To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Request Dehumidifier Recommendation with Pump....

atwnsw

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
81
Hi Everybody,

I did a garage renovation a couple of years ago and love the finished product. Detached 2 2-car garage with insulation. Concrete floor.
Unfortunately, the space traps moisture (I am in NC mountains, specifically a rain forest).

Despite installing a Mr. Cool mini split system, it doesn't do a great job with the humidity. I need a reliable dehumidifier with a pump to drain water to the outside.

Can you recommend a dehumidifier for a roughly 450 SF space (hopefully, one that is efficient)?

Thanks in advance.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
A

atwnsw

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
81
Depending on your setup could you wall mount it and just let it gravity drain outside ?
Yes, I could definitely use gravity to drain outside. Looking for something reliable (most seem to die soon after warranty)
 

dcg9381

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 20, 2018
Messages
11,660
Location
Austin, TX
Despite installing a Mr. Cool mini split system, it doesn't do a great job with the humidity. I need a reliable dehumidifier with a pump to drain water to the outside.
This surprises me. Have you tried running it in dehumidify mode? Is it run in cooling mode 24/7 or just on when you need it?

My mini-splits (24k) pour a very steady stream of water out the drains. And I mean steady, no dripping... It's a LOT of water.

Most of the dehumidifiers I've seen around here have far less capacity than what a mini-split would have...
 

DrinkMan

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 13, 2020
Messages
1,238
Location
Georgia, USA
Gravity is Good.

You are going to see a lot of suggestions for some real good high quality dehumidifiers that are pricey. Those are great options. One day I will buy a good one. But I'm very cheap and sometimes you buy what you can find locally. I've own/owned 5 dehumidifiers. Only 1 has failed (after 12 years). Here is the overly verbose details of each one. (There is a common theme - the pumps fail....a lot but gravity is good)

I had a Kenmore (name from the past) in our crawl space of our cabin with a pump. Dehumidifier lasted about 12 years of hard work but the pump part failed in about 2 years so I switched it over to the hose system to drain outside (made a little platform to raise the dehumidifier up for gravity to do the job).

When the Kenmore failed, I replaced it with a Midea Cube system. It has 3 options - pump, drain hose for gravity, or bucket. It was the best I could find locally up in the mountains. I don't remember when I got it. It was about 10 years ago? It has been running fine all this time. The pump part of it failed early so I switched it over to the drain hose. When this system fails, I'll probably spend some real bucks and buy a good one like you will see recommended here on GJ. But it was cheap and available and still working.

Then, 2 years ago, a tornado hit and threw a tree through the roof of our cabin. I immediately went to the local stores and the only dehumidifiers I could find were more of the consumer grade Mideas. I bought the last of the upright style 50 pint with pump and another Midea cube. I set them up in the loft that was now missing a roof and only had a blue tarp. Ripped up the carpet and those two Mideas worked non-stop (never cycled off) for 6 months and used their pumps the entire time. After the insurance settled and reconstruction was complete, I moved them to our primary residence and put them our basement garage with the pumps routed outside. Guess what - within 3 months, pumps failed. I took the pump inlet filters off, cleaned them, blew out the lines and they worked briefly. Realized I was wasting my time. Elevated them a little, hooked up the gravity hose and was done. I've had them running in the basement for a year and half after their half year running in the mountains 24/7.

At our coastal home in a flood zone on the marsh, I didn't even bother trying to use a pump. I bought a Toshiba 70 pint dehumidifier and hooked up the garden hose to the drain to route outside. Because we are in a flood zone and our basement garage is in the danger zone, all the electrical outlets are high on the wall and everything is elevated anyway so I built a platform for the Toshiba. It has been running perfectly for 5 years. It is set at 50% humidity and it does fantastic in the 1400 sq ft area. If not for that, our cars would be in a 80% humidity area (6 feet above sea level about 20 feet from a giant salt water marsh near the ocean on St Simons Island).

I know that there are better units than I have been buying but I'm getting long life out of these cheap units as long as I don't depend on the pumps. One of these days I'll buy a high quality unit (but will it outlast what I've experienced?).
 
OP
A

atwnsw

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
81
Regarding the mini-split, this is what Mr. Cool says about using the Dry setting: "It is not recommended to run Dry mode for more than 10–13 hours at a time. Extended use can lead to discomfort and inefficient energy use, potentially "freezing out" the room."

So, this leads me to conclude that I will buy a dedicated Dehumidifier. In my research, I have narrowed my search to a Moiswell commercial dehumidifier (70 pint) that is gravity fed. The warranty is 2/5 yr and has decent reviews.

I need help with 2 suggestions:
1) I am going to hang it from my ceiling. Could you recommend a hanging kit? [Dimensions are 16L x 13W x 13H] and weight is 40lb.

2) The gravity hose that comes with it is roughly 6' long. I need to have approx a total of 15'' hose length. What should I buy to extend or replace the gravity hose that comes with it, and would look professional flowing to the outside of the garage and away from the house?

Thanks in advance.
 

CMB41

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 31, 2018
Messages
81
Location
california
I have this one and have been very happy with it. Humidity where I live runs between 45-65% ambient. I use this in a 1200sq ft room filled with expensive equipment and it keeps it at 35% with no issues. Has been running for 3+ years now. Prior to this, I blew through 3 Honeywell 70 pint units in 5 years. It also has a pump so gravity placement is not an issue.
Cons. Expensive and relatively loud.

They make a smaller one that might be better for your application. YMMV

 

Sumboodie

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2021
Messages
10,668
Location
AK
Gravity hose to a $40 condensate pump.

I have a unit with pump. Pump was SLOWWWWW to drain, even when new, and quite noisy. Like 20+ mins to drain the maybe 2 gallon tank.

The pump didn't last but 3 or 4 seasons. Just makes noise now.

Way ahead to buy a cheaper and much more common non pump unit.
 

larry4406

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
19,082
Location
Northern Virginia
2) The gravity hose that comes with it is roughly 6' long. I need to have approx a total of 15'' hose length. What should I buy to extend or replace the gravity hose that comes with it, and would look professional flowing to the outside of the garage and away from the house?

Thanks in advance.
All of the dehumidifiers I have fooled with all use standard garden hose thread.

If you are mounting this high on the wall, you could install say 1" PVC pipe along the wall pitched downward to where you want to exit. Near the dehumidifier, elbow up with say a length of pipe 8-10" long. Take your supplied hose and push the discharge end into the pipe riser.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

phantoms01TC

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2016
Messages
8
Skip the cheap stuff. Get a Santa Fe Compact70, built for tough, humid spaces like yours, works in low temps, and handles 70 pints/day. Add the pump kit, done.
 

Notgrownup

Well-known member
Joined
May 5, 2014
Messages
5,866
Location
Snow Hill NC
Santa Fe or Aprillaire. I have a Aprilaire in my crawlspace and it# been running nonstop for about 8 years I think. I’d buy it again and I would install a gravity drain.
 

joe_padavano

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 26, 2011
Messages
1,788
Location
Northern VA
I've been through many dehumidifiers over the last 25 years, including several with the built-in condensate pumps. They ALWAYS **** out eventually. Gravity drain if possible, but if not get a separate external condensate pump.
 

dcg9381

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 20, 2018
Messages
11,660
Location
Austin, TX
Regarding the mini-split, this is what Mr. Cool says about using the Dry setting: "It is not recommended to run Dry mode for more than 10–13 hours at a time. Extended use can lead to discomfort and inefficient energy use, potentially "freezing out" the room."
Mr. Cool can be setup on it's timer / app. Why not run it for 3 hours a day and see how it does? You may be able to set multiple run times in a single day... If it won't get the job done when you're using it frequently, something seems off to me.

We have a dedicated dehumidifier in the basement. It's just a "small AC" that runs constantly and drains water to a sump pump.
 

tncatadjuster

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2010
Messages
1,986
Location
Memphis, TN
My 24K Mr Cool will dehumidify 3200 sq ft basement in less than a day. I’m keeping it around 49% humidity and 70 degrees 24/7. Could there be something wrong with the unit?
 
OP
A

atwnsw

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2013
Messages
81
I exchanged emails w/ Mr Cool and essentially my unit is over-sized for my garage so that it cools so fast that it doesn't remove humidity.

I am going to try the Dry setting daily for 3 hours per day (hopefully that doesn't freeze it).
 

Donghammer11

New member
Joined
Mar 15, 2026
Messages
1
I exchanged emails w/ Mr Cool and essentially my unit is over-sized for my garage so that it cools so fast that it doesn't remove humidity.

I am going to try the Dry setting daily for 3 hours per day (hopefully that doesn't freeze it).
Any update on how the dry setting has worked?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom