To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Question about a Craftsman toolbox and rolling cabinet

Joined
Aug 14, 2023
Messages
23
Location
Tennessee
This vintage Craftsman model 4370 toolbox and model 43581 rolling cabinet showed up on the marketplace. They looked to be in decent condition, and had the additional benefit of being full of vintage Craftsman, Husky, and a few other hand tools. The lady selling them told me her father had been a mechanic for Ford and Studebaker at different points in his life, and also enjoyed car restoration.

I noticed the differing logos, and found stamped behind the logo on the rolling cabinet that it was made by the Advertising Metal Display Company in Chicago. It was also stamped 59, so that made it easy to find in a '59 Sears catalog. It would have been over $40 back then. No mention was made of the drawers being painted red. All it said was a gray finish. Knowing what I know about the other logo, I found it in a '55 Sears catalog, and it was around $18. Also made by Advertising Metal Display Co, and no mention of anything painted red.

The rolling cabinet had a sheet of thin masonite covering its top Unfortunately, it had been exposed to moisture at some point, and probably never got all the way dry. So, while both the cabinet and tool box appear solid, there is some rust. The toolbox itself seems to have the worst of it.

I used a razor blade to scrape some of the bubbled and rusty paint off the top of the cabinet, and I might have seen remnants of that sort of hammered gray finish that Sears used on some of their toolboxes in that era. Is it possible this may have been repainted at some point and they went with a more plain gray color, or would it have been gray from the start? I'm planning to sand and repaint both items over the weekend in order to get the rust under control. I realize it's my stuff now and if I wanted to paint it metallic flake chartreuse or something like that, it's up to me, but I'm not going to do that. I do want it to look right and be durable. I'll also cut a piece of 1/4" plywood to fit in the space where the masonite was.

All in all, I'm glad to have found these items and will enjoy being their caretaker.

Edit: I just confirmed with the man's daughter that he worked for 37 years at the Ford Motor Company Stamping Plant in Chicago Heights, Illinois.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20251125_134411.jpg
    IMG_20251125_134411.jpg
    474.5 KB · Views: 84
  • IMG_20251125_134423.jpg
    IMG_20251125_134423.jpg
    624.5 KB · Views: 83
  • IMG_20251125_134451.jpg
    IMG_20251125_134451.jpg
    763.4 KB · Views: 84
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Cruzan80

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 22, 2015
Messages
4,200
Location
Denver, CO
Yes, it was repainted. The original was a hammered silver-gray color (at least on the outside). The Crowntop boxes are fairly rare, as they were only made for two years (58-59) before they changed suppliers.
 

GatorEd

Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2016
Messages
21
This vintage Craftsman model 4370 toolbox and model 43581 rolling cabinet showed up on the marketplace. They looked to be in decent condition, and had the additional benefit of being full of vintage Craftsman, Husky, and a few other hand tools. The lady selling them told me her father had been a mechanic for Ford and Studebaker at different points in his life, and also enjoyed car restoration.

I noticed the differing logos, and found stamped behind the logo on the rolling cabinet that it was made by the Advertising Metal Display Company in Chicago. It was also stamped 59, so that made it easy to find in a '59 Sears catalog. It would have been over $40 back then. No mention was made of the drawers being painted red. All it said was a gray finish. Knowing what I know about the other logo, I found it in a '55 Sears catalog, and it was around $18. Also made by Advertising Metal Display Co, and no mention of anything painted red.

The rolling cabinet had a sheet of thin masonite covering its top Unfortunately, it had been exposed to moisture at some point, and probably never got all the way dry. So, while both the cabinet and tool box appear solid, there is some rust. The toolbox itself seems to have the worst of it.

I used a razor blade to scrape some of the bubbled and rusty paint off the top of the cabinet, and I might have seen remnants of that sort of hammered gray finish that Sears used on some of their toolboxes in that era. Is it possible this may have been repainted at some point and they went with a more plain gray color, or would it have been gray from the start? I'm planning to sand and repaint both items over the weekend in order to get the rust under control. I realize it's my stuff now and if I wanted to paint it metallic flake chartreuse or something like that, it's up to me, but I'm not going to do that. I do want it to look right and be durable. I'll also cut a piece of 1/4" plywood to fit in the space where the masonite was.

All in all, I'm glad to have found these items and will enjoy being their caretaker.

Edit: I just confirmed with the man's daughter that he worked for 37 years at the Ford Motor Company Stamping Plant in Chicago Heights, Illinois.
Nice! I picked up a similar lower cabinet at a flea market here in Florida for $5 and just figured out how to get the drawers out today. None of the videos on YouTube covered this particular type. I made a steel tool similar to a hacksaw blade but it had to be narrower. My logo is definitely from the 1950 era; however, I've never seen a Craftsman with cast iron swivel casters! I wonder if anyone on Garage Journal knows if these were ever offered on these types of cabinets?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4286.jpeg
    IMG_4286.jpeg
    713.7 KB · Views: 43
  • IMG_4289.jpeg
    IMG_4289.jpeg
    716 KB · Views: 36
  • IMG_4287.jpeg
    IMG_4287.jpeg
    542.3 KB · Views: 39

Zrxrunner

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2018
Messages
521
Location
Eastern Iowa
Don't think those cast swivel casters on the top of the box are original...to the box at least. Common on creepers or roll around shop seats tho. I have that same box, and has more common poly wheels
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

four.cycle

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
28,723
Location
Tacoma, Washington
^ I was perusing through an old "Huot" catalog last week, and they offered those steel "creeper casters" as an option on their boxes in the 50's.
1956 Huot catalog Bassick Flying Saucer creeper caster pp.jpg
1956 Huot catalog Bassick "Flying Saucer" creeper caster

Pretty sure it was "Alemite" grease guns that sent me down this rabbit hole. "Bassick" was one of the largest (if not the largest) manufacturer of casters in the world.

Bassick / Bassick Alemite Corp., Chicago, IL / inc. Feb 1923, acquired Nov 1924 by Stewart Warner Corp. / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ /

Bassick / Bassick Co., 275 Warren St., Bridgeport, CT / est. 1879 (as Samuel A. Burns Co.), inc. May 1917, merged with M. B. Schenck Company and Universal Caster & Foundry Co. 1917, acquired 1923 by Stewart Warner Corp., Chicago, IL / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ / https://mycompanies.fandom.com/wiki/Bassick_Company /

Bassick / Bassick Mfg. Co., 2660 N. Crawford Ave., Chicago, IL / est. 1919 acquired Alemite Lubrication Co. and renamed Bassick Alemite Corp. Dec 1919, renamed Alemite Mfg. Co. 1928 / grease gun / patent 1475980 Dec 4 1923 Oscar Zerk / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ /
 

1982fxr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2012
Messages
10,003
Location
Phoenix
^ I was perusing through an old "Huot" catalog last week, and they offered those steel "creeper casters" as an option on their boxes in the 50's.
1956 Huot catalog Bassick Flying Saucer creeper caster pp.jpg
1956 Huot catalog Bassick "Flying Saucer" creeper caster

Pretty sure it was "Alemite" grease guns that sent me down this rabbit hole. "Bassick" was one of the largest (if not the largest) manufacturer of casters in the world.

Bassick / Bassick Alemite Corp., Chicago, IL / inc. Feb 1923, acquired Nov 1924 by Stewart Warner Corp. / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ /

Bassick / Bassick Co., 275 Warren St., Bridgeport, CT / est. 1879 (as Samuel A. Burns Co.), inc. May 1917, merged with M. B. Schenck Company and Universal Caster & Foundry Co. 1917, acquired 1923 by Stewart Warner Corp., Chicago, IL / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ / https://mycompanies.fandom.com/wiki/Bassick_Company /

Bassick / Bassick Mfg. Co., 2660 N. Crawford Ave., Chicago, IL / est. 1919 acquired Alemite Lubrication Co. and renamed Bassick Alemite Corp. Dec 1919, renamed Alemite Mfg. Co. 1928 / grease gun / patent 1475980 Dec 4 1923 Oscar Zerk / https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/threads/alemite-zerk-bassick-hand-held-grease-guns.553024/ /
On Huots I have only seen creeper style wheels on old ones.

I've had several of these old craftsman boxes but none had creeper wheels. Just my limited experience.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom