I love my Toast Master 1B24 that came out of the St. Vincent's scrap metal bin. It's a very solid mechanism that makes an impressive sound when you push the slider down.
It pops up with enough gusto to almost throw lightweight slices out of the slots. The Darker > Lighter knob is very sensitive and holds its setting. The original cloth covered cord and Bakelite plug are still going strong. Mine's a bit newer than yours and has patent dates as late as 1953.
I foolishly passed up a nice group of similar toasters for around $5 each once. I decided not to start a toaster collection. I do have one other old one in the back of the shop. It needs new wire windings because I was dumb and broke them while grabbing it by the slots. That one has two settings. One for light > dark and the other for soft > crunchy. It would be worth repairing someday.
I totally agree about kitchen tools. Vintage kitchen power tools are cool.
TOm