Maybe they should go after those who are buying the stolen merchandise.
That will slow thefts down much faster.
Claiming "I didn't know it was stolen" doesn't really fly, at least in Indiana.
How the hell is a person supposed to know the items are stolen?
Most of the time, you can’t find a list of serial numbers to check an item against, let alone a “description list” which might not work well for items sold in the tens of thousands, but which would potentially work for obscure items and tools.
Someone’s initials drawn in sharpie on a tool doesn’t really cut it, since plenty of people sell, dive away, or pawn old tools, and never bother removing sharpie marks or other identifying marks.
Serial number plates sometimes get damaged due to use, or cleaning messy tools.
Price isn’t necessarily a determining factor, since plenty of places offer discounts from time to tome which flippers take advantage of, and there are also closeout deals, tools that get surplussed, sherif’s sales, etc.
Businesses sometimes purchase batches of tools for expected jobs or to keep tools on hand, then when things get tight, or a job gets cancelled, tools wind up on eBay.
Most manufacturers want little to nothing to do with assisting a buyer of a surplussed or second hand tool from determining if the tool might have been stolen.
This isn’t like in the 1700s and 1800s, where craft guilds required members to mark their tools, and then kept a registry of the tools and make if the Guild member’s tools got stolen, which was done because the craft guild insured or partially insured guild members tools.
Not being able to purchase or posses “old tools” because you were not the original purchaser, and you might get arrested and charged with possessing stolen property simply means a huge amount of old tool waste on the market.