Redneckvtek
Active member
Hello All,
Thanks in advance for any advice or feedback you can provide on this.
I have gone back and forth with garage build plans for a long time. I think I am finally ready to pull the trigger. I have a 100K budget + 20k contingency, if I go beyond that I need to start asking tough questions and making tough decisions.
The Wife wants some more interior space so this is the plan I have come up with, plus a quote I received from an Angi's list contractor.
Location is Raleigh, NC outside of the city limits.
The Concept is a 2+1 garage with office space above the 2. I asked the contractor to leave as much work unfinished as possible to keep the cost down, as I can do that once the COO is issued (if i understand correctly). Examples would be only minimum electrical downstairs, no downstairs insulation or interior finishing, no concrete finish work, no downstairs hvac.
There is no plumbing planned for this project, and the existing lot is flat with a mild slope front-back of ~18"
The other potential fly in the ointment is my current 200a service. It passes under the proposed location of this, so I expect the wire will need to be re-run. Additionally, my home is all electric so my existing 200a service is at capacity. Therefore I expect to upgrade to a 400a service and install a exterior breaker panel with 2x 200a main breakers which would feed my existing 200a panel and the new building's panel (likely 200a as well to serve tools and elec. car chargers).
Please let me know if this budget is reasonable, if the quote seems reasonable and in line with industry standards, and what questions I should be asking the contractor before I move forward.
I do have one other contractor who I have been discussing with. His "verbal" quote was ~150k but he cannot narrow that down unless I commit to approx 10k of Concept and Planning costs, which would result in a final planset and permits.
I don't want to get into this thinking it can be done for 100K and end up with a partially done project and no money to finish it.
The sketch I have provided:



And this is the quote I received.
These are the questions I have so far (for the contractor, I will send him an email after thinking on it and soliciting feedback):
1. Insulation and Drywall for upstairs - is this budgeted, and if so which line item?
2. Concrete - is the garage floor concrete included in the "hardscape" line item?
3. Doors - What is included in the garage door portion - just the doors, or also openers, and if so which ones? I will need "hi-rise" tracks to allow for future lift install.
4. Windows - what windows are included in this line item?
5. Electrical - Can you please break this into "new electric for construction" and "upgrade electric - 200 amp to 400 amp upgrade" items?
Questions for the hive mind:
Shingles - are these decent shingles? I don't need fancy, but I would like to buy something that will last another 25+ years. The plan is to have the contractor do both the new building and my existing house (2200 sq ft) so it matches.
Should I try to get the 400a upgrade done separate - IE before breaking ground on the building? I have already reached out to my electric utility so I should hear back early this week.
What else do I need to be asking?
- Is the budget reasonable for what I am asking or am I way off?
- Is the quote reasonable - meaning in line for the scope of work. If its too good to be true I should be scared. If its too high (I dont think it is), I should keep shopping.
Thanks again,
Chris
Thanks in advance for any advice or feedback you can provide on this.
I have gone back and forth with garage build plans for a long time. I think I am finally ready to pull the trigger. I have a 100K budget + 20k contingency, if I go beyond that I need to start asking tough questions and making tough decisions.
The Wife wants some more interior space so this is the plan I have come up with, plus a quote I received from an Angi's list contractor.
Location is Raleigh, NC outside of the city limits.
The Concept is a 2+1 garage with office space above the 2. I asked the contractor to leave as much work unfinished as possible to keep the cost down, as I can do that once the COO is issued (if i understand correctly). Examples would be only minimum electrical downstairs, no downstairs insulation or interior finishing, no concrete finish work, no downstairs hvac.
There is no plumbing planned for this project, and the existing lot is flat with a mild slope front-back of ~18"
The other potential fly in the ointment is my current 200a service. It passes under the proposed location of this, so I expect the wire will need to be re-run. Additionally, my home is all electric so my existing 200a service is at capacity. Therefore I expect to upgrade to a 400a service and install a exterior breaker panel with 2x 200a main breakers which would feed my existing 200a panel and the new building's panel (likely 200a as well to serve tools and elec. car chargers).
Please let me know if this budget is reasonable, if the quote seems reasonable and in line with industry standards, and what questions I should be asking the contractor before I move forward.
I do have one other contractor who I have been discussing with. His "verbal" quote was ~150k but he cannot narrow that down unless I commit to approx 10k of Concept and Planning costs, which would result in a final planset and permits.
I don't want to get into this thinking it can be done for 100K and end up with a partially done project and no money to finish it.
The sketch I have provided:



And this is the quote I received.
Admin Services $14,000.00
provide on site supervision and all needed insurance and drawings, as well as time to maintain an efficient work timeline.
Demolition Services $3,000.00
Demo the described area of work and take away all applicable trash and debris and dispose of safely. removing any dirt that is not needed or wanted by the customer. there will be a onsite dumpster for trash.
Flooring Services $3,500.00
install laminate or lvp. customer to choose the flooring at a budget at 3.50 a sqft.
Framing $21,000.00
provide materials and all rough framing materials per nc 2018 code and any engineering drawings that may be applicable. all framing will be built per the engineers specs on the final approved drawings by the customer and 123 renovate.
Electrical Services $26,000.00
installation of electrical services that are needed for minimum code for nc 2018 install a new 400 amp service panel. install minimum wiring for the garage areas and normal for the living space above the garage.
Gutters $2,200.00
install matching gutters to house or customer chosen type of gutter. gutters will be put into the ground as well.
Hvac services $8,500.00
install all necessary materials and unit for hvac system needed for per 2018 nc code.
Drainage, hardscape services. $14,000.00
install the footings and foundations to meet customer and engineers specs.
Roof installation $16,000.00
install new shingles on the house and the new addition. shingles will be black charcoal or grey. brand of shingles is gaf timberline shingles. 20 year warranty and 7 year on labor.
Trim Carpentry $9,000.00
install the doors and trim and siding. install garage doors per the customer choices, install the hardiplank siding to match the house.
Window install $4,500.00
purchase and install matching windows to the existing windows sized 1/2 inch smaller to fit into the rough opening and allow for proper insulation and breathing of the house and window to ensure that the window maintains the full manufactures warranty.
Painting Services $4,000.00
paint the inside of the add-on of the two office spaces, paint the outside siding to match the house.
Subtotal $125,700.00
Payment schedule: 10% down, then pay for each subsection as progress is reached.
These are the questions I have so far (for the contractor, I will send him an email after thinking on it and soliciting feedback):
1. Insulation and Drywall for upstairs - is this budgeted, and if so which line item?
2. Concrete - is the garage floor concrete included in the "hardscape" line item?
3. Doors - What is included in the garage door portion - just the doors, or also openers, and if so which ones? I will need "hi-rise" tracks to allow for future lift install.
4. Windows - what windows are included in this line item?
5. Electrical - Can you please break this into "new electric for construction" and "upgrade electric - 200 amp to 400 amp upgrade" items?
Questions for the hive mind:
Shingles - are these decent shingles? I don't need fancy, but I would like to buy something that will last another 25+ years. The plan is to have the contractor do both the new building and my existing house (2200 sq ft) so it matches.
Should I try to get the 400a upgrade done separate - IE before breaking ground on the building? I have already reached out to my electric utility so I should hear back early this week.
What else do I need to be asking?
- Is the budget reasonable for what I am asking or am I way off?
- Is the quote reasonable - meaning in line for the scope of work. If its too good to be true I should be scared. If its too high (I dont think it is), I should keep shopping.
Thanks again,
Chris
Last edited:
