I'm most likely going to go get the HF ratchet and still keep the Matco. I do love knowing I have a bad assed ratchet if I need it.
Your best advise, funny it came from yourself. If you don't end up liking the HF, you can dump it at less of a loss or just keep it since it's a smaller investment.
I would not want to take the loss on the better tool to get a cheaper one myself. I have the 1/2" drive 18" Armstrong locking flex and it's not going anywhere.
You'll have to post a better picture of your main box. Looks like an older Matco 54" or 72". I have an older 54" that I like quite a bit.
I used to ride in a few hare scrambles way back when but, mostly rode MX. Honda was my choice but, a CR500.