To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Stihl MS170

TomB19

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 1, 2015
Messages
547
Location
Regina, SK, Canada
Any good?

I need to fell a few 12" trees and cut them into chunks small enough to band saw into usable wood.

Any saw I get will end up cutting 3~10 treed in it's life and perhaps trim a couple of large bushes a time or two.

I don't want to spend a bunch of money but I don't want a saw that is frustrating, either.

Any info is appreciated. :thumbup:
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

LawnBoy-5247

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 20, 2016
Messages
303
Location
Kansas City
The MS170 is a good saw especially if you don't expect to use it much. If you foresee using a saw a little more you may consider stepping up to a MS250 or MS251 which are also excellent saws.

Sent from my LGLS991 using Tapatalk
 

Jazz1

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
4,184
Location
Thunder Bay On.
The MS170 is definitely up to task for the little use you have planned.
I have had a Stihl 009 for 20 years. Its a small saw that has taken on many larger tasks. No issues ever and I cut firewood for heating garage so it cuts a few cords each year. The ECHO saws are also very good and still have adjustable carbs.
 
Last edited:

PNWguy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2018
Messages
494
Location
Near Grants Pass, OR
For so few trees, I wonder if renting a saw is an option? Or would it be less expensive to hire somebody to cut the trees than to buy a saw?

Stihl makes good saws, and so does Husky. On the lower end of things, Echo also makes a good one, but they generally won't last as long.
 

themiller

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 24, 2012
Messages
4,805
Location
Seattle Suburbs
Electric.

I have a 180 or 170 (can’t remember). Intermittent use, albeit a bit more than you. Only use Stihl ethanol free premix. It needs new carbs every 3-5 years. First carb replacement carb was warrantied. Guy told me he’d see me again in 3 years. On the 3rd carb now.
 

finn

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
16,187
Location
The UP, God's country
Go to Home Depot and rent a Makita for the day.

Even a Walmart Poulan will cut 12 trees with no problem.
 
Last edited:

bob15

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 8, 2011
Messages
6,863
Location
Northeasten, CT
For so few trees, I wonder if renting a saw is an option? Or would it be less expensive to hire somebody to cut the trees than to buy a saw?

Stihl makes good saws, and so does Husky. On the lower end of things, Echo also makes a good one, but they generally won't last as long.

I have to disagree, the Echo saws are as every bit as good as stihl & husky and will last just as long. And if you really want to talk saws and longevity, find a McCulloch.
 

Boilerhouse

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2012
Messages
1,320
Location
Muskoka
If this saw is only cutting up 10 trees in its entire life, you really should consider renting. Whatever you rent will likely be properly maintained and work well. I don't think it is great for a chainsaw to sit for years between uses. I personally own a 30 y.o. Stihl, model 032. It blocks up 100 twenty foot logs a year. Overkill for what you are looking for but it does start and run great.
 

fast one

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 13, 2011
Messages
69
Location
MD
The only experience I have with the 170 is at work, that is what they buy us. I work for a electric utility as a lineman.

We use them to cut cross arms, poles up and trees/brush as needed. They have been very reliable.
 

2mJps

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
1,797
Location
north central Mo
The 170 is a good saw but i have a walmart poulan that i cut wood for 2 wood stove. It has been used hard for 7 years. The bad thing for alot of saws is seating around so i would buy the cheapest thing or remt one.
 

rk5n

Active member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
39
My friend bought me one in exchange for helping him for the day. Both of us were impressed with the little saw and it cut down a few 12" trees no problem. Where it really excels is cutting off the limbs since it's so light.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

CR888

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 19, 2017
Messages
1,198
Mmmm....Chinese made homeowner grade Stihl & Husky saws will outlast Japan made Echo saws.....that's a good one!! Echo may not produce class leading saws however their build qaulity has a VERY strong reputation, and that goes back decades.
 

Davefr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
11,817
Location
OR
I have to disagree, the Echo saws are as every bit as good as stihl & husky and will last just as long. And if you really want to talk saws and longevity, find a McCulloch.

Agree. For small chainsaws I think Echo makes a better product then the small homeowner grade Stihls and Husky's. However Echo falls short when it comes to professional grade saws. (primarily power to weight ratio)

P.S. The MS170 is a fine homeowner saw. It's very light and nimble. It's a good one to have alongside a MS361.
 
Last edited:

WWheeler

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
4,105
Location
Middleofnowhere USA
Mmmm....Chinese made homeowner grade Stihl & Husky saws will outlast Japan made Echo saws.....that's a good one!! Echo may not produce class leading saws however their build qaulity has a VERY strong reputation, and that goes back decades.

What?

My Stihls come straight off the line in VA Beach VA.
 

Davefr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
11,817
Location
OR
Now I'm reconsidering 120V.

Thank you for the great comments in this thread. I appreciate it.

I'd reconsider again. IMHO 120V is the worst way to go right now.

I'd look at Lithium battery powered saws for occasional small jobs.

I bought the Lowes Kobalt 40V pole saw and am thoroughly impressed with it. I'm going to add their 12"chainsaw since I already have the battery and charger from the pole saw.

These Lithium saws don't take the place of a professional grade 2 cycle gas saws for larger jobs but they're sure handy for small jobs.
 

kctyphoon

Banned
Joined
Jun 9, 2014
Messages
9,102
Location
Jersey/Staten Island
If a cord is an option, you can get a cheap 14" homelite or Remington for like $50 -$70 I think. I mean, I've used them to cut up telephone poles, so a few trees won't be any issue.

Any gas saw will do just fine, you'll just need to decide how much you wanna spend, and if you wanna buy what you WANT or just what will work.. you'd be surprised just how well cheaper saws perform. As long as the blade is sharp they work surprisingly well. Trick really is to make sure they don't hit anything they shouldn't. Even dirt. The blades spin so fast that if hit the wrong thing for just a second, it can seriously impact the cutting ability of the saw - and that's true for every chainsaw.

But yes, I can tell you from experience that even the cheapest electrics work pretty good. I don't think cordless is a good choice for you. If you have nothing else to use with the battery and charger - you negate the benefit of buying part of a cordless system, and now you're paying a lot just for the one battery you can't use on anything else. If you think it's worth the convenience to pay that price anyway - then go for it.

This thing is pretty decent believe it or not. We used one for like 2 years to cut poles up. It's only $49. You can get a reconditioned one for $39, or opt for the bigger 16" model for $75.. it is NOT a professional or premium equivalent. But it's a good homeowner grade corded saw.. the only thing that did ours in was 7' or water from Sandy cause someone brought it home from work for the storm.. lol.. you really just need to let the saw work at its pace, and not force it down faster then it can cut.. its simple to do, just don't push down so hard that the motor bogs down so much that it's obviously struggling.

https://www.homedepot.com/p/Homelite-14-in-9-Amp-Electric-Chainsaw-UT43103A/202723256

The 16" is obviously a bigger saw, but the 14" is nice and small.. you can buy a gas echo or stihl if you want to, but if it's just gonna sit around for years the electric is probably better. The best corded electric to get right now is a makita. It's built like a tank - but the overload protection is very sensitive and REALLY annoying. Home Depot rents these models out - most likely cause it's idiot proof and will shut off at the slightest degree of excessive pressure.

With years at work using electric chainsaws, we've had the Homelite, Remington, Milwaukee, Makita, Husqvarna, and Stihl... between all the different trucks and crews at work. Handful of gas as well for use on the ground. The electric aren't as fast as the bigger gas saws we had, but like I said - they do work very well.
 
Last edited:

WWheeler

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
4,105
Location
Middleofnowhere USA
Yes but does your MS170 come from Vaginia Beach VA?

I don't own any homeowner-grade saws. That said, Stihl's page for the MS170 on the 'features' tab says it's made in the USA and if you click the 'More information' tab they introduce you to some of the people who work at their VA Beach plant.

https://www.stihlusa.com/products/chain-saws/homeowner-saws/ms170/

It's been a few years since I used to live near the VA Beach plant and knew many people who worked there, but it's been my understanding that all but their largest saws sold in the US are manufactured in the US (no doubt with many global parts), and the larger ones that aren't are made in Germany, and IIRC their chains are all still made in Switzerland. I'm sure someone will correct me if any of that has changed.
 

CR888

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 19, 2017
Messages
1,198
Yeah your right. Here in oz the ms170 comes from their China factory. But the US Vaginia Beach facility produces all home/ranch & some pro models along with blowers, weedeaters etc. The models they don't produce are the 201tcm arborist top handle/reach handle, ms150 and the large pro saws from ms441 up (441, 461, 661, 880). I have a few vaginia beach items bg86/bg56, MS261, and my Aussie delivered attachment power head km94 was from Vag Beach. While a mate sent me my VA saws over here, I have 2 ms261's, 1 from Germany & 1 from VA. Other than the crankcase COO sticker, the saws are identical despite coming out of 2 different factories. Stihl is good and kinda mastered global manufacturing. Even the stuff out of China is consistent with Germany. My beef with Stihl is all the little parts like bearings are no longer top shelf INA, Koyo or SKF but rather cheap China made no names. I've found this on Pro grade equipment from VA & Germany. But that's another story. While the ms170 has sold many units, for the money I think Dolmar or Echo will give you a better saw. Even a 5020 Poulan is a good saw for the $$.
 

bpjr

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2013
Messages
554
Location
Florida east coast
Renting or buying electric is probably your best bet. Otherwise a homeowner grade gas Craftsman or Poulan Pro (same) will do fine and save you money. I do way more than a couple 12" diameter trees a yr (especially after hurricanes and tropical storms) and use Craftsman saws. Bought 3 of them since the mid 1970s. The first was dropped from a tree on concrete and broke the case. The 2nd was purchased in the 1980s and still runs like new...the only repair was a new $10 clutch after 20 yrs. The 3rd I bought 5-6 yrs ago just because I wanted a new saw. They have been as reliable and user friendly as my newer Stihl and Echo 2 stroke equipment. Homeowner grade equipment is more about user error than the equipment being inferior.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom