To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Thoughts on a new socket set

kctgb

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2024
Messages
305
There have been a lot of suggestions , a lot to digest in this thread. There are probably 100's of options of mix and match. Now this set might not meet the criteria of something you'll want to leave your grandchildren, and its made in Taiwan. I have Milwaukee's 1/4" set in my truck and it's a pretty nice ratchet. This 3/8" drive set meets some of your criteria ,and it's cheap enough you could buy a set for more than one grandchild:

https://www.acmetools.com/milwaukee...iaRMF1r4uP2pqMaAknFEALw_wcB&slasRedirect=true
That’s a very good price for a Milwaukee socket set. I want to know how much for shipping? Where I live that price is a dream.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

liliysdad

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Messages
5,378
Cars are metric, so are appliance electronics, furnaces and pretty well everything. The only place you see imperial is lumber and DIY stuff at HD. I am sure you come up with some examples that are still imperial. They will be old designs. Those companies will be out of business if they are not re-designing regularly. My best example, is we built a house and we have a German boiler for heat. Three separate plumbers said US was overpriced and not as good. But heck, the execs got a nice quarterly bonus for their bottom line as a result of not investing in the future of the company.
Farm implements are SAE. The majority of domestically produced lawn and garden equipment is SAE. US manufactured firearms and accessories are almost exclusively SAE. A lot of aftermarket auto accessories are dimensionally SAE. One of the largest manufacturers of oilfield equipment designs and builds their entire line in inch based measurements with SAE fasteners and hardware.

This only mentions the new stuff out there. There are a lot of folks still working on really old stuff, and that doesn’t simply stop being relevant because industry moves away from that standard. Hardware stores sell SAE hardware 10 to 1 over metric. SAE taps and dies and inch based drill bits easily outsell metric equivalents.

SAE isn’t going anywhere any time soon.
 

alinc100

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2013
Messages
3,020
Location
Dearborn,MI
That’s a very good price for a Milwaukee socket set. I want to know how much for shipping? Where I live that price is a dream.
After tax it shows $91.26 delivered. By contrast it is $106 at Home Depot, Ace hardware shows it for $80 + tax with free shipping to store.
 

kctgb

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2024
Messages
305
After tax it shows $91.26 delivered. By contrast it is $106 at Home Depot, Ace hardware shows it for $80 + tax with free shipping to store.
That’s not a bad price for a Milwaukee socket set.
 

Tynee

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
979
Location
In the Heart of the Bluegrass
Ok I had to know. Metric Craftsman 11mm-19mm, Williams Taiwan quick release ratchet, Craftsman 3/8" thru 3/4",dewalt case linked above=
Oops, replied before I saw this post.

That looks handy if you need to take stuff with you. I bet you could fit a 1/4 drive ratchet and some sockets in there, and reduce the space they have to float around.
 

BobsYourUncle69

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 21, 2023
Messages
411
Location
Westchester New York
For my two cents op...
You don't say where you are from in your post I have no idea if you live in the USA or other parts of the World. Some of those fancy nice products are super, super fantastic, that is until they break, and you got to send them in for replacements and then the long wait sometimes.

If I was in your shoes and I lived in the USA, and money was lying all over the ground then a snap-on set would fit the bill. On the other hand, if money was tight and you are not a billionaire, then I would stop in a HF store and pick up their new G2 ratchets and give Tekton a call for one of their complete socket sets.

If money was very tight, then I would hit garage sales and stock up on old school names, trust me it will be slow going but you can put together some great sets. Been there done that.
The Tekton sets really seem like great value for money, that 1/2 6pt socket set 10-38mm is damn good value @$100 and they seem to have a very good lifetime warranty.
 

jblnut

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Jan 17, 2015
Messages
6,969
Location
In the Middle of MN
Good grief there are a lot of very passionate replies in this thread. I started with a set like yours and added random things over the years until I finally bit the bullet and purchased a USA Craftsman master set with 6 and 12pt, screw drivers, nut drivers and way more things than I can remember. Beyond that I’ve added a few fine tooth ratchets and larger stuff as needed.

Don’t over think this. If I were to do it today I’d look at Tekton and Sunex for everything 1/2” and under. I have Stark impact sockets in 3/4” drive that have seem some serious abuse and look great. I just purchased a 1” Stark impact set and am pumped to put them to work. Meanwhile the Craftsman
Set is still here and rocking it to the shop radio.

Farm implements are SAE.

SAE isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.

Eh not everything is SAE. We have many things with wheels with 33mm lug bolts and other misc metric stuff scattered around. Gotta have big SAE and big Metric stuff in the farm shop. I just added a 1” SAE impact set that goes up to 3-1/8” and ordered a few random Metric sockets for specific things. I have a full 3/4” drive metric impact set up to 45mm for the oddball stuff that’s quite tight.

Agreed on the SAE sticking around but it’s getting muddier every year.
 

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,729
Location
SE PA
Williams is the right answer I think.

I bought a rubber bellows way cover for my mill on eBay. Like to get another and now shipping is $150 where it was free a few months ago. Assume it’s a tariff.

Anyone seeing tariffs on tools? How might a tariff change the recommendations? Anyone panic buying any items?

I remember during Covid, my favorite HF nitrile gloves were either unavailable or really expensive and I wished I had an extra box.

Above makes Williams an even easier answer.
 
OP
J

jasonrohrer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
119
Ok I had to know. Metric Craftsman 11mm-19mm, Williams Taiwan quick release ratchet, Craftsman 3/8" thru 3/4",dewalt case linked above=

Ah, good to see the DeWalt case in action for this purpose...

Am I missing something, or is there a whole bunch of rattling and socket-mixing going on, especially in the bigger subdivision of this case?
 

Hohn

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
2,630
Location
Diesel Central, Indiana
I have a drawer full of impact sockets and a drawer full of chromes.

I’ve never once grabbed an impact for use on a ratchet if a chrome was an option. I’ve no desire to use a thick, heavy, clunky impact socket when other options exist.

To each their own, but every time I see that advice, I’m confused by it.
I actually went the opposite direction.

I had nothing but chrome for ages. Since acquiring some good impact sockets, I always reach for the impacts first. Preference is hard to account for.
 
OP
J

jasonrohrer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
119
There have been a lot of suggestions , a lot to digest in this thread. There are probably 100's of options of mix and match. Now this set might not meet the criteria of something you'll want to leave your grandchildren, and its made in Taiwan. I have Milwaukee's 1/4" set in my truck and it's a pretty nice ratchet. This 3/8" drive set meets some of your criteria ,and it's cheap enough you could buy a set for more than one grandchild:

https://www.acmetools.com/milwaukee...iaRMF1r4uP2pqMaAknFEALw_wcB&slasRedirect=true

Adam Savage loves this set, or a similar one, here:


Goes to show that plastic cases CAN be well-designed! I agree that the design of this set looks stellar.

I'm just not a fan of "American" companies like Milwaukee that have turned into 100% importers. I only have one M tool in my shop, and it's one of the last US-made Sawzalls.

I'm also not a fan of "Japanese" companies like Makita that do the same thing. Festool has started doing it too, and it leaves a bad taste, ESPECIALLY when there's no price drop to go along with it. Festool prices for something made in Vietnam? Really?

I actually don't mind buying Chinese-made stuff, but it better have Chinese writing on the box, not the name of a Proud American City. The few Chinese things that I've bought recently have been shipped to me directly from China, in a weirdly over-taped box with a customs form glued to it.

Like, if I can get a "Fluke" thermal camera for $2000, or a Chinese brand for $400 with the better features that's made in the same Chinese factory with almost identical tooling, I'd rather go direct.

I feel like Fluke is trying to fool me, especially when it comes to price.

All these American companies bury the COO label deep in the fine print.

To unpack the price thing a bit more.... WHAT AM I PAYING FOR? Expensive materials? Okay, sure. The guy who polished this gets paid $30/hour? Okay, I get that. But when the guy is getting paid $2/hour, and the out-of-the-factory price is $8, I'm wondering where the other $92 is going for the $100 item. Transit and middle men is the answer.

Like, take a look at this stepladder factory:


I've been inside the Bauer Ladder factory in Wooster, Ohio, and... it was nothing like this. The workers weren't barefoot, for starters. It was clean and well-lit. I'm pretty sure that I'm paying for *that* when the Bauer ladder is more expensive.

So buying something from Wright or Ko-Ken is an FU to these bait-and-switch, high-priced tricksters. At least that's one facet of it, for me.

It's become a fun game: can I find something NOT made in China? Can I fill my workshop shop with non-Chinese stuff? Can I clothe my person in non-Chinese stuff? American Giant does make a really nice hoodie! I just got some shoes for Salsa dancing with my wife, and they were made in Brazil. ProTec and Benchmade knives. Lamy and Uniball pens.... there's some amazing stuff out there!

On the other hand, if you want the best drone in the world.... at least DJI is a Chinese company... Da-Jiang Innovations.

If there was a ratchet with Da-Jiang stamped on it, I might consider it...
 
Last edited:

Hohn

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
2,630
Location
Diesel Central, Indiana
I'm just not a fan of "American" companies like Milwaukee that have turned into 100% importers. I only have one M tool in my shop, and it's one of the last US-made Sawzalls.
I have an 11 amp Super Sawzall from 2001 and a matching 8 Amp magnum 1/2" drill. Both MI USA early 2000s and both some of my favorite corded tools. Why did they have to get rid of the quick-lok cord?
 

Kscardsfan

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 28, 2020
Messages
1,650
Location
The Little Apple
Depends on where you are....Used SAE sells just as fast as Metric here, and there is very little price difference. Ag and Oil is still very much SAE centric.

As far as "nicer," everyone has their definition. For me, I prefer US made tools while fully acknowledging that comparable quality can be had off shore. Like anything, the law of diminishing returns applies to tools as well.

I like having higher end truck and industrial brand tools simply because I like them. Could I do the same work with Husky and Pittsburgh? Sure, but if I don't want to, why should I? Why should the original poster? I prefer to wear nice shoes, carry a nice pocket knife, wear a decent watch, and use good tools to fix things.
I got a Proto set for less than $50 a few weeks ago. If you do your searching it's pretty easy to find. I'm in the same boat, I'd rather buy American if it's all the same. I am also in a unique spot where I don't Need much of anything for my tools now, it's a want. I just can't say that out loud still. And damned sure can't say it around my wife.
 

Citation

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2016
Messages
3,212
Location
Indy
I know I'm late to this discussion so forgive me if I'm asking a repeat question. Why replace vs getting tools that complement what you already have. A while back I wanted to upgrade my old Cman raised panel ratchet. At first I got a Husky similar to the old in the original post. It's not a bad ratchet and in general was an upgrade. However, I then started looking around here... :D
What I realized is there are other ratchets that would help a while lot more than just a nicer version of what I already have. I got a Stanley extendable, locking flex head. It's a great ratchet when I need more leverage. I don't take advantage of the flex part much. When I need a flex head I typically grab my rotohead ratchet. If all you have is fixed head ratchets, a roto or flex head can be a game changer in some places.

In the end I actually use my old Cman ratchet perhaps more than the Husky replacement because it's a bit shorter. The shorter part was an issue when it was my only ratchet. However, with my current selection the Husky doesn't provide any unique advantage over my other options. If I need the extra lever arm I'll use the extendable. If I need to with around obstacles I'll use the roto. If I just want to spin a bolt off I'll use the Cman because it's shorter and lighter.

So consider getting different types of ratchets (and/or sockets) that provide an ability the current stuff can't do.
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,556
Location
nd
Cars are metric, so are appliance electronics, furnaces and pretty well everything. The only place you see imperial is lumber and DIY stuff at HD. I am sure you come up with some examples that are still imperial. They will be old designs. Those companies will be out of business if they are not re-designing regularly. My best example, is we built a house and we have a German boiler for heat. Three separate plumbers said US was overpriced and not as good. But heck, the execs got a nice quarterly bonus for their bottom line as a result of not investing in the future of the company.
why do people refuse to believe there are places that sae exists and anyone using it is old, out of date and going out of business?

example. i have a salford liberty bbi fertilizer spreader that is 2 years old. my neighbor just bought a new one. it is very well made and works very well and yes modern design. both are 100% sae or if they are not i have not run across something that isn't. shafts, bearing, pillow blocks, tires, hydraulic fittings, hydraulic cylinders, roll tarp. etc.

i fully understand metric is prevalent. most of my tractors are. but...... it is just plain ridiculous to assume that unless it is metric it is old fashioned, out of date, poorly designed and the mfg will be lights out short order.

my point being. just because you claim to have a better made in germany metric boiler we should just accept your word as gospel yet one someone has new new equipment that uses sae it is somehow subpar. i would bet your meric boiler uses sae pipe thread and the actual plumbing and is dimensionally sae. using your logic your plumbing would be sub par.
 

Dave455

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
5,800
Location
Sussex, England
I'm just not a fan of "American" companies like Milwaukee that have turned into 100% importers.
In fairness, Milwaukee are not an American company, they’re a Chinese one. Have been for about 20 years. Sadly, if someone sells the family silver, they can’t complain about what the new owner does with it.

I'm also not a fan of "Japanese" companies like Makita that do the same thing.
Makita are very different. Makita make tools in different grades, for different purposes. I have probably ten different Makita power tools, and I think only two (one being an inexpensive palm sander) were made in China.

The remainder are made in Romania, Germany, the U.K. and Japan.

Of my angle grinders, the cheapest is made in Romania, the best in Japan. You get what you pay for, although even the Romanian grinders are decent.

I’ve noticed similar comments from other members before though, and I wonder if Makita sell predominantly their lower end tools in the U.S? Or whether folks are buying them from stores that only stock the lower end tools?
Festool has started doing it too, and it leaves a bad taste, ESPECIALLY when there's no price drop to go along with it. Festool prices for something made in Vietnam? Really?
I’m with you there.

Festool is different to Makita etc.

With Makita, you only pay Makita Money. That will be ”Made in Japan” money for a Japanese tool, or ”Made in China” money for a Chinese tool.

Festool is “ Made in Germany” money (possibly plus a bit). If I’m paying that, and the tool isn’t made there, it’s going straight back.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

alinc100

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2013
Messages
3,020
Location
Dearborn,MI
Ah, good to see the DeWalt case in action for this purpose...

Am I missing something, or is there a whole bunch of rattling and socket-mixing going on, especially in the bigger subdivision of this case?
Ok since you were not satisfied with the first iteration, my OCD kicked in further this morning. Sockets are now 5/16" thru 13/16", 9mm thru 21mm on rails, 3" and 6" extensions, a universal, 3/8" Williams ratchet, 3/8" sliding tee bar, all with a piece of drawer liner on the bottom to minimize shifting. After 3 pages of drivel, mine included ,I believe you are suffering from paralysis by analysis. I don't know what else this forum could offer you other than the 3 pages of offerings. Something like this Snap On service set ,while great only gets you SAE or Metric. Maybe someone could chime in if they have a new offering with both runs of sockets. https://www.ebay.com/itm/3358390042...TkXj2oIUreYXxerDerlogJ4cb8vwzU54aAhdHEALw_wcB
 

Attachments

  • 20250422_102756.jpg
    20250422_102756.jpg
    1,022.7 KB · Views: 20
  • 20250422_102759.jpg
    20250422_102759.jpg
    938.2 KB · Views: 18
  • 20250422_102803.jpg
    20250422_102803.jpg
    783 KB · Views: 32

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,729
Location
SE PA
Not sure if this will help or not:

Several times I've posted pictures of my mobile tool sets I made up when I lived in the UK. I used random clear topped plastic storage cases and lined them with foam yoga mats, cut-out for the tools I wanted to carry. It was my belief and experience that when I needed a socket to fix something, I also needed a couple ratchets, extensions, but also bit sockets, a screwdriver, flashlight, small prybar or plastic prybars, and maybe a pair of pliers.

If I were to do it all over again, and I might: I'd start with something like a thin Milwaukee pack out or other interlocking tool box.

The nice things about a DIY set are:
  • ability to choose tools independent of their packaging
  • The "small parts" style boxes with foam can have WAY more tool density than the roto molded cases that come with Taiwan sets
  • You can include more than just sockets and the one ratchet you get with the set
  • The cases I built had open bins for stuff. Not everything was in a shadow style situation. That was fast and easy to use.
  • Stuff like sockets were WAY more usable, easier to access and put back. I also arranged tools based on typical usage not size. For example: I had 2 rows of 3/8" sockets with 8, 10, 13, 17, 19, 21 on the top and 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 18 on the bottom. At the time I had no Asian vehicles and VAG cars didn't yet use ISO sizes (16/18mm etc).
Right now, I can't fit my Bobcat in my garage. I have it parked in my construction materials area. So when I work on it, which is almost every time I use it, I need to go fetch tools. I could totally see slapping together a new mobile tool kit with SAE tools custom chosen for the Bobcat. I could also see buying a matching white US general 5 drawer cart, solely with the tools needed to maintain this thing, since, as @sk farmer said, its mostly SAE. I assume the engine (Kubota) is metric.

PS- important to add: my garage is where I will soon be back to fixing cars. My automotive boxes are 99% metric, which is why I kinda need SAE tools for vehicle repair for the first time in decades. I own SAE tools, but they are in my machine shop, which isn't convenient to either the garage or the bobcat. So if anyone is questioning WHY one might need a mobile tool kit IN ADDITION TO full toolboxes, this explanation may help.
 

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,729
Location
SE PA
Lowes has a Komelon tape with metric. It’s a nice tape measure, sometimes working in metric is simpler than fractions.
A lot of US kitchen cabinet builders (pros and amateurs) have switched to metric. All the hardware is metric and some of the power tools are metric (like Festool stuff). I have kitchen cabinets to build but don't have any of that stuff and I think in fractions of an inch so I will probably stay imperial (if that's the right word).

I think US carpenters will stay in inches for the foreseeable future, but some other sorts of tradesmen may go metric.

BTW, can you buy a metric tape measure in Home Depot with US Dollars or do you need to pay with Euros?
 

Tynee

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
979
Location
In the Heart of the Bluegrass
Ok since you were not satisfied with the first iteration, my OCD kicked in further this morning. Sockets are now 5/16" thru 13/16", 9mm thru 21mm on rails, 3" and 6" extensions, a universal, 3/8" Williams ratchet, 3/8" sliding tee bar, all with a piece of drawer liner on the bottom to minimize shifting. After 3 pages of drivel, mine included ,I believe you are suffering from paralysis by analysis. I don't know what else this forum could offer you other than the 3 pages of offerings. Something like this Snap On service set ,while great only gets you SAE or Metric. Maybe someone could chime in if they have a new offering with both runs of sockets. https://www.ebay.com/itm/3358390042...TkXj2oIUreYXxerDerlogJ4cb8vwzU54aAhdHEALw_wcB
That's awesome.
 

sk farmer

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2009
Messages
5,556
Location
nd
Not sure if this will help or not:

Several times I've posted pictures of my mobile tool sets I made up when I lived in the UK. I used random clear topped plastic storage cases and lined them with foam yoga mats, cut-out for the tools I wanted to carry. It was my belief and experience that when I needed a socket to fix something, I also needed a couple ratchets, extensions, but also bit sockets, a screwdriver, flashlight, small prybar or plastic prybars, and maybe a pair of pliers.

If I were to do it all over again, and I might: I'd start with something like a thin Milwaukee pack out or other interlocking tool box.

The nice things about a DIY set are:
  • ability to choose tools independent of their packaging
  • The "small parts" style boxes with foam can have WAY more tool density than the roto molded cases that come with Taiwan sets
  • You can include more than just sockets and the one ratchet you get with the set
  • The cases I built had open bins for stuff. Not everything was in a shadow style situation. That was fast and easy to use.
  • Stuff like sockets were WAY more usable, easier to access and put back. I also arranged tools based on typical usage not size. For example: I had 2 rows of 3/8" sockets with 8, 10, 13, 17, 19, 21 on the top and 9, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 18 on the bottom. At the time I had no Asian vehicles and VAG cars didn't yet use ISO sizes (16/18mm etc).
Right now, I can't fit my Bobcat in my garage. I have it parked in my construction materials area. So when I work on it, which is almost every time I use it, I need to go fetch tools. I could totally see slapping together a new mobile tool kit with SAE tools custom chosen for the Bobcat. I could also see buying a matching white US general 5 drawer cart, solely with the tools needed to maintain this thing, since, as @sk farmer said, its mostly SAE. I assume the engine (Kubota) is metric.

PS- important to add: my garage is where I will soon be back to fixing cars. My automotive boxes are 99% metric, which is why I kinda need SAE tools for vehicle repair for the first time in decades. I own SAE tools, but they are in my machine shop, which isn't convenient to either the garage or the bobcat. So if anyone is questioning WHY one might need a mobile tool kit IN ADDITION TO full toolboxes, this explanation may help.
interesting comment. bobcats main usa skid steer mfg plant is about 40 minutes from me and a satellite location is about 15 minutes from me. my buddy in sales call on both. i don't own one so will not say one way or another what hardware they use. i assume they are mostly if not all metric. i know many 3rd party attachments are sae.

i just had a mobile air conditioning mechanic here to replace a cracked fitting on a caterpillar 55 tractor. it is about 99% metric. the guy works on anything and everything. guess what? sae ac fittings. i looked in his tool bag and van. hardly any metric in it. just saying.
 

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,729
Location
SE PA
interesting comment. bobcats main usa skid steer mfg plant is about 40 minutes from me and a satellite location is about 15 minutes from me. my buddy in sales call on both. i don't own one so will not say one way or another what hardware they use. i assume they are mostly if not all metric. i know many 3rd party attachments are sae.

i just had a mobile air conditioning mechanic here to replace a cracked fitting on a caterpillar 55 tractor. it is about 99% metric. the guy works on anything and everything. guess what? sae ac fittings. i looked in his tool bag and van. hardly any metric in it. just saying.
So far everything on the body, all the body hardware and the big joints are all SAE. Assume the hydraulic fittings are all SAE. But pretty sure the engine is 100% metric, but I don't know that for sure.

Similar on my Exmark lawn mower. My Kohler engine has a mixture of SAE and metric. Every other part on my mower is SAE.
 
OP
J

jasonrohrer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
119
In fairness, Milwaukee are not an American company, they’re a Chinese one. Have been for about 20 years. Sadly, if someone sells the family silver, they can’t complain about what the new owner does with it.

Whoa, didn't know that. Even more reason not to buy Milwaukee stuff. See, even I'm being tricked, and I care about such matters.

Makita are very different. Makita make tools in different grades, for different purposes. I have probably ten different Makita power tools, and I think only two (one being an inexpensive palm sander) were made in China.

I’ve noticed similar comments from other members before though, and I wonder if Makita sell predominantly their lower end tools in the U.S? Or whether folks are buying them from stores that only stock the lower end tools?

Yeah, all the Japan-made Makita stuff that I have... I had to seek it out, order online, etc. USA Big-Box-Store Makita is all made in China, from what I've seen. There is one specialty store locally that carries the better Japan-made stuff.

Something like this Snap On service set ,while great only gets you SAE or Metric. Maybe someone could chime in if they have a new offering with both runs of sockets. https://www.ebay.com/itm/3358390042...TkXj2oIUreYXxerDerlogJ4cb8vwzU54aAhdHEALw_wcB

Ah, SnapOn still makes this set!


And it comes with the Dual-80 ratchet now.

However, it no longer comes with the metal box, just the tray. Could be a nice wood-working project. Customer service wouldn't measure the damn tray for me, but they did tell me this: Shipping dimension for item 218AFSP is 20"x6"x2"

I wonder if the tray would fit in here:

 

Submariner733

Active member
Joined
Mar 2, 2024
Messages
25
Hospital Facilities Maintenance

Ridgid case is compact with more efficient use of space than a Milwaukee Packout
Rails add the flexibility to only haul what you need up to an Equipment Room

Wright ratchets and rails
Proto sockets and extensions
Imperial to 1"
Metric to 19mm


1745354101232.png1745354141323.png1745354189413.png
 
OP
J

jasonrohrer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
119
Chris from Ko-Ken USA customer service has been very helpful, answering all of my questions. Snap-On was not very helpful, which I found surprising, because I thought that was their whole model (don't they drive a truck right to your auto shop and provide in-person customer service).

Turns out the Ko-Ken USA warehouse is down in Westford, MA, which is only an hour from my house.

I went a-pawn-shopping today, but couldn't get my hands on either a Matco or a Snap-on modern ratchet.

Anyway, my current plan is to get the 1/4" drive Ko-Ken set to start with, because that's all 6pt, and I currently have no usable 1/4" drive ratchet or sockets at all. That will let me see Ko-Ken quality first-hand, and see what all the fuss is about (best in-class backdrag on their 1/4" ratchet, supposedly, but only 20 teeth....)

If Ko-Ken puts me over the moon, then I can piece together 6pt sockets to replace the 12pts in the Ko-Ken 3/8" set, and put the 12pts on rails in case I ever need them for something.
 

alinc100

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2013
Messages
3,020
Location
Dearborn,MI
OK I really should be cooking dinner right now as I am starving, but the service set reminded me I just picked up one of those metal boxes at an estate sale. I wonder how much Snap On I could find to fill it??? Of course different eras, fonts, date codes, but I came pretty close. with a bit of improper arrangements I can get a flex head in the box.
 

Attachments

  • 20250422_162742.jpg
    20250422_162742.jpg
    1 MB · Views: 35
  • 20250422_162747.jpg
    20250422_162747.jpg
    732.9 KB · Views: 20
  • 20250422_162811.jpg
    20250422_162811.jpg
    734.8 KB · Views: 10
  • 20250422_162814.jpg
    20250422_162814.jpg
    539.4 KB · Views: 8
  • 20250422_162819.jpg
    20250422_162819.jpg
    823.7 KB · Views: 7
  • 20250422_162824.jpg
    20250422_162824.jpg
    978.3 KB · Views: 9
  • 20250422_164645 - Copy.jpg
    20250422_164645 - Copy.jpg
    919.3 KB · Views: 8
  • 20250422_164649 - Copy.jpg
    20250422_164649 - Copy.jpg
    541.1 KB · Views: 12
  • 20250422_164651.jpg
    20250422_164651.jpg
    742.4 KB · Views: 13
  • 20250422_165941.jpg
    20250422_165941.jpg
    1,017.4 KB · Views: 20

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,809
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
Chris from Ko-Ken USA customer service has been very helpful, answering all of my questions. Snap-On was not very helpful, which I found surprising, because I thought that was their whole model (don't they drive a truck right to your auto shop and provide in-person customer service).

Turns out the Ko-Ken USA warehouse is down in Westford, MA, which is only an hour from my house.

I went a-pawn-shopping today, but couldn't get my hands on either a Matco or a Snap-on modern ratchet.

Anyway, my current plan is to get the 1/4" drive Ko-Ken set to start with, because that's all 6pt, and I currently have no usable 1/4" drive ratchet or sockets at all. That will let me see Ko-Ken quality first-hand, and see what all the fuss is about (best in-class backdrag on their 1/4" ratchet, supposedly, but only 20 teeth....)

If Ko-Ken puts me over the moon, then I can piece together 6pt sockets to replace the 12pts in the Ko-Ken 3/8" set, and put the 12pts on rails in case I ever need them for something.

This set is almost half price if you are going to start swapping 12 point for 6 point


It's not the way I would go personally, I'm in the build your own storage case and piece together your perfect socket set (from Ko-ken) camp.

This thread might help give you some ideas on how to build and organize a great socket/tool set

Post in thread 'Portable Combination Wrench Storage & Organization?' https://www.garagejournal.com/forum...nch-storage-organization.533086/post-10692825
 
Last edited:

cody1325

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 17, 2024
Messages
1,075
Location
Southwest Virginia
Definitely following this thread. Been helping a family friend and neighbor a lot lately on old cars, and most of my mobile boxes were geared around small engine, hobby, and household stuff. Thus, the space is poorly utilized and I often lack tools I shoulda brought with me in the first place. Plans are, at present, to equip a Popular Mechanics (Stack-On for Walmart) 20-inch box for the job.

I've recently picked up a Craftsman Versastack box like this, since I have a few random pieces from it already. The only problem is that the stock dividers are terrible for efficiently organizing tools. If foamed, I think my Gearwrench set (in addition to a metric one) and many other needed but didn't bring mechanic's tools should fit without hassle.

Any advice on foaming out the drawers? I picked up several foam kneeling pads at Tractor Supply on sale, and they should be the right thickness.

09729810.jpg
 

bonneyman

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
8,759
Location
Desert SW
interesting comment. bobcats main usa skid steer mfg plant is about 40 minutes from me and a satellite location is about 15 minutes from me. my buddy in sales call on both. i don't own one so will not say one way or another what hardware they use. i assume they are mostly if not all metric. i know many 3rd party attachments are sae.

i just had a mobile air conditioning mechanic here to replace a cracked fitting on a caterpillar 55 tractor. it is about 99% metric. the guy works on anything and everything. guess what? sae ac fittings. i looked in his tool bag and van. hardly any metric in it. just saying.
I can confirm that on residential A/C as well. Last time I looked at new A/C condensing units they were crammed full of foreign parts but the nuts, screws, and fittings were all SAE. I kept a small selection of metric wrenches and sockets for odd jobs but most of my specialty stuff was SAE.

Guess it depends on the trade.
 

Dave455

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
5,800
Location
Sussex, England
Anyway, my current plan is to get the 1/4" drive Ko-Ken set to start with, because that's all 6pt, and I currently have no usable 1/4" drive ratchet or sockets at all. That will let me see Ko-Ken quality first-hand, and see what all the fuss is about (best in-class backdrag on their 1/4" ratchet, supposedly, but only 20 teeth....)
I don’t think you can go far wrong with this strategy.

The KoKen is a notch up on what you have, but hopefully without going too mad pricewise.

You won’t fault the sockets, and if you really don’t like the ratchet, you can always replace it with something you do like, and you’ll still be $$$’s ahead. Personally, I think you will find the ratchet just fine.

One tip - the two KoKen 1/4“ drive standard length ratchets feel very different, even though they have the same mechanism. It’s worth trying both.

Personally, I think the knurled handle 2753N feels nicer.
IMG_1504.jpeg
 
OP
J

jasonrohrer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2022
Messages
119
I don’t think you can go far wrong with this strategy.

The KoKen is a notch up on what you have, but hopefully without going too mad pricewise.

You won’t fault the sockets, and if you really don’t like the ratchet, you can always replace it with something you do like, and you’ll still be $$$’s ahead. Personally, I think you will find the ratchet just fine.

One tip - the two KoKen 1/4“ drive standard length ratchets feel very different, even though they have the same mechanism. It’s worth trying both.

Personally, I think the knurled handle 2753N feels nicer.

Yes, good news! Because that's the one that comes in the 1/4" set. Looking at the Ko-Ken catalog, I just noticed that the knurling is intermittent, not wrap-around. That's a nice touch!

Also, I'm NOT trying to save money here. When I'm buying something that I will use for the rest of my life, price isn't really an issue.

I'm just trying to find something that checks my personal boxes. Opinions here obviously differ, but for me, personally, having something that goes together is important. I don't know why.... it's just a sensibility that I have. Same with having it in a case that's designed to contain it. I just want it to be that way... I can look in there, and see that nothing's missing, and... just get a cozy feeling. Same with the idea of passing it on to grandchildren. They will open a special red box and see the set all there, together. Everything in its right place. Cue choirs of angels. Thanks grandpa!

It's just a very different feel than having a Dewalt box with a SnapOn ratchet and some Wright sockets rattling around in there.

Snap-On comes close to checking this box, but it's SAE only, and there's no box for the tray. Matco's got nothing as a set, that I can find.

The only other real contender here is the SK91848 set. If the 1/4" Ko-Ken set really lets me down in terms of quality, I will consider the SK set.
 

alinc100

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2013
Messages
3,020
Location
Dearborn,MI
I don’t think you can go far wrong with this strategy.

The KoKen is a notch up on what you have, but hopefully without going too mad pricewise.

You won’t fault the sockets, and if you really don’t like the ratchet, you can always replace it with something you do like, and you’ll still be $$$’s ahead. Personally, I think you will find the ratchet just fine.

One tip - the two KoKen 1/4“ drive standard length ratchets feel very different, even though they have the same mechanism. It’s worth trying both.

Personally, I think the knurled handle 2753N feels nicer.
IMG_1504.jpeg
Dave,
Asking because I've not seen /used a KoKen ratchet. Would they be any different that the Proto 4749? I can find the Proto pearhead ratchets around here for $5-10
 

Dave455

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
5,800
Location
Sussex, England
Yes, good news! Because that's the one that comes in the 1/4" set. Looking at the Ko-Ken catalog, I just noticed that the knurling is intermittent, not wrap-around. That's a nice touch!

Also, I'm NOT trying to save money here. When I'm buying something that I will use for the rest of my life, price isn't really an issue.

I'm just trying to find something that checks my personal boxes. Opinions here obviously differ, but for me, personally, having something that goes together is important. I don't know why.... it's just a sensibility that I have. Same with having it in a case that's designed to contain it. I just want it to be that way... I can look in there, and see that nothing's missing, and... just get a cozy feeling. Same with the idea of passing it on to grandchildren. They will open a special red box and see the set all there, together. Everything in its right place. Cue choirs of angels. Thanks grandpa!

It's just a very different feel than having a Dewalt box with a SnapOn ratchet and some Wright sockets rattling around in there.

Snap-On comes close to checking this box, but it's SAE only, and there's no box for the tray. Matco's got nothing as a set, that I can find.

The only other real contender here is the SK91848 set. If the 1/4" Ko-Ken set really lets me down in terms of quality, I will consider the SK set.
There are a lot of nice touches with KoKen.

I’ve got tools from a lot of manufacturers, and everything I’ve got I like, but some leave me with a more positive feeling than others.

The KoKen tends to grow on you. It looks good from the start, and for the price paid there‘s never any “buyers remorse”, but as you use it you realise how good it is.

KoKen is much higher quality than SK - I’ve got some of each,
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom