb dry chemical on all floors of the house and two in the garage. No argument with any of what you say about the Halotrons, except maybe for the electronics should be weather sealed part... My 1962 Triumph TR3 doesn't know the meaning of the phrase, and this is the one where I can realistically anticipate using the extinguisher. :)

i-n8Xwc8g-X3.jpg
 

reader2580

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 31, 2014
Messages
14,571
Location
Minneapolis, MN
I bought a fire extinguisher for my motorhome from a company that specializes in fire extinguishers. Places that only do fire protection seem to have better units. I think I have a five pound unit.

I know that there are a number of fires I could never stop with my extinguisher, but it could help a small fire from becoming a big fire. If I have a tire fire it isn't even hardly worth using the extinguisher as I'll never put out a tire fire once it starts unless I catch it at the very beginning. A tire fire on my motorhome is going to end badly unless you can dump water and/or foam on it within a couple of minutes. A car tire on fire isn't going to be nearly so bad.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Cairo94507

Well-known member
Joined
May 9, 2015
Messages
344
Location
Auburn, CA
I keep a 5 lb. extinguisher under the hood of my '71 914-6. If you have ever seen a car fire, those 2.5 lb. extinguishers run out pretty quick. The 5 lb. gives you a fighting chance.
 
OP
G

Grimpala

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
1,406
I bought a fire extinguisher for my motorhome from a company that specializes in fire extinguishers. Places that only do fire protection seem to have better units. I think I have a five pound unit.

I know that there are a number of fires I could never stop with my extinguisher, but it could help a small fire from becoming a big fire. If I have a tire fire it isn't even hardly worth using the extinguisher as I'll never put out a tire fire once it starts unless I catch it at the very beginning. A tire fire on my motorhome is going to end badly unless you can dump water and/or foam on it within a couple of minutes. A car tire on fire isn't going to be nearly so bad.
With the classics I'm more worried about an electrical fire and/or possibly a fuel fire, but I try to keep an eye on fuel lines and tanks with those. With the modern vehicles it's anyone's guess as to what it will be.

In the race trailer they keep 10 gal of water, buddy told me that he had a hub bearing ignite one time and the extinguisher only put out the fire, didn't remove the heat, which reignited the fire several times, ultimately lost a 53 foot trailer and its contents. So now the water is there to not only extinguish, but to remove the heat as well.
 

tez929rr

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 26, 2005
Messages
3,787
Location
Welfare, TX
With the classics I'm more worried about an electrical fire and/or possibly a fuel fire, but I try to keep an eye on fuel lines and tanks with those. With the modern vehicles it's anyone's guess as to what it will be.

In the race trailer they keep 10 gal of water, buddy told me that he had a hub bearing ignite one time and the extinguisher only put out the fire, didn't remove the heat, which reignited the fire several times, ultimately lost a 53 foot trailer and its contents. So now the water is there to not only extinguish, but to remove the heat as well.
We send a brush truck with foam to vehicle fires first but the 500 gallons of water on board are never enough to completely put it out. We follow it up with an engine with 1500 gallons and a water tender with 2000 more just in case. Most of the time we use all or most of the water on the engine.

It’s a great idea to plan ahead but don’t be surprised; even if you can suppress the fire until fire apparatus arrives you still might have a total loss.
 

infinite97

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 15, 2009
Messages
230
Location
Vancouver, WA
I keep a 2.5lb amerex in my truck. It’s small, but it fits into my emergency bag (which fits under my rear bench seat) so it works for me.

hopefully I never find out if 2.5lbs is enough.
 

Vintage Veloce

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
1,076
Location
San Diego
I carry an Element because the small size means I can keep it in the door pocket ready to go. IMO, time matters. There is a small chemical extinguisher in the trunk.
I keep a large Halotron and a giant chemical extinguisher in the garage on the wall by the door in case something happens at home.
 

bbxlr8

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
131
Location
Eastern PA
I carry an Element because the small size means I can keep it in the door pocket ready to go. IMO, time matters. There is a small chemical extinguisher in the trunk.
I keep a large Halotron and a giant chemical extinguisher in the garage on the wall by the door in case something happens at home.
This (y)

I have not used the element but was impressed by the videos.
Know it's not the same....
 

charbar

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 6, 2021
Messages
2,007
Location
Midwest
The Element looks like a neat idea and all, but how many people are going to know that it's a fire extinguisher and how to use it? Obviously I'm not talking about the person who bought it, but any random person who might need a fire extinguisher to save YOUR *** and your not able to help. Or if you are there but unable then you're wasting time trying to explain to someone what it looks like and how to run it.

Everybody knows what a normal extinguisher looks like and to pull the pin and squeeze. Seconds count when it comes to fires.
 
OP
G

Grimpala

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
1,406
We send a brush truck with foam to vehicle fires first but the 500 gallons of water on board are never enough to completely put it out. We follow it up with an engine with 1500 gallons and a water tender with 2000 more just in case. Most of the time we use all or most of the water on the engine.

It’s a great idea to plan ahead but don’t be surprised; even if you can suppress the fire until fire apparatus arrives you still might have a total loss.
My 96 Impala SS caught fire one day on the way to class way back when, the only thing that saved my *** was the 2.5# ext I had in the trunk. The ground strap shorted and melted, then caught the firewall insulation. Time was of essence there, that's what I'm looking for now, I realize that at some point it's moot, but I'd like to at least have a chance before it gets to that point. At the very least give all occupants time to get out and get away.
 

FredWanaker

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2021
Messages
1,470
Location
NorCal
kind of off the subject but on a crime show the other night they went thru a fire and the evidence freed the guy.. What they discussed I did not know and it is well advised to know it. Apparently polyester upholstery will just smoulder if a cigarette hits it. But drop a match on it and it instantly ignites. Throw water on it to put it out and it literally explodes into flame like a grease fire does when water hits it.
 

PWC Repair

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 27, 2012
Messages
3,198
Location
Arkansas
We have the Amerex 2.5# in the show cars. The key is using precisely aimed pulses. I've seen people panic too and aim AT the fire.....wrong! Aim at the BASE of the fire. That being said, I hope I never have to use one. And we have a Badger in the house.
 

rlitman

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2010
Messages
24,688
Location
Long Island
kind of off the subject but on a crime show the other night they went thru a fire and the evidence freed the guy.. What they discussed I did not know and it is well advised to know it. Apparently polyester upholstery will just smoulder if a cigarette hits it. But drop a match on it and it instantly ignites. Throw water on it to put it out and it literally explodes into flame like a grease fire does when water hits it.
I wonder how much that info is based on cigarettes from 20 years ago. Modern cigarettes (anything legally sold in the US at least) are formulated to be less likely to start upholstery fires nowadays.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom