I don't really care if my tools look dirty (I mean, sure I clean them and prefer them looking clean, but it doesn't bother me if it's dirty), and I VASTLY prefer the comfort grips. I'm generally anti-bulkiness, but the comfort-grip is only where your hand goes anyway, so I don't find it causes me any loss in utility. Maybe it's just because I have large hands though (large enough that most XL sizes gloves are too small for me).