To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Toolboxes don’t need no stinking keys

JeffreyG

Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2025
Messages
24
Bought some vintage toolboxes, some with, some without keys. The two without keys came locked with most drawers open. So far I have not figured out how to get keys for these MAC toolboxes. In the meantime I bought a lock pick set which allowed me to unlock the boxes so I can comfortably use all drawers for storage. I found the picking tools take surprisingly little time to use after a bit of practice.

This got me looking at my other toolbox stacks which are Craftsmen boxes from 90s or so. These were bought as scratch and dents from Sears stores without keys so boxes cost almost nothing and have worked fine for decades of basement storage. When you look for replacement keys for old toolboxes you find that Craftsmen keys are very easy to buy, which I was preparing to do. But every lock needed a different key, which led me to consider replacing every lock so they would be keyed the same. But then it hit me that I would never need to lock them, and for me the only reason to lock would be to move them without drawers falling out.

So I decided to instead replace all the locks with thumb operated cam locks. No need to keep track of keys, and yet able to seal closed for moving.

There are several styles of the thumb knob, cheap and easy to find on Amazon and other places, so worth looking at options and picking the one you like best. Easy to install for these used and vintage craftsman boxes using simple cam locks, though most of the lock bars needed some adjustment with vise, hammer, grinder or file to mate perfectly.
IMG_1400.jpegIMG_1349.jpegIMG_1350.jpegIMG_1412.jpeg
IMG_1415.jpeg
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

whateg01

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
11,198
Location
doo dah, kansas, usa
I've often wondered if toolbox locks are as easy to repin as door locks. I've repinned a bunch of doors as needed, often to get matching keys for the garage as the back door without having to buy a set. Pins are really inexpensive online. I also cut my own keys because I got tired of getting keys that almost worked or only worked after some jiggling.
 

Firebrick43

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2015
Messages
13,992
Location
West central Indiana
Old Tool box locks are about the easiest. When coworkers forgot thier keys they asked me to open them. I just ground pick like tools out out a small piece of steel pallet strapping and applied rotational pressure with a small pocket flat blade screwdriver
 
OP
J

JeffreyG

Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2025
Messages
24
This is the outfit you get tool box keys from:

Easy / EasyKeys, 11407 Granite St. Ste B, Charlotte, NC 28273 / https://easykeys.com/ / keys, locks, locksmith tools / * this is the company that supplies keys for tool boxes * /

You need the code number from the face of the lock cylinder.
This isn’t really about the MAC toolboxes that I am still seeking keys for. But I have corresponded with easykeys including pictures and they are unable to help me with the vintage MAC boxes.

My point was about the many toolboxes out there that keys are really not needed for, and that are easily replaced with these unkeyed turn button replacements.
 
OP
J

JeffreyG

Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2025
Messages
24
I've often wondered if toolbox locks are as easy to repin as door locks. I've repinned a bunch of doors as needed, often to get matching keys for the garage as the back door without having to buy a set. Pins are really inexpensive online. I also cut my own keys because I got tired of getting keys that almost worked or only worked after some jiggling.
These small cam locks that I replaced are fully sealed so I suspect would be very difficult or impossible to repin.
 

four.cycle

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
28,576
Location
Tacoma, Washington
This isn’t really about the MAC toolboxes that I am still seeking keys for. But I have corresponded with easykeys including pictures and they are unable to help me with the vintage MAC boxes.

My point was about the many toolboxes out there that keys are really not needed for, and that are easily replaced with these unkeyed turn button replacements.
I didn't misunderstand your post. I was kind of puzzled at first until I saw the photo of the "thumblock" installed.
I posted that for those who click on this thread trying to find keys for their boxes. ;)
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Chefjpd

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
May 18, 2022
Messages
270
Location
NYC / Virginia Beach
I took a craftsman bottom box and put it in the back of my wagon drawers facing up. Moving to a new home. No need to lock them, so I put the keys in the top drawer. No issue, right?

After the 350 mile trip, I unloaded the box and put it in my workshop. It was fully locked!!
MFSOBB. the jostling must have moved the mechanism. Had to order a key for $15. I was not about to drill it out.

In the 30+ years of tool box ownership, I have never locked them.
 

Mike'smeatshop

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 1, 2023
Messages
1,273
Bought some vintage toolboxes, some with, some without keys. The two without keys came locked with most drawers open. So far I have not figured out how to get keys for these MAC toolboxes. In the meantime I bought a lock pick set which allowed me to unlock the boxes so I can comfortably use all drawers for storage. I found the picking tools take surprisingly little time to use after a bit of practice.

This got me looking at my other toolbox stacks which are Craftsmen boxes from 90s or so. These were bought as scratch and dents from Sears stores without keys so boxes cost almost nothing and have worked fine for decades of basement storage. When you look for replacement keys for old toolboxes you find that Craftsmen keys are very easy to buy, which I was preparing to do. But every lock needed a different key, which led me to consider replacing every lock so they would be keyed the same. But then it hit me that I would never need to lock them, and for me the only reason to lock would be to move them without drawers falling out.

So I decided to instead replace all the locks with thumb operated cam locks. No need to keep track of keys, and yet able to seal closed for moving.

There are several styles of the thumb knob, cheap and easy to find on Amazon and other places, so worth looking at options and picking the one you like best. Easy to install for these used and vintage craftsman boxes using simple cam locks, though most of the lock bars needed some adjustment with vise, hammer, grinder or file to mate perfectly.
IMG_1400.jpegIMG_1349.jpegIMG_1350.jpegIMG_1412.jpeg
IMG_1415.jpeg
So can I just replace the key lock with a thumb lock and still use the original lock? I have a box load but gave up on keys. And who did you use?
 

lowbucktruck

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2010
Messages
1,323
Location
Foothills, Northern California
A useful post. Some of us have found it necessary to lock our toolboxes when sharing shop space... because coworkers "borrow" stuff and forget to return it to the toolbox where they found it to complete the job.

I also have some vintage MAC toolboxes which have that key challenge. I think I changed the lock tumblers on the Waterloo boxes out some time ago, just so I could key them with the same key.
 

Jagmandave

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 6, 2011
Messages
6,299
Location
Overland Park, Ks.
Ummm.......I ALWAYS locked my box at night because if I didn't the second shift would be in there and I would find my tools all over the plant. Ony one time tho......after that they were SOL....

The locks on my HF boxes use a barrel type key, I would think those are pretty difficult to pick? I don't lock them since they're in my garage and no one uses those tools except me.
 
OP
J

JeffreyG

Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2025
Messages
24
So can I just replace the key lock with a thumb lock and still use the original lock? I have a box load but gave up on keys. And who did you use?
Sorry, but I don’t understand your question. In the last pic I posted, it shows a box of all the locks I removed, plus an example of the thumb-lock I replaced them all with. I just looked on Amazon for thumb operated cam locks, and picked my favorite of the several different styles they list.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom