As a matter of company policy we believe it to be unprofessional to compare our product to a product we don't sell. The product you speak of is a great product. So are Daytona as well as others. I've sold many types of garage tiles and if I were using a garage tile in my own garage I would use Swisstrax.
I can absolutely list what I believe the highlights of Swisstrax to be for you, but as I do not sell the product you reference, how would it be fair for me to say what it will or won't do?
The car industry has basic facts that can be presented based on industry testing. 0-60, Federal Tests, etc. When it comes to tile, you have thickness (both products are 1/2", you have material: Both products are a polypropylene, number of locks: Swisstrax has 5, ability of product to resist stains: Swisatrax guarantees it.
Additional information:
Warranty: 12 year limited
Material: Polypropylene copolymer
Chemical Resistance: (UV Stabilized)
Alkalis - Excellent
Oil, Gas & other Auto Fluids - Excellent
Acids / Solvents - Good
Tile Weight: 17.5 ounces
Tile Size: 13" square
Slide: Non Slip
Temperature Tolerances: -22F + 248F
Compressive Strength: 5120 psi
Fire Rating: UL94 (USA) or BS476 - part 7 - class 1 (UK)
Most other statements are a matter of opinion. Just like in your example the only way to truly get an answer is to go for a test drive! You seem like an intelligent individual. I’m sure you would not buy one car over another just because the manufacturer says its better?