Get something straight.. preferably a test bar and chuck it up repeatedly keeping the bar in same location rotation wise and check readings.
Or chuck up some solid stock, take a cut and keep re chucking the piece keeping it in exact same location in jaws, take your readings.
You want a 3 jaw to be repeatable within reason.... that's the point.
As stated above, there's many places for wear... if it looks old and worn it most likely is.
4 jaws are a different story. Rough rule of thumb, used 4 jaws can be ok, old used 3 jaws not so much.. better to buy new.