Alright - then what DO you use?

I have been told repeatedly - by plumbers in the business - to use the yellow tape and maybe a touch of dope since all the pipe and fittings you buy are china sourced and fit is iffy. I tried just the dope (all of which seems to have Teflon in it- rated to xxxxPSI, air, gas, etc) on my air lines and they leaked like crazy. Tape - like 6-8 wraps- and a touch of dope was required to seal them up. So - out with it.
Your question wasn't directed at me, but I know the answer, so let me respond.
It is perfectly acceptable to use gas-rated teflon tape for gas. In fact...that's what they make it for.
Now...the following list is my "OPINIONS" on the subject matter.
1. Teflon tapemakes a much neater joint than pipe dope and it won't stain your clothes, get all over your wrenches or drip onto the floor if you get too much on your brush.
2. Teflon as a pipe dope additive is essentially worthless and the only reason that sealant manufacturers put powdered teflon in their sealants is because there is and has been a preception in the U.S. that Teflon is a miracle cure to whatever ails you and anything that has teflon in it, from frying pans to valve grease, is BETTER...when in fact it isn't. I personnally spoke to a manufacturer of pipe sealant who told me the only reason they add teflon to some of their sealants is because that is what everyone else does and if you want your sealant to sell at a hardware store...you better advertise it has teflon in it.
3. Pipe sealants (pipe dope) are easier to use sucessfully than teflon tape. This is based on my experience. Teflon tape requires greater torque to seal than pipe sealants and is less forgiving in overall application. That's why I personnally much prefer pipe dope over teflon tape. If you can't get pipe sealant to seal, I'd recommend you read the directions on the can and follow them as I stated in my previous post.
4. Using teflon tape and pipe dope is not recommended (at least to my knowledge) by either the people who make teflon tape OR the people who make pipe dope. That being said...it DOES sometimes do the trick.
5. Teflon tape can get sucked into a gas orifice and cause problems. So can a chunk of pipe sealant. I think that issue is a wash when comparing one to the other.
And finally I'd point out that the proper way to fix a pipe fitting that just won't seal is to replace it with a new fitting....not come up with some hair brained (even though I admitted it sometimes works under 4. above) plan to use the "belt and suspenders" approach.
Phil