Looking for input from those wiser than myself. I own two townhomes, one is a rental making income, one is occupied by me at low cost. I bought them as investments and the property values have appreciated significantly since purchase in 2018/2019. My original plan was to keep the homes until I retire and they're paid off, then either sell or continue to rent for additional retirement income. I don't particularly enjoy being a landlord, but it's worked out so far.
I've recently moved out of state to occupy a vacant family home for free for at least the next year. I would really like to purchase a long-term home with some acreage to start a small hobby farm in the near future.
Details:
- Rental is bringing in about $750/mo average
- Other house could be rented out to bring in additional $675/mo, otherwise it costs $400/mo to keep empty
- Selling both homes today would put a liquid $315k in my pocket after fees (estimate based on recent comps sold in same neighborhood)
- Annual income from my employer is $85k gross
- I am 30 - 35 years away from retirement age
- Home values are up and acreage isn't cheap
So the questions start rolling in. Should I sell now, capture the profit off the investment and put into a personal home? Put profit into a fund and let sit for the next 30 years for ROI instead of actively land-lording? Should I keep renting and use residual income to help secure a third mortgage for personal home? Sell one, keep the other? etc.
There is an emotional component to this too - managing properties by oneself is pretty taxing, especially when you work a demanding full time job. Living in the same state is no longer feasible (choosing to be closer to family/friends again), so I'm now 1000+ miles away. Property management companies are very expensive, and add another layer of people that need managing/direction. The good news is the HOA takes care of all exterior maintenance/landscaping. I'm a 2hr plane ride away, but not close enough to justify taking care of all the maintenance myself like I normally do. So profit would disappear if I let others manage/repair, but the homes would still be building equity.
Because rents are high in the area, my total income is well into the 6-figures and income taxes are high. I'm unable to save much more than $10k per year liquid after I cover housing expenses, taxes, minimal personal expenses, contribute to 401K, HSA, and personal investment account. I also feel I have to maintain a 6-month emergency fund on hand for all expenses incase I lose my job, can't get renters in, HVAC blows up, etc. So saving for a minimum down payment/closing costs on a third house with acreage will likely take me 3 - 5 more years at the current rate, and it would be a real grind (minimum enjoyments). If I take profits from the sale and dump it into a personal property, there's a chance the mortgage would be small, possibly non-existent if I could find a good fixer-upper.
Conclusion: Life has been a largely unenjoyable grind for the past 5 years. It has paid off so far, but I feel I'm ready to invest in more personal endeavors. Would I severely impact retirement by selling homes now? Or should I leave everything alone and just keep scraping money together for my future home?