I am getting ready to build a 40x40 and really like the look of split face block. Does anyone have experience with it? Any leaks in the block? Any responses will be greatly appreciated.
As some others have stated, most big-box stores use split-face. This started happening when people began expressing concerns over the boring/industrial looks of the large buildings. Now most of those stores have architectural elements in an attempt to make them look more like several smaller buildings. They use sf block to help enhance the appearance, but most of them still paint over the face of the block.
SF block are a little heavier than standard block because they have to be molded as a larger unit, then split into two or more 8x8x16 blocks. The walls need to be thicker to withstand the stress of the splitting process.
Most small-time masons don't like it because they need to pay much more attention to the order. Gray smooth block is kept in stock, including halves, solid-bottom-bond-beam blocks (for over doors and windows), and knock-out-bond-beam block (for horizontal rebar). So if they need more, they can just run down to the manufacturer and buy a few.
With split-face, most manufacturers keep limited quantities on hand, especially if it is colored block. If they tool up to run a custom color for a project, they will charge a great deal of money to make more of something if a few are needed. Technically, a mason needs to ensure they order the correct quantity of corners (split on one face and one end), and solid-bottom block (if halves are not preferred) for a sf project, the rest of the shapes can be cut out of the standard split-face units. Masons would rather have all the special pieces pre-made instead of having to cut them, but the manufacturers don't like running small quantities, and may charge an additional set-up for each.
Apples to apples, there shouldn't be much of a labor upcharge. Some of that comes from the additional weight of each block, but most of it comes from the addtional planning and layout that is required to make a sf project look good. Feedback from my masons was usually mixed, but most liked split-face because they only needed to focus on keeping one side of the wall (the smooth face) pretty. The other side is supposed to look rough and irregular. With smooth block, masons need to ensure both sides of the wall look good. This can be difficult because 8" block is actually 7 5/8" wide, with some variance, especially from different batches. So they could be laying a 7 1/2" wide block on top of a 7 9/16" block.
All that being said, colored split-face block is beautiful. If you intend to paint the exterior, it would not be worth the additional cost of using sf. Even when gray block is split, it exposes the multi-colored aggregate for a more beautiful finish.