and its UPS fault for not returning the item to Amazon when they unloaded the trailer at their warehouse.
I'm thinking I wouldn't want some UPS employee who doesn't know the difference between a wrench and a screwdriver to decide what should be returned. I'd rather all damaged packages be delivered to me so I can be the one to inspect.
Obvious this was damaged but would you want some UPS employee deciding if a package is damaged enough to decide to automatically return it on their own or would you rather be the one that decides?
I've received damaged, smashed and ripped open boxes and bubble shipping envelopes that contained undamaged merchandise. I've received pristine boxes and bubble shipping envelopes that had damaged merchandise inside them.
Convince me that UPS should be making the decision if damaged items I ordered should be returned.
My thought, there is a lot of unofficial policy between Amazon and UPS regarding their "free" shipping.
I've received damaged packages from retailers other than amazon that weren't shipped by UPS. And that I paid the full going shipping rate on.
All packages, even poorly packed ones, probably could be delivered undamaged. But if the system was set up to do so I suspect that shipping costs would be prohibitive.