Read Carefully: 6 Point Socket vs 12 Point Wrench

[dchawk81]

I wrote read carefully because my question is NOT 6 vs 12 point sockets.

I have read a bunch of the 6 point vs 12 point threads and I know there is a load of back and forth on that. My take away is that if it is rusted or stubborn and I have a 6 point socket I should use it just to be certain.

So here is my question. If I have a very rusted fastener and I need to break it free is it better to use a 6 point socket or a 12 point box end wrench? The wrench would deliver the rotation on the same plane as the fastener needs to turn. The socket is delivering the rotational force in a plane that is offset from the fastener by roughly the height of the socket and the ratchet.

I know that I don't have all the technical terms correct in that question but I am hoping it is clear enough. So would it be better to reach for a 12 point that delivers the force in the same plane or a 6 point that delivers it in a slightly different plan along with the slight camming action this would create?

Force don't mean a thing if your 12 point rounds off the corners.

The best 6 points grab the long side of the fastener for best results.

 

[ScottsGT]

I know Snap On still make them. The SO industrial guy gave them to my son instead of the 12 points he was supposed to get. Took 6 months to get the correct wrenches. I told my son to make excuses for the next six months before he gives them back.

 

[nbpt100]

Snap On OSHM150B (comes in a set 10 mm thu 17 mm skipping 16 mm (they must assume you will use a 5/8") these are combination wrenches and ain't cheap!
I believe Sears/Craftsman used to have 6 point box end or combination wrenches but probably not anymore.

Anyone,does Proto have 6 point box end wrench/combo?

IDK but SK does.