Hi Ron,
Where have you been hiding?
About 10 years ago I was involved in a huge study to rate the different sealers for wood decks. I looked at about 30 different products. Thompson's Water Seal came in DEAD LAST!
The best performing product was from Cabot. The three products that I formulated came in 2nd, 4th, and 8th. This testing was not only laboratory testing but also tested in the real world on a fairly large boat dock at Lake James in Morganton, N.C. The dock has complete exposure to the sun for the entire day... no trees or shade.
You can also check research done by Consumer Reports. Their results and mine were fairly similar although our project was much more extensive.
Cabot was sold to Valspar a few years ago. So, I'm not sure of their current formulations. Big companies tend to 'dumb down' technology when they purchase small technology companies. However, Consumers Reports does research about every 2 years.
Eric