To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Requesting Pneumatic Impact Recommendations

Dud

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
76
I am seeking recommendations on a pneumatic impact for a family member. He has started a new job at a local shop and he needs an impact. The shop recommended that he purchase his own impact for daily tasks such as tire rotations. I am looking for a "best value" recommendation for a 1/2" impact that is of reasonable cost and one that would last a long time, assuming that it is taken care of.

The current candidate tools include the Earthquake impact from Harbor Freight and a Klutch model from Northern Tool. Both are similarly priced in the $100 to $130 range. Both have nearly the same torque. The vendors sell other brands such as Ingersol-Rand as well.

Please recommend a brand/model that you would consider a good candidate tool for this situation. Thanks so much ...
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

CJM8515

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 8, 2014
Messages
9,286
Location
NJ
IR 2235TiMAX well worth it. its light weight, powerful and well made.
 

Gummi Bear

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
524
Location
Sunset, Texas
I’m very happy with my AirCat tools.

I just upgraded my ⅜” impact and it has nearly as much torque as my old ½” (which I’ll be upgrading soon)

They’re a little more than the HF, but have more torque, and I think are a little better made. A terrific value overall.

All that said, I am also happy with the IR and Chicago Pneumatic tools that I own. Wouldn’t hesitate to buy more from them as well.



I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately...

Henry David Thoreau
 

setfocus

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2020
Messages
413
Location
rust belt
IR 231C is a solid budget choice and a tire shop classic ($120ish), Aircat 1200k, IR 2135 or 2235 are modern choices

agreed on the IR 231C, whenever I finally have a decent garage and compressor for at home, a classic 231C is on the list. Chicago Pneumatic made an impact that was considered just as good as the IR 231, back in the day, don't remember the model # but probably in your price range. No experience with Aircats but hear good things. HF Earthquake XT supposedly has good power and as cheap as it gets, but I doubt it will last long in a shop. I know nothing about Klutch

I've got both the old IR 2135qtimax and new 2235timax at work. They don't make the old 2135timax anymore (except the pinned anvil version) but they have a 2135qxpa, which I guess is basically the old quiet 2135qtimax but with aluminum hammer case instead of titanium and cheaper... but maybe worth the extra cost over a 231C if used for more than just lugs. Much lighter weight (makes a difference with constant use in awkward positions) and more power. 231C is pretty heavy

I mostly use my old 2135. The 2235 comes out for stubborn fasteners. I like that the 2135 is lighter and a hair smaller but mine is nearing the end of its life :sad: . The 2235 is a real beast but probably overkill and around $300
 

skruft

Well-known member
Joined
May 9, 2011
Messages
759
I have used the IR for many years, and some Snap-on, but have not used Snap-on enough to make any recommendation.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

xjfish

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 22, 2014
Messages
1,290
I have used Aircats for pro use with good results. They are maintained but get the **** beat out of them. They do get tired after many years of use and abuse, as most do. Highly recommend for your family member. IR is also a great suggestion, usually slightly more expensive.
 

Schurkey

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,366
Location
The Seasonally Frozen Wastelands
The shop recommended that he purchase his own impact for daily tasks such as tire rotations. I am looking for a "best value" recommendation for a 1/2" impact that is of reasonable cost and one that would last a long time, assuming that it is taken care of.
FIRST, if the main use is "Tire work", buy one with an extended anvil, and a couple of "flip sockets", one in SAE and one in Metric.

SECOND, if the main use is "Tire work", you do not need a 1/2" impact. A quality 3/8 is ENTIRELY powerful enough, especially for a beginner. A high-powered 1/2" impact will tear the lug studs right out of the hub in a moment of carelessness. (I don't suppose he'll work on many Mopars with reverse-thread lug nuts on one side...)

I started my career with borrowed and VERY "used" impact tools. The first one I actually bought--used, from my employer that specialized in Tires, Batteries, Accessories (TBA) and fluid changes, was a CP734, but with the 2" extra long anvil, and a CP flip socket in SAE sizes. The '734 was pretty-much the "Industry Standard" back then. The thing would be considered a cripple compared to today's powerful impact wrenches. CP says 310 working foot-pounds of torque for the current version; and that's on-par with the better 3/8" wrenches now. I don't think CP offers an extended anvil on the 734 any more, but they do with the CP749-2 and probably others. IR will have something competitive.

https://www.cp.com/en-us/tools/products/impactwrenches/cp749-2

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0054R6M6A/?tag=atomicindus08-20

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004EYJYTQ/?tag=atomicindus08-20

Flip sockets (Most come with an impact extension, some don't.)

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0002SR38M/?tag=atomicindus08-20

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000LQG35O/?tag=atomicindus08-20


When I was looking for a new "Tire work" impact about a year or two ago, I bought a 3/8" drive tool with a 1/2" anvil, ("Compact 1/2") packaged as a kit with a couple of flip sockets. Light weight, easy to handle, doesn't take a lot of air to run, and has MORE than enough power to do 80% of what I need.

2019_Snap_On_MG3255L_01_LG.jpg

MG3255L.jpg


Look in the pawn shops, first, especially if you're NOT getting an impact with an extended anvil. Air impacts seem to be a popular item in pawn shops, and they tend to be reliable. Almost all of my impacts have been bought used. I wouldn't buy a used air ratchet, but I've had no problem with used air impact wrenches.

Better to have a used Snap-On or other "quality" tool than brand-new Bottom-Feeder Chinese ****. I have a mild preference for an oil-lubed impact mechanism rather than "greased", but there's good tools with either design. If you buy an impact wrench that lubes the impact mechanism with grease, you'll have to buy the specialized taper-tip grease gun to use with it, and tubes of grease.

Some of the older "oil lubed mechanism" impacts had a pipe thread drain plug, pull the plug, dump the oil every couple of years. The newer ones "omit" the drain plug 'cause it saves fifteen cents.

Tell him to be sure to oil the air inlet (for the air motor, not for the impact mechanism) it every day. Do not trust "The Company's" inline oiler until he's seen the reservoir get refilled a couple times. Often the in-line oilers plug up and don't put any oil into the air supply, so the air motor gets zero lube.

Make sure he NEVER uses a "chrome" socket or extension (and especially a "chrome" universal joint/swivel socket) on an impact wrench.

He's going to need a torque wrench to put the wheels back on.
 
Last edited:

anndel

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 28, 2015
Messages
3,270
Location
Hawaii, USA
Snap-on PT850, Ingersoll Rand 2235QTiMAX , Astro 1822 and 1823 (discontinued) and Air Cat 1150 Killer Cat. If money is an issue, get the Air Cat 1150 or IR 2235.
 
Last edited:

jpaw

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
524
Location
Michigan
IR 231, take care of it and it should last a lifetime.
Not the most powerful and a little heavy compared to newer composite guns but rock solid reliable.
 
OP
D

Dud

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
76
Thank you all for your sage advice, especially Schurkey. It looks like the consensus is the IR 231C with 600 FT-lbs of torque. On sale ATM for $110 on Amazon. I prefer local sales but my local store is 20% more expensive. I'll see what the kid thinks.

Thanks again one and all!
 

RedneckWelder

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 12, 2013
Messages
5,693
Location
The Ghetto Kingdom of Methlandia
Thank you all for your sage advice, especially Schurkey. It looks like the consensus is the IR 231C with 600 FT-lbs of torque. On sale ATM for $110 on Amazon. I prefer local sales but my local store is 20% more expensive. I'll see what the kid thinks.

Thanks again one and all!

It’ll do well for a budget gun and then when he wants to upgrade he can bring it home and it’ll do nicely for home use.

Later he can get into a compact 3/8 and battery and all that. We are in a golden age for pneumatic and now battery choices.
 

Schurkey

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,366
Location
The Seasonally Frozen Wastelands
It looks like the consensus is the IR 231C with 600 FT-lbs of torque.
600 ft/lbs is optimistic. I bet it's right around 350 in real life. The IR web site says 300 forward, 350 reverse. And that's only if the shop has real air pressure. If they've regulated down, the torque will be lower still. This is not a bad thing for tire work. Pretty lame for big or seized fasteners. As said, that's right in the range of a good 3/8 drive.

On sale ATM for $110 on Amazon.
$30--$50 at a pawn shop.

Don't forget to add the cost of the grease gun, and a bottle of air tool oil.
Both in one kit
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000E0TC8C/?tag=atomicindus08-20

Separate grease gun
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000FMK7FG/?tag=atomicindus08-20

Separate oil
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0019VOCLM/?tag=atomicindus08-20
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom