repair or replace drywall

[scottsu150]

I would like your thoughts, I have a two stall finished garage but is nothing fancy. the back wall has newer drywall from previous owner when they hit back of garage with their car and not finished and most of the rest of the seams are ****. So my question is would it be easier to rip it all out if I want to add more outlets and a heater or just fix the bad spots?

 

[87jeepwrangler]

Ultimately there's a lot more info needed to make an educated decision about your situation. However, if it were me, I'd probably rip out and add outlets. Especially if I planned on staying a while.

 

[readhead]

If the drywall is basicly ok then cut a one foot rip the length of the wall and install what ever you want and patch and tape.

 

[scottsu150]

after thinking about it I am going to just gut the garage and start over. I want to add a 220 outlet for a new compressor, and add more outlets along 3 walls and more lights, plus I have an old tv but I want a flat screen on the wall and lastly I found a heater to tie into my boiler so those lines need to be run. after cutting that many holes it will be easier to just replace it all, now to convince the wife.

 

[C96]

Sounds like you have your work cut-out. Just make sure you don’t run to small of wire for the compressor outlet. Already know the electrical requirements for the compressor you are going to be using.

Good luck

 

[DonnyT]

after thinking about it I am going to just gut the garage and start over. I want to add a 220 outlet for a new compressor, and add more outlets along 3 walls and more lights, plus I have an old tv but I want a flat screen on the wall and lastly I found a heater to tie into my boiler so those lines need to be run. after cutting that many holes it will be easier to just replace it all, now to convince the wife.

I think this will be easier in the long run. Drywall is cheap enough and you will be very will the end result.

 

[cptn_zippy]

Rip it all out and redo. You will be happier, and the time involved will likely less.

 

[MScott]

Is there insulation? If not it would also be a good time to add insulation and vapour barrier esp. considering you are in Mi.

 

[Dan in Pasadena]

....now to convince the wife.

Don't ask for permission, just do it. Drywall is less than $10 a sheet. Even if money is tight, buy one or two sheets per paycheck and make it look right.

 

[rburke65]

I vote for all new. Make it your own and add it now.

 

[cwlo]

How about taking out the bottom row and putting in OSB or plywood. Don't forget its not easy to dispose of the old drywall due to its weight, and most municipalities not taking construction materials.

Chris

 

[scottsu150]

wife was actually for it, but she wants me to wait until it is warmer because her car is in the garage. that will give me a chance to make a plan and save up some cash so it's a win-win. i will keep everyone posted

 

[87jeepwrangler]

How about taking out the bottom row and putting in OSB or plywood. Don't forget its not easy to dispose of the old drywall due to its weight, and most municipalities not taking construction materials.

Chris

I personally like the added fire protection of 5/8 type x in garages attached to houses. Not to mention it looks better when finished than painted osb.

My trash guys take loads of drywall and construction materials. I've had 10 cans or bundles (my max allowed per pickup) for weeks straight and never had an issue. Guess it depends what their policy is in your township.

 

[Milton Shaw]

Rip it out and replace. Also add conduit in a few locations to run in something that comes up in the future. Cat 5 wiring and cable for tv/sound system would be nice to have in the walls if you ever need it. Insulation and vapor barrier would be on the list of things to upgrade while doing this. Also use green waterproof sheetrock for the lower piece to eliminate any moisture problems from cars dripping etc. The x fireproof would be recommended for the dividing wall to the house just for safety.

 

[scottsu150]

I called and the township won't allow osb in attached garage but it is nice, we had it in my last garage. I was going to go with 5/8 board, it is heavy but I think it works better. I do like the idea of cat5 and cable line, and I was thinking about using the fire rated stuff but never thought about waterproof but that is a good idea and lastly is the vapor barrier just plastic between insulation and sheetrock?