Snap-On Dual 80 Quick Release vs Standard Ratchets Question

[Slupie]

I'm trying to decide between the SO Dual 80 F80 vs FR80 3/8" drive and T72 vs TR72 1/4" drive ratchets.

Can some of you that have both the standard and quick release comment on pros and cons of each.

I only fix my own cars in my garage so I can not try them myself. I don't have an access to SO truck.

Currently I'm using Craftsman Raised Panel Quick Release ratchets but i'm finding the need for more teeth and smaller swing arc. I like the quick release option on my Craftsman ratchets.

 

[DrkMtnDew]

i like the non-QR better, but another guy i work with likes the QR better, because he's getting older and doesn't have the strength in his hands that he used to. also clearence plays a very small role, as does hitting the button accidently and losing the socket. biggest thing it boils down to is personal preference.

 

[G1GRANDEUR]

For just general use, I like quick release ratchet. Never hurt to have both.

 

[mudflap]

I prefer the quick release style, otherwise, when hands get even a little bit greasy, i am fighting with sockets the rest of the day.

 

[tbobbo]

I prefer the non quick release ratchets, quick release seems to make ratchets feel cheap.

 

[wreckerman5357]

I prefer the non quick release ratchets, quick release seems to make ratchets feel cheap.

+1, Quick release *****, you won't miss it if you get a ratchet without it.

 

[pipsters]

I upgraded from Craftsman raised panels to the Craftsman thin profiles because I wanted quick release. I have an older Snap-On that does not have QR and my preference is still for it.

 

[Tunger]

I have a couple QR ratchets and they are relegated to the truck box. I find they just frustrate me after using standard ratchets for many years in the shop. But basically it all boils down to personal preference, try a few ratchets with and without QR and then order the style that you prefer from snap on.

 

[flintsghost]

I have never owned a QR ratchet in my many years. Yes, occasionally a socket gets stuck on the ratchet but I always seem able to get it off. I have a dozen Snap On ratchets in 1/2", 3/8", and 1/4" and like them just fine without the button. I also don't worry about accidentally ejecting the socket at an in opertune time.

 

[otis66]

Non-quick release is better. Sometimes the quick release button gets in the way.

 

[Slupie]

Thanks for the wisdom and advice. I think I'm just going to buy one of each and see which ones I like better.

 

[bobcatdan]

I bought 36 tooth SO qr snappy had on the truck, mostly because they say USA on them. All said and done, I don't really notice any difference, I just have to push a bottom to get the socket off.

 

[Rico.]

I have to push a bottom to get the socket off.

That might be o.k. in the USA, but I don't think that particular
Snap-On ratchet will pass European legislation.

 

[RRmech]

Murphy's Law:

A socket will always bounce to the one spot in your garage where you can't find it.

I use non-QR ratchets for the above reason.

Steve

 

[ajchien]

I used to prefer the QR, now that I'm doing much more DIY than ever, my preference has shifted to the round head non QR.

The QR was exactly that, easier to remove the socket, and it can also hold the socket tighter.

However, I have had a few times sockets drop, particularly with 1/4 rats, due to tighter space using them ... And then having to run after a rolling socket going down my driveway headed towards the street drain. I also have started to prefer palming by 1/4 rats, because it's a bit faster, which increases the near drop rate with QR.

On the other hand, I'll still use my craftsman QR when I want a socket or extension on extra tight. For example, spark plug sockets sometimes stick harder to the plug than to the extension or ratchet. It's a little annoying to have the plug and socket still in the hole, and you're holding the ratchet +\- the extension. I've also gotta set of QR extensions just for these situations.

 

[humpdawg]

Pulling sockets off a non QR is like taking candy from a baby. Just a little resistance but its worth it.
Sometimes I use a little plastic butter knife tool to pry it out. no big deal dough.

 

[GeorgiaHybrid]

It depends on what I am doing. If i'm dropping a ****** or oil pan or anything else where my tools are likely to get coated in slippery fluid, I reach for a QR. Anything else I prefer a non QR ratchet.

 

[el tanque prohibido]

Get all one or the other. If most of your ratchets are non-quick release and you go to take a socket off the quick release without pressing the button, you're gonna get flustered.

 

[travis85904]

me personally, i am a quick release kinda guy

 

[Conductor562]

I typically prefer non-qr ratchets. It's just one more thing to break down the road. I've seen lots of older rats that were in perfect working order with the exception of the QR

Edit: Didn't realize this was a 3 year old thread

 

[samgodbout]

I like more quick release. The time I lost fighting to remove socket with greasy hand.. My 3 ratchet I use the most are quick release. The rest are non quick release.

 

[97nismo]

I've broken several quick release so ratchets. I don't find them as strong and they strip the gears

 

[newspeed]

I've broken several quick release so ratchets. I don't find them as strong and they strip the gears

Same experience here. Not as strong, plus they can be very annoying after using standard ratchets for years. Non QR is the way to go.

 

[Rarified27]

I grew up using the Craftsman RP QR and don't miss it, plus I've had a few instances of knocking a socket off with a QR.

Maybe it's psychosomatic, but i feel like the non QR have a more resistant ball spring where as the QR have balls that travel more, essentially locking them into place. However, I've never had a non QR leave a socket on a fastener, only the RH POS ones you get in "kits".

 

[Dust Devil]

I like non quick release.

With one of these. I keep one on all my 3/8 and 1/4 ratchets.

http://buy1.snapon.com/catalog/item...roup_ID=680887&store=snapon-store&dir=catalog

The reason is that I often press on the backside of the ratchets when using, usually with my thumb.

The "spinner" attchments are priceless. Easy to pull off sockets even with the greasiest hands. Priceless.

 

[HairMetal]

The quick release button is pretty useless unless it's recessed into the ratchet head.

 

[Ridge Runner]

I absolutely prefer quick release ratchets. I like knowing that the socket isn't going to come off until I hit the button. Never really had a problem with hitting the button accidentally. Just like keeping your finger off of the trigger until you're ready to fire a gun, I've never had a problem with keeping my hand away from the release button on a ratchet.

Also, I like being able to hover the ratchet over my socket tray and drop the socket right back into its place as opposed to having to place it by hand on the tray when I'm using a standard release ratchet. Sounds lazy, but doing it day-in and day-out, it is a noticeable difference in efficiency and rhythm.

 

[abvw]

I absolutely prefer quick release ratchets. I like knowing that the socket isn't going to come off until I hit the button. Never really had a problem with hitting the button accidentally. Just like keeping your finger off of the trigger until you're ready to fire a gun, I've never had a problem with keeping my hand away from the release button on a ratchet.

Also, I like being able to hover the ratchet over my socket tray and drop the socket right back into its place as opposed to having to place it by hand on the tray when I'm using a standard release ratchet. Sounds lazy, but doing it day-in and day-out, it is a noticeable difference in efficiency and rhythm.

I have an easy fix for you:

Buy enough ratchets so you won't ever need to swap sockets.