I've only used the RaceDeck, as it is what I have. As far as how it is working out, after a year and all four seasons, it is doing quite well. I don't know whether you have specific questions, and if you do, add them and I'll respond in more detail if necessary.
By the way, I live in an area of real winter [read: snow, ice, frozen road slush dripping off car undersides and tires, spring mud, autumn leaves and pine needles blowing in, and so on.] My clean-up, so far in my limited time experience, consists of a combination, depending, of using a broom, the shop vacuum, a damp rag. Eventually, I shall pull out some of the tiles to remove a bit of road dirt that has accumulated behind where each tire sits. Don't need to do so, yet, but I can see I will one day. The tiles are easy to snap out and set aside for this.