I'm probably in the minority here, but....
I think nearly all of the boxes looked better before he worked on them. Apart from structural issues that make the boxes unusable, the other things that he mocks and laughs about are the very things that make an old tool box neat and give it life....things like screws used for repairs, chipped edges, scratches, etc, etc. These are things that you look at and know that a living person used the box and touched it, and so on.
You take all that away and make it perfect, and it becomes sterile.
I have an old science lab table in my garage that serves as a workbench. The bubble gum stuck underneath, the pencil gouges from restless students and the graffiti from 1940, are the things that people always comment about. If I were to strip it down, refinish it and put an new epoxy top on it, it would look new again, but man....what a tragedy that would be.