To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Ratcheting screwdrivers: yah or naw?

Ratcheting screwdrivers? Yah or naw?

  • Yah

    Votes: 104 69.8%
  • Naw

    Votes: 45 30.2%

  • Total voters
    149

Steve_P

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 15, 2010
Messages
5,185
I pretty much have two, or more, of every tool, but no ratcheting screwdriver. Never saw the purpose over a regular driver. Ratcheting wrenches, ratchets, yes they have obvious advantages and I have plenty of them.
I also have the dewalt gyroscope cordless driver mentioned above, and it seems like it couldn't possibly work satisfactorily per the description, but it's freaking awesome. I love it when installing outlets or switches where you have an inch long screw.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Wakefield

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
5,132
Location
Arlington VA (but would like to get out to country
I'd go so far as to say I mostly hate ratcheting screwdrivers. For me they always seem to either switch direction inadvertantly or have too much drag once the screw gets loose.
I can usually spin a plain screwdriver in my fingers while maintaining enough pressure to keep it engaged.
I have used yankee screwdrivers and offset screwdrivers that work well in certain situations (like outlet covers).
Not Snap On?
 
OP
B

Badgerstate

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2020
Messages
484
Location
Columbus, OH
Interesting responses. I do have an impact driver but I dont know that I would use it in every situation. Even on the lowest setting, a 20 volt impact could be way too much power in some instances.
Im looking at either the Craftsman one that Lowes sells or the Masterforce one that Menards sells. I do like the Craftsman because it is telescoping and I like not of their because they have a quick change collet and can accept impact driver bits.
I also have a DeWalt Xtreme 12v screw driver (non impacting impact, basically) that I keep in the house but I feel like by the time I grab the DeWalt, grab a battery and use it, I could be done with a ratcheting screwdriver. Not to mention its not a tool that Im going to be using all the time, so the battery is probably going to be dead anyways.
 

BlakeTheCarGuy

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 10, 2018
Messages
9,373
Location
Roanoke Virginia
I have a few ratcheting ones one at home one at work. My home one is a Craftsman USA from the pawn shop. Haven’t had an opportunity to use it yet but I do like the handle that is similar to the Snap-on. Then at work I have my Snap-on one. I use it on dashes a lot because we aren’t allowed to use any power or air tools on interiors of vehicles due to past people damaging things. Plus you need it if you can’t fit a screw gun in a place but want to save time by ratcheting.FF1D38F0-D7C5-444B-9A1B-F76911052174.jpegE1CF1DF9-B215-4ABD-865E-E40FD35C517D.jpeg
Love the color.
 

Ton ton

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 16, 2019
Messages
4,592
Location
Page County,VA
I have a few ratcheting ones one at home one at work. My home one is a Craftsman USA from the pawn shop. Haven’t had an opportunity to use it yet but I do like the handle that is similar to the Snap-on. Then at work I have my Snap-on one. I use it on dashes a lot because we aren’t allowed to use any power or air tools on interiors of vehicles due to past people damaging things. Plus you need it if you can’t fit a screw gun in a place but want to save time by ratcheting.FF1D38F0-D7C5-444B-9A1B-F76911052174.jpegE1CF1DF9-B215-4ABD-865E-E40FD35C517D.jpeg
Love the color.
That is a nice screwdriver.
 

rkevins

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
950
Location
Central Arkansas
I carried a Kobalt at work for 5 years before (the cap broke so the bits fall out) I switched to a snap on like Blakethecarguy pictured we use them multiple times a day the snappy is a good one. The Kobalt was the one before the twin drive which is heaver
 

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
I just picked up this set at HD on Black Fri special. I mainly got it because of the longer bits alow you to get in to deeper counterbores and pockets. Secondariy the stubby adds some versatility. I wish it had more Torx in place of sq drive. Just what I run into more. I used it today and i like the feel of the tool. I have other ratcheting screw drivers and only use the ratchet feature about half of the time. It is very helpfull when you are only using one hand so you can keep downward pressure on the fastener.

 

jsaw

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 11, 2008
Messages
1,788
Location
Geneva, N.Y.
I might change my naw to a yah if the ratcheting screwdriver had an auto-shift (like a Tiburon SST) whereby it doubles the speed when there is little resistance, and reduces speed when there is heavy resistance, something like a screw-gun.....oh wait, never-mind, still a naw....
They do make them. I have one I bought off the Mac tool truck. It is called an overdriver. It has a reversible roller clutch, and a set of planetary gears. When you hold one part of the handle while you turn the other part, it gives you an overdrive. Every revolution of the handle gives 4 revolutions of the shank. It works nice and smooth, but I seldom use it since getting cordless screwdrivers and impacts

1637124357637.png
 

Citation

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2016
Messages
3,219
Location
Indy
I was indifferent until I got the Cman copy of the Snap on people liked
It was free with the other tools the previous owners left in my house... it was the best of the lot.

I've had cheap junk ones and never liked them. This one works as well as any bit driver and gives me ratcheting as an option. Win win. I would say a good one can be worth it and don't judge the concept if, like me, your experience was based on cheap ones.
 

jshillin

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
5,601
Location
PA
They definitely have a place in the toolbox. I have a couple Snap-on ratchet drivers and a couple Gearwrench sets. Look around and you can find the Gearwrench sets that have a regular handle as well as a T Handle ratchet driver with a bunch of bits.
 

VolvoRyan

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2019
Messages
1,339
Location
Kentuckiana, USA
I haven't found one I like. I usually have my other hand on a panel so if there's not enough friction on the screw, ratcheting drivers become a regular driver. So I'm a "nay". Though I do have a ratcheting "offset" bit driver thingy that is super handy.

I'll second that impact drivers and plastics don't mix.

-Ryan
 

DadsTools

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2017
Messages
1,852
Back in the day (a long time ago) when I worked on pneumatic pipe organs out in the field, mostly at churches, we had no cordless drivers. Since you crawled up inside organ chambers, you needed to carry as few tools as possible. If you needed to take off the bottom of a wind chest, you used a yankee, otherwise you'd be there all day, especially since the screws were usually long. The screwheads were always recessed inside the wood, so you needed something to reach in. In instances where the screw might be very tight in the wood, we used a ratcheting screwdriver. I had a Craftsman like the one in post #35. After leaving that job, I wanted to continue using it, but it never found the application where it was the best tool to use. If a screw came out easy, there was no need for it. If a screw was tough to get started, it had no advantage over a regular screwdriver, especially those with a square shoulder so you can put an open end wrench on it. It's more bulky and awkward compared to a regular screwdriver. There's no speed advantage to it, especially in this age of cordless tools. If I need to ratchet something out, I'll use a 1/4 ratchet with extension and a bit holder socket--it's all DIY, so I'm under no time constraint to worry about the 30 seconds it takes me to pull the 1/4 drive set out. I've used it on rare occasion just for nostalgia's sake, but in every application I've have a better tool for it in the shop. I imagine it has a better potential in the field where you have limits to what you can carry with you, or in a time constraint situation where you don't want to take the time to reach for multiple tools. But in the shop, it no longer even has a place in my screwdriver drawer.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

M6erfan

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 6, 2014
Messages
10,170
Location
'Merica!
Naw, never found them useful.

Years ago, mainly because of the hype here on GJ, I bought a S-o ratcheting screwdriver. What a waste. Large handle, bulky, and the bits roll around in the handle which I found irritating. I sold it.

I found myself using ratcheting screwdrivers mostly in the non-ratcheting position due to not enough resistance on the threads to let it actually ratchet. What's the point?

No contest, traditional screwdriver or 12v driver for me.
 
Last edited:

APEowner

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 2, 2009
Messages
4,164
Location
Sunny, New Mexico
I like drivers with interchangeable bits in places where I don't have a complete tool box but I never found the ability to ratchet useful at all. If the screw is loose I just spin the shank with my fingers to spin it in or out and if it's turning too hard for that I just loosen my grip when I'm turning my hand in the ratchet direction.
 

Jim_No_Garage

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Messages
3,315
Location
Millington NJ
I have the Williams version of the Snap-On ratcheting screwdriver and like it a lot. I don't like the "bits in the cap" thing but it's great otherwise. I reach for it almost every time I need a screwdriver. My sons HATES them and refuses to use them.

I got an M12 hex impact driver for X-Mas last year and use it when appropriate.

Cheers

Jim
 
OP
B

Badgerstate

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2020
Messages
484
Location
Columbus, OH

dnschmidt

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2014
Messages
7,279
Location
Phoenix, AZ
The only problem with that is the same problem that I have with any other powered screwdriver: every time you want to use it, the battery is probably going to be dead.
Completely true with NiMH batteries or NiCd. With Li-Ion not so much. If you use it once a year you'll not have that problem as that's how long a Li-Ion battery will hold a charge. Since Milwaukee puts the 4 charge dots on the tool you'll immediately know when the battery needs charged simply by turning on the tool. I don't use mine much but I've never had the problem. What's nice about this tool is that you can also use it as a conventional screwdriver even if the battery is removed or completely dead.
 

garfunkle24

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Messages
3,429
Location
Saskatoon, Canada
I have a few nice ones, including Snap-on, Wera and my favorite, a PB Swiss Insider. I very rarely use any of them. If it's one or two screws it's quicker to grab a fixed-blade than mess with bits. If it's more than that it's time for the 12v. If it's an awkward ***** it's time for the bit ratchet.
 

HenryAZ

MEMBER EMERITUS
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
1,054
Location
South Congress AZ
I've tried a few brands of ratcheting drivers. My biggest dislike is the ones that slip off the ratchet setting, or are too easy to bump off myself in use. I have finally found one I like and use it exclusively when called for. It is made by Felo, in their Ergonic line (black and yellow handle). It has a flex head with stops at 90-45-0-45-90.
 

dimichele

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
101
I'm not a fan. However, I like the Mac overdriver posted earlier. Especially, for working on home appliances. The gear lets you run screws in and out quickly.

Using a drill to run screws in out of sheet metal just doesn't feel right to me. Too bulky and risk of over tightening.
 

garfunkle24

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
Messages
3,429
Location
Saskatoon, Canada
Using a drill to run screws in out of sheet metal just doesn't feel right to me. Too bulky and risk of over tightening.

That's what clutches are for. I use my 12v Bosch driver to run dash screws in all the time. I also use a drill to drive a metal tap with the clutch set pretty low when just cleaning up a threaded hole.
 

KnurledNut

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
8,152
Location
n/a
Whether you think they are good or not, you're right.
Different people, different jobs, different tools, different opinions.

I will say this: No one makes a P2R screwdriver. I use my SO-ratcheting with a P2R bit (usually Apex) a lot because its often better at certain tasks (not all obviously) than a P2/crosspoint screwdriver.
 

Renegade1LI

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2018
Messages
4,965
Location
long island ny
I bought a few of these megapros, love the bits stay secure, comfortable, SS with magnetic insert.
The MEGAPRO 13-in-1 automotive ratcheting screwdriver shaft is made from Stainless Steel 303 and includes 6 sizes of star screwdriver bits. This magnetic screwdriver drive fasteners easier and faster with its precision 28-tooth ratchet design and rubberized cushion grip handle.

Loaded with 12-one inch insert bits made from S2 industrial grade steel, this assortment of bit types and sizes provides the most suitable tips for driving automotive screws. The shaft opening serves as a 1/4″ hex driver. This is simply the right tool for difficult spaces and angles.

Additional information

  • Weight: 0.5 lbs
  • Driver Features: Ratcheting, Stainless Steel, Comfort Grip, Retractable Bit Cartridge, Palm Saver Cap, Magnetic Shaft
  • Screwdriver Bits: Phillips, Square, Torx, Flat, 1/4" Hex Shaft
  • Warranty: Lifetime Warranty
  • Made in: Canada
 

GTO

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2009
Messages
3,927
Location
NJ,FL
The only problem with that is the same problem that I have with any other powered screwdriver: every time you want to use it, the battery is probably going to be dead.
You must not own any Li-ion batteries or you are to lazy to put them in the charger.
The SO long shaft hard handle ratcheting screwdriver is the one to have.
Good luck
 

1foxracing

Well-known member
Joined
May 14, 2014
Messages
1,086
Location
Tuscarawas Co, Ohio
I have 3 Vessel ratcheting screwdrivers and 1 Dewalt electric, I always reach for the Dewalt when it can be used and I don't think I've ever used the Vessel ratcheting models. That Milwaukee model looks like a terrible joke, they can't make a drill with a chuck that spins true or actually hold any bits without slipping. I'm sure that $180 screwdriver spins as true as a banana.
Oz84fzhx4ZxTvEjuhbgCJM8ld=w1666-h937-no?authuser=0.jpg
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom