To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Some ramble about shops

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I been in a lot, all kinds of them. I didnt want to dump on another thread but some of the stuff I learned and if I had a chance to do it again would for a couple reasons but cost and speed are part of it.
I put off buying a few pieces I should have and bought some I didnt need. In lifes great scheme its rather low on the list of mistakes a guy can make but if done easier often makes it so much more rewarding.
Some MyGyver things are really my most rewarding,,,, way better than all the fussy stuff. As I mention,,, times and tools and vendors mean a lot different than when I started and a lot more susceptible to opinion, etc.
A master I had a while back said,,, we got good tools here. Sometimes I was interested in some stuff,,, he wasnt scared to buy,,, bought a couple things we needed but he would also say when he could see that glaze,,, we get along just fine for a long time without it.
I would copy masters more and invent less. I listened to a lot of paranoid self engineer types, they knew some **** but jump to a lot of conclusions and set up a pattern of obsession about a volt or pound loss, were overkill, they also always had to add a booger or 2 to take if from standard to a work around for some grand vision.
Today would buy only few true high dollar tools, every time a guy needs a Northstar water pump tool even the guy at the Cadilac dealer used a Lisle he scored off the shelf at the time. 30$ is huge for 3 uses and 300 tossed at it wouldnt make it any better.
Its a good way to buy tools. I can feel it, we are short a couple clamps here, we need a couple hammers and 2 more 12 inch etc, some of the most fundamental are that way and it all adds up fast enough without tossing 4 grand on a table sits in a guys garage, takes space and he really doesnt need it. I would be very aware today,,, learn early on and now I see why my Bud, licenced master pluma 50 yrs, can get anything he wants, any pipe or air filter, any gadget, any compressor still uses his 1/2 steel line he put in when he was 20 something.
I found the longer I went and really did some revision that a guy uses less not more, can get way more simple, some of the big investments became paper weights or never used most of the expensive options and features. **** I thought was critical dont mean squat,,, some of this even goes to very pro shops, taking a little longer once in a while or one off may be a lot better than rushing in to set up for something not work out.
I like what clyde does, the band saw he has is a beauty. Got it used, set up he can use it every day, he has legit work for it. I could use it but it wouldnt save me any money, already have a fast way to do that work I do. In general repair and occasional fabrication precision isnt a big deal, accurate and making it work right, getting it reassembled correctly and this is often so true,,, well thats the way it came apart or putting **** together so it worked.
Did a job a while back tipped myself when I made out the bill for fitting it all up, the guy even said,,, you hooked it up first for I went crazy with the welder. I got a neighbor has a fab shop. He really doesnt like walk in work and really rightly so. They can weld, they can cut but they dont fix.
This is where it all hits the road, the bottom line no matter what the tools and today the quality of the tool isnt as much contributor as its made out to be. Some of the best mechanics I ever met use common stuff and a lot of the first Sears **** and more they ever bought. I know a couple drag a bit behind but they do it and lack of success doesnt seem all that connected to the brand of screwdriver.
My shop is a "professional" but not dedicated to a particular craft as it is general, all the way from tractor to telephones. My career is welder, it blends with this and on occasion the ability to do higher level work is needed, its not really a real tech deal and fundamentally uses the same equipment being able to stick head in a ditch and weld a fitting on a pressure pipe in a pass or chase a hole in something upside down and under is a skill all its own as is to be able to pass welding test if needed.
It can be a welding shop, it just isnt. Last time I took a job, maybe 75 ton of misc small steel we had a small bench with no holes and about 20 clamps. A welder or 2 and a plasma cutter. Made all the jigs on plates and stood them up in the corner, designed it to use 11R and a couple screw clamps. Wouldnt and couldnt been done any faster. I bought a couple bottles whisky for Christmas at the steel yard and instead of quoting paid them by the hour for band saw and shear. I had about 50 cents a cut including shearing 75 1/4 plates. I went couple times a week with my cut list in my hot hand. I would try to dodge the manager but I ran the list, they loved it made it easy, 10 of these, to of these, 3 plates in to 10 or 12 blanks. I had about 1 thingI truely had to miter and cut the blanks square and simply plasma cut the angle and they were welded in hidden joint.
Did it all short circuit, might change that today but we designed the welding to be hidden when we could and limited to the need vs welding the **** out of every piece.
90% of our welding and fab stuff done today is one simple piece to another, chop saw 90 degree. 99.5 % of it got nothing to do with a flat bench or a hole in one. All done with common clamps that have a LOT of use in a general garage, I cant think of a thing in the last 30 years a real fixture table would have helped or really saved me 15 minutes.
Lots of guys will find this out 30 years from now. They will find out a 10 cable to a 6-50 will do every welding chore they ever did. They will find out that a whole gob of air hydrants they installed sit un used and they use the same 2 for decades.
In my own case had a fire interruption, I managed out of it with a lot of my tools barely but I did all the clean and rebuildand salvaged a lot out of need and speed and how so much worked out so much better than the plans, some I changed, some I didnt replace. I did some remodel a while back and moved some and removed more than I added. I changed a panel out and didnt include a welder outlet back on it. Put it on there in 94 or 95 and never used it. I aint putting it back "just in case"
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Some tech is so cool. A usable combo wrench and screwdrivers have gone down but the quality of econo power tools has went up. I bought my 12 yr old a battery drill from Walmart is better for 50$ than the one I paid 150 in 91 was and a 50$ drill then was about like a power screwdriver. Even 10 yrs ago and I am probably behind,,, they were not so good and the price has been going down.
Its not totally the 28 but I use it all week and can drive a big fist full of 3 inch decks for framing no problem. Sooo much lighter. I am considering another, not such a ball buster when its 50or 75$ vs 300 to have something so useful and works so well.
For some stuff used is great, for some people and some get such deals, my cousin got a 10 yr old Hobart 140, bottle, wire, hood never used, 150$, only welder he will ever need.
If a guy has it in mind to fabricate a bit more the 210 class is right on and to add would be looking for that 140 deal to get extra bottle and a machine set up 023. I got by it for long time but got one and its nice/handy. Old exhaust work and foil thin sheet makes a big difference with the smaller wire. If I got to do a change I dont bother and limp thru 030, its a thing of beauty to have it ready.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
If a guy lives where maintenance is a real problem a hoist is well worth it. Lets a guy fix problems when they come and takes so much grief out. And,,, while its tempting to wanna get every little socket the ever invented most of the real chores can be done 1/2 impact and decent socket selection, short, deep, about 3 extensions, a uni and any special swivels, bought a metric HF set a while back and used a couple.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I have chain drive cumalongs, got them long time ago after seeing what we used at work but today carry the 4T cable after trying a couple other things.
I wouldnt hesitate to spend modest down the path it took me but al less likely today to take the shotgun approach, more inclined to wait a little and run a line there iff and when I need vs setting up 100A in the back corner just in case I wanna monster tig there. Some cord use is ok, sometimes its even easier. Same for simple plug in stuff anymore, such low current a common lamp cord works and especially during set up proto type, hook it all up first, figure out what works.
 

Tduby

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
496
Location
Da U.P.
Sberry don’t take this the wrong way but are things ok honestly you use to have great advice but lately you really have just seem to go off on weird tangents and not really focus on the question asked. Again not trying to hurt feelings just a concerned guy who has noticed a change in your behavior
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
To some its a hobby and the cost or/and complication of going over the real demand is insignificant. My whole question here is mostly mechanical if someone asks,,,, is it all worth it" In the day some professional tools separated pros and now are even disposable. No need to pay a service call to someone with a bigger hammer drill,,, just buy one. Tile saw another tool as are the lifts etc.
Now the Everlast welder has come of age where its a clone of a Maxstar. They been in service a long time.
I was interested in more long term from Mechanic John. Last I knew he did so well that he sold off the HF that got him out of the hole for what he paid for it. Got all his money back and made for some good down payment on the Mac and Snap truck.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Ask me where to get a deal on some top stuff and I dont care but as we lower the cost I think the best in value goes a step below at Sears and some generic and lots a guy can even find at fleas and in white box.
You can add some assurance and a warranty on a 1.25 tool if you care but Stanley that kind of thing is really good as sockets and wrenches and even they make different models and even change some out at Walmart. Most of that stuff in there is works and been tested and they also sell a lot of brand and semi brand and HF is such a power house has forced the standards up not down as well as kept a real lid on pricing over decades.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
All the **** we use would cost 2x as much as it does now without them. The video from those guys is so so, I dont watch but the strategy of competitive vending and improving vs Sears continioually lowering their standards for a long time cause they didnt want to raise prices some when they should have which would have capitalized and fueled an upswing they sat on their ***.
Now, I dont know if I like the HF or not or how he got there the success is proof. And all on the upside to raise prices a little and make it while it shines plus can continually prove out the pieces for forensic, he aint even got to call someone to discuss deep mechanics but simply buy it from the next guy who makes a little better one.
On a scale of 1 to 7, the real value, the mechanical value with 1 being the cheapest and 7 hi is around a number 2. While the 10$ grinder works and some work longer than others and if we give some credit to power a 30$ can get pretty reliable and have sufficient power to perform journeyman level work . There is a generic model they use worldwide where people dont care, its in a white box waiting for a stamp or a sticker, kind of like brake rotors, mufflers all kinds of **** delivered thru chains with no label till it gets on the shelf at the store. Gets pulled off the same line and has a different color jacket installed in a different box going to different stores and sometimes the same, ship a box of Craftsman, box of Performax, box of Rigid all to same depot and in some cases stores.
Some raw materials went down as new mills come on and they can make so much better steel so much cheaper that its not worth it to create a new stream of tracking to save 20 a ton on raw product for some wrenches, thin the finish, create a whole line to make a difference in every raised panel built, couldnt save 25 cents to build it cheaper but can make 25$ when its sold by adding a brand stamp on it.
People had a bias in the 90's over import adjustable and we still "invested" in brands but we got some ATD worked in along the way and now that wrench, have seen it under other places has become a staple along the Proto, fit, finish, durability, all of it. The local auto store has it on the shelf about 12$ retail and it works really well.
If you would have told me 30 yrs ago would have been using a 30$ grinder and a 50$ drill I would have said no way. 40 yrs even more no way. I would have been wrong. Every generation of battery tool I had got went up in cost till I finally almost by accident tried the new econo tool and I am really impressed. Being impressed with a trinket or the top of the line is somewhat understandable, like the finest of anything and not all that long ago the semi cheap didnt function so well but use the drill doing anything cept for continious holes in a wire job for a week then 2 and you absolutely forget it felt like a toy and cost only 50$,,, thats impressive.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I am on a tangent, this is a summary of a lot of the questions on these threads, is it worth the difference in aqusition effort and if the answer is to get real work done the easiest and most economical way then no,,, ifs a different opinion or conclustion than if I like it, if its my favorite or I admire the shine or I like the driver and wanna send his kid to college.
The true value line has moved down, the quality has risin to an acceptable level with modern standards and the cost went down. Back in the day we would have said no way will this dollar wrench survive rugged service, 30 years later still in service without stripping the fukkin nut off in a hostile environment, not the hobby jeep but some now with 1000's of hard cycles on them and still perform. That is the reality,,,,,, its got so good in that respect except for a couple items I dont even want the other.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
In general work the best might not be the best for the job. Second, to support some common opinion often thought of as real fact we should see a dozen pictures a day of stripped bolts here caused by a faulty cheap tool, hell, we dont see a pile of broken HF wrenches or Stanley sockets.
I had a gob of broke older Cman if you consider 80's old, I havnt had to take a broke thing back to HF, didnt then, not worth it. I never broke a Cman wrench, broke about half a dozen China over the years where we bludgeoned them with hammers or impacts. Never by hand. I found one a while back that felt funny and I had to see if I was imagining it all and sure as **** it was stretched. It had come floating back in from somewhere it got hammered repeatedly with impact.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I remember at a power plant they had spec ordered a 1/2 ratchet that was so ****** no one wanted to steal it. The sockets were some WFit seems, the extensions good. Every once in a while some old timer seemed to have a better one but they didnt have exactly 430 and 440 Channelocks either. The Diamond number 9 was as good as a Klein, they did use that. They got Proto and Diamond adjs by the pallet.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I have walked thru a lot of business that should have bought new tools in the morning and could have roi on them by noon. Those places need more vs better really and even standardize to make it practical.
So much of the worlds work is done with simple hand tools. I did a consulting fab thing and one of the first things we said was they needed more hand tools and they already had a couple reasons that want good idea. Time for me to finish and leave with 6 workers out there fighting over 1 hammer a pair of channelocks and a utility knife. 200K sq ft and a 26 watt lamp in the place but got it going on gonna get a grant to put some real energy effecient lights in. This guy should have partnered with an engineer but he gotta be the smartest one in the room I guess, cant help those guys.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I talk to this guys secretary when they took over the place and she said,,,, he really needs to talk to you. I am on the phone about 5 minutes, said look,,, I understand you owners grand plans he starts down but you need a couple general millwright proto tech engineer types here to get off the right foot and I been in this place for 3 renovations change overs in 30 yrs including the last and most extensive and I know where all this **** goes and what it does and the utilization since I was the welding set up contractor.
Nope,, he has been talking to experts and has decided on certain energy efficient lights for each section etc. Got 10 slugs spinning their wheels in easy jobs using porto potties fer the toilet doesnt work, catches the place on fire big time. I gotta give him credit is back in business cutting up old matresses.
 

Downwindtracker 2

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2019
Messages
1,715
Location
BC
I've likely spent time in more maintenance shops than you have . Hand tools are a tradesmen's problem, if he is standing around from lack of tools, get rid of him. As a tradesman, he's likely useless. Shop tools like Bessey clamps and chain come-alongs, bite the bullet. allow for some slippage.

A lot of the time, maintenance superintendents, don't know what machine tools are for, let alone how handy they are. Big Radial Arm drill presses are a classic example. I was only in two shops with them. Another thing are portapowers. Even in my home shop, I've had a few times where I've needed one. Mills and lathes are merely nice to have.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I am sitting here trying to figure out if I can buy anything gonna make me any money. Actually talking to a guy in Australia about a John Deere.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
They are nice to have but doesnt mean a guy in the landscaping biz needs one so to speak, not saying they aint good but my neighbor has all of it, he got it to build itself and not really much work for it and it doesnt take long even for free to break even and order a part cost 150$ and get on with it. Its kind of like turning rotors sometimes. A guy depends on it is certainly another matter.
Welding is on the list ahead of machine tools,,,, hahaha.. A good plasma used to cost real money, that has went down. It doesnt have a lot for real auto repair but for salvage its potential is huge. I know there is some fascination for plasma tables but I would be lost without the hand cut of it. So zippy.
 

Attachments

  • Cary cut.JPG
    Cary cut.JPG
    56.1 KB · Views: 139
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I've likely spent time in more maintenance shops than you have . Hand tools are a tradesmen's problem, if he is standing around from lack of tools, get rid of him. As a tradesman, he's likely useless. Shop tools like Bessey clamps and chain come-alongs, bite the bullet. allow for some slippage.
All this assumes you are in a well funded industrial situation, thats different than general **** in the world where so much is so varied and blended, multi task and it trickles down to 1 stall outfits.
Lots of people going to work to do as their told and really not helped by management as much as we might want to believe.
When I slumbed around and gave a **** it usually took a week or even as much as a couple days for the ring leader to ask what I thought. I said, we got a lot of overhead here and men waiting on a hammer, I brought a hammer at some point but there is no incentive for these guys and if you really wanted to improve as fast as you could replace that fukkin comp runs all the time cause of a blown gasket and go to sears and the flea and buy 500$ in hand tools for these guys. Buuuuutttt,,, they might lose one? Buy a brand new truck and worry a guy might lose a harbor frieght screwdriver.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Where to get the best deal on the best wrench doesnt interest me as much as where to get the best wrench for the cost. Lots of other appliances the same way. I dont think its the cheapest but often found at the second cheapest in competitive categories.
I had a toaster problem a while back and did some forensics and then went and really looked at some on the shelf. B&D has a line and then maybe some kind of Silex sort of semi house brand thing with about 6 models all based on the same 2 ends, its slick as ****. Sunbeam makes a 9$ or a 10$ toaster which is junk but at 15 for the basic 2 slice a guy gets the same guts as one might get 90$ all dolled up and another section and trim level. You could do the same work for 30$ with 2 basic units. The 15$ toaster I picked outlasted the previous 25$ one that about killed me. It cost 5 more than the cheapest one but its 3x as good and good enough to brand and warrant with another free one, big deal.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Ok, been reading till i am blurry about this tractor i been working on and finally figured out how it works and whats wrong with it today. Been driving me crazy and took so much time. Solved another problem with an injection pump too makes me feel a little better about things this week.
Pic 1 was the test I was coming up with during the babble this morning.
 

Attachments

  • 20201124_120352.jpg
    20201124_120352.jpg
    63.6 KB · Views: 102
  • 20201124_120402.jpg
    20201124_120402.jpg
    72.6 KB · Views: 104
  • 20201124_120437.jpg
    20201124_120437.jpg
    60 KB · Views: 109
  • 20201201_161157.jpg
    20201201_161157.jpg
    141.5 KB · Views: 110
  • 20201202_151402.jpg
    20201202_151402.jpg
    57.4 KB · Views: 116
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Should have got pics of the inj repair but it looked a little depressing for a while then we lucked in to getting a stuck busted piece apart.
 

Attachments

  • 20201123_154201.jpg
    20201123_154201.jpg
    60.2 KB · Views: 100
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
People assume cause I own some green tractors I know how they work. I never did understand this and I am a terrible study and like a lot of things once I understand a bit more how it works some of the reading and the manuals make way more sense. Like electric, you cant really learn wiring from reading the code book, after a guy does some and learns a little the book makes more sense. I been at this a month now till I am bleary eyed,, I am just now getting some of the concept and what some of the trouble shooting actually means.
 

username2

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 22, 2016
Messages
970
I am on a tangent, this is a summary of a lot of the questions on these threads, is it worth the difference in aqusition effort and if the answer is to get real work done the easiest and most economical way then no,,, ifs a different opinion or conclustion than if I like it, if its my favorite or I admire the shine or I like the driver and wanna send his kid to college.

Probably yet another tangent, but this makes me think of the several medium big companies I've seen auger in due to a fascination with process. Very high tech boutique manufacturing. It's hard to watch someone take $100M or $1B and throw it on the fire. Taking part in the calamity can be exhilarating though.

Lotsa buying of useless hardware and software, lotsa meetings, lack of interest in the delivered product. Oftentimes it's a need to reduce mainline design work to a manufacturing line sort of philosophy, everyone is a drone, other times it's simply an organizational takeover by staff with their own kinks. In R&D it's scary to depend on a few highly competent people but the alternative is usually disaster.

Applying that thinking to my hobby life, a small hand tool box like I had in high school is probably sufficient. The smart move would be to have kept as many of the cars as possible. Watching a lot of them run through auctions and/or end up in collections as the prices go up and up is a bummer. Maybe buying high-end screwdrivers is a way to re-exert some form of control on the cheap.
 

Junkdrawer Dog

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2019
Messages
1,460
Location
LV NV
As long as we're on a tangent...I once worked for an older English gentleman who had trained as a tool and die maker and then rose through the company ranks. I was planning out a repair job that certainly looked as though it would require some special service tooling from the OEM. When I spoke to my boss about it, he chuckled and replied that sometimes, special service tools are just a substitute for imagination and initiative. He came out to my bench and together, we did the whole job with ordinary tools we already had. He did this more than once. Very valuable lesson to me at the time.
 

Ign

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
12,769
Location
Butte Peak ND
Yeah I actually really enjoy buying specialty automotive tools while simultaneously finding it kind of absurd - I mean all vehicles fall out of favor (like K-cars) or fall out of circulation through attrition if nothing else.

Some of the worst I've personally observed are GM/KM (Kent Moore) tools for incredibly obscure applications. Sometimes just searching eBay for KM stuff can be an interesting look into the not so distant past....and you know all this stuff cost hundreds or more when new.

I'm guilty of having the full KM kit for rebuilding the clutch baskets in NP246's - something that rarely needed to be done on any of those t-cases.

I've also got a KM kit for actually seeing hydraulic pressure in a p/s system. Honestly, I'll probably never use it but I got it after a particularly problematic pump and steering rack installation (actually on an '03 Chrysler mini van - sberry's flagship vehicle!)
 
Last edited:

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,053
Location
Southeastern Pa
Don't ask me how much I have invested in 2 cycle Detroit Kent Moore speciality tools...................maybe they'll come back into favor.......not :)
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
As long as we're on a tangent...I once worked for an older English gentleman who had trained as a tool and die maker and then rose through the company ranks. I was planning out a repair job that certainly looked as though it would require some special service tooling from the OEM. When I spoke to my boss about it, he chuckled and replied that sometimes, special service tools are just a substitute for imagination and initiative. He came out to my bench and together, we did the whole job with ordinary tools we already had. He did this more than once. Very valuable lesson to me at the time.

Its taken me a while to come to this kind of conclusion and its really not a conclusion but a process. I was sorting thru some specialty stuff and notice out of 150 tools a bunch a wire or a shim, etc.
 

GCS

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 12, 2014
Messages
311
Location
Oklahoma
Sometimes a bit hard, you need an interpreter. Helps that I came from a similar background to what sberry is in. Let me help you on this thread:

Farm shop is a bit different than industrial or mechanics or home hobby garage. Make things work with what you have. Cheap is good. Low cost is more important than fast; would be more important if you did the same thing every day but farm shop is always different. Have to puzzle things out because don't do them enough to master them and having the perfect tools doesn't help you there because you won't use them enough to pay for them. Keep extra materials and tools on hand, sometimes you have to try a few different before you get one to work and you can't just run to the store to get things to try. Enough stuff on hand, enough time and trying, you can usually get something to work. Best to get a lot of stuff for less money, instead of just enough good stuff for more money, what survives will surprise you and having extra is good so you don't have to go looking for it. More than one guy work out of a shop, extras good so you're not looking for stuff the other guy misplaced or waiting on him to finish. It's nice to not worry about what a tool costs or how to take care of it, just beat on it and heat it up to bend it if needed and you're not out much if you bought it cheap. You can be making money instead of waiting to be able to afford the best tool if you just buy something okay for the least money, the quality on most things today is good enough to get you by and some will amaze you with how well it lasts. A guy tries something cheap and it works, he can go for years and never remember to upgrade, nor need to. Specialty tools don't have a lot of return on investment, when I look at what I have, most of them the work could have been done with regular stuff and common stuff like wire and shims.

Did I miss anything? Still need more translation from here?


Thanks
 

SuperCat

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 6, 2012
Messages
1,100
Location
Sacramento, CA
sberry reminds me of my Dad, so practical and a lot of life experience, too. Dad had 2 bottom boxes and two top boxes. He spent money where it counted in tools, spent less for tools that got the job done for less frequent jobs, and even less for the occasional job, just good enough to get it done. I have ended up with quite a few more tools (different era cars), plus his tools and don't feel the urgent need for more. I just buy the occasional specialty tool when it is at the right price and it makes the job possible at home or speeds things up. But speed isn't always critical, it is just a "want," usually not a need, most of the time I have enough tools to make a repair, it just takes a little longer. If I need expensive specialty tools that I might never use again, I weigh the costs and might consider taking the job to a shop, it's just economics, time, safety, training, equipment, experience, etc. I 'get' what sberry is trying to say most of the time. He makes me consider all the factors in a job, not just the name on a tool or the ego of the tool owner. As is often said, the nut or the bolt doesn't care what the name on the tool is, it's going to be a pain in the tailpipe no matter what. Thinking, planning, experience, and persistence are the critical factors that determine if a problem will be resolved. Tools are a secondary factor, and the person using the tools is always the most important factor. :thumbup:
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
Some of you guys say this better than I do. It's difficult to simplify some times as we tend to pontificate. The word cheap gets used a lot but adequate is really where it's at, it has to work. I was more about better and best way earlier, I have moderated and went down the scale as econo tools have went up and as we gained experience with some of them and were really surprised at how well they worked. It has moved over now in to more sophisticated tools and the greater cost spread has become a bigger incentive to try them. Has lowered the risk and changed the rate of return numbers.
Tools that were considered investments now at disposable prices. Stuff we bought thinking to try, we had intended to upgrade have survived long term use. A lot of the speculation that they wouldn't was and is incorrect. The changes have shifted the (there is not an exact number or chart, i suspect I have a scale somewhat could be put together by an engineer) but shifted concerning quality/value in regards to getting work done and service life,,, we havnt seen the end of life for many now still in service as when they were new.
It's different than want, it's different than why people buy.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
This kind of cooked Sears to some extent with some additional factors but my point with this is,,,,,, the attitudes or assumptions, the general speculation was that the value was in the middle, I know people that say that, they are not sure why but it's what they believe.
What I mean is,,, on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being the cheapest, let's say stamped steel India combo and 10 being a Snap. People would have said the value was in the Sears of old and they would pick a number on that scale,, mostly in the middle, avg would be 5 or 6 before the quality would have been deemed usable, the 1 is not a value, it's too cheap and the 2 may not be reliable etc but if we really test today I think the value items are on 2 or 2.5 of the price scale and the quality that used to be found at 2 has hyper escalated, some has went above the ability of the user to distinguish the actual difference. The price of premium has risen but the cost of functional utility has went way down.
This has now hit welding machines and may stabilize near here, it wasn't so along ago there was a huge spread on quality but that gap is closing fast.
When the gap was greater there was more incentive to buy due to concern about value but since the shrink a lot more incentive to risk smaller amounts for greater return. When I can buy a usable wrench for the cost of sales tax on premium, maybe a pinch more I am inclined to see how good it "really" is.
This changes a lot. In some cases now don't even "want" the better and has given the opportunity to find items I actually like as good or better,, it doesn't mean inferior anymore. It means a lot of relief from the restraints of acquisition and can get return so much faster, allow immediate purchase at the point of need vs delay, less insurance, less money parked for decades in some cases. Means I don't need to pursue to get what's needed, less wait, less exposure to loss. Means it can be bought of the shelf from competitive vendors. Some cases 24 hrs a day.
If you asked me this 30 yrs ago my opinion would have differed, asked me if I could buy a pail of hydraulic oil at 3am cheaper than by the drum from the jobber would have said no, would have never believed the 50$ battery drill would have been a daily working tool in 2020 I would have said you were insane but contrary to some common belief it's here.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
We debated the difference between Miller and Lincoln and considered Hobart discount,, now we refer to Hobart as a top brand and are comparing the differences in clones and discount that cost significantly less in today's dollars than they did then. There has been a huge deflation in the common tool market while the quality has taken a huge leap.
 
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I make equity in some cases where i make speific tools. Same for some parts. I fix a lot of parts. We took the turn lever out of an old car, i call the store and it was reasonable, some generic import but 28$ and 15 minutes drive plus some wait but we pretty much standing around drinking coffee anyway so I tell the tech, take a look, bent tab and a little dirt cost a paper towel and we put it back in 10 minutes before we would get back with 40$ expense cheap **** from China etc.
If I stopped and shopped for every broke piece could not babble on here.
All of that would be slightly different if it wasnt gonna fer sure not work well enough to outlast the car.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

sberry

Banned
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
35,747
Location
Brethren, Michigan
I got a few pulled I spend some on but a collection of pieces I keep and make one I need or brackets for r an r.
I will get back to this in a bit.
Old slide hammer, really pounded and abused but had to fuzz out one little bit of something I already had fashioned and made for the ideal tool, cost 50$ from a premium set for 1 piece and only need 1 piece.
Lets see, the other is a stand for tractor splits, tacked on all its extra extensions. I am going to stop a hour or so and hunt up some of this and burn thru a can of yellow and mark them all as tools.
I am going to use the wheel and make new pipe and bracket for a different job. I got 3 or 4 jobs I use that same piece. There are some flats on the threaded bolt thru it, can adjust height without turning the wheel and steer without changing height.
 

Attachments

  • 20201204_095720.jpg
    20201204_095720.jpg
    58.1 KB · Views: 40
  • 20201203_153024.jpg
    20201203_153024.jpg
    64.5 KB · Views: 34
  • 20201203_153010.jpg
    20201203_153010.jpg
    76.1 KB · Views: 38
  • 20201204_104502.jpg
    20201204_104502.jpg
    43.3 KB · Views: 34
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom