Which Compressor?

[Adamski]

I don't know much of anything when it comes to compressors. I have a small 2 gallon in the garage now and absolutely despise it. I want/need something bigger. This will be for light duty work, like just using air to clear off saw dust, filling tires and maybe a lug nut every now and then. I wouldn't mind getting something too big in case I need to use it more often for projects the require a bit more air.

I know the harbor freight ones aren't ideal, but for my purposes, the price is right. Here's the ones I'm torn between. I'd love some insight on which is better for me. Any help is appreciated!

Thanks
Adam

http://www.harborfreight.com/air-to...p-10-gallon-125-psi-air-compressor-67708.html

http://www.harborfreight.com/air-to...-17-gal-150-oilless-air-compressor-69666.html

 

[p0lar]

I don't know much of anything when it comes to compressors. I have a small 2 gallon in the garage now and absolutely despise it. I want/need something bigger. This will be for light duty work, like just using air to clear off saw dust, filling tires and maybe a lug nut every now and then. I wouldn't mind getting something too big in case I need to use it more often for projects the require a bit more air.

I know the harbor freight ones aren't ideal, but for my purposes, the price is right. Here's the ones I'm torn between. I'd love some insight on which is better for me. Any help is appreciated!

Thanks
Adam

http://www.harborfreight.com/air-to...p-10-gallon-125-psi-air-compressor-67708.html

http://www.harborfreight.com/air-to...-17-gal-150-oilless-air-compressor-69666.html

I have yet to see a HF compressor that I could recommend without some degree of anonymity, but if I had to choose between only those two, I'd take the first. All oilless compressors are, IMHO, designed to be disposable. (Though there are rebuild kits for many.) If you're decent with maintenance, most oil-based compressors will last for a while as long as you purge the tank often. Both compressors likely utilize LeFoo pressure switches, which are prone to failure regardless of what compressor they're used on.

So, bearing all that in mind (and with only those two options), the first gets my nod with its 5.3 SCFM @ 90 PSI and oil splash-lubricated.

Depending on your budget, if you'd like to look outside HF, you may be able to find a used RolAir compressor via Craigslist. They're arguably some of the better portable ones on the market. Look for clean oil - it's uncommon someone will change the oil before selling it.

 

[CNGsaves]

Don't waste your money on any compressor at HF.

Just watch CraigsList or a Moving Sale and get yourself a decent oil-splash compressor. If all have is 120 volt, then look for something in the 20 to 30 gallon range like a Sears, CH, etc.

Most people end up with 2 compressors long-term . . . smaller one that is portable and runs on 120v, and then the whole shop compressor on 240v that is generally 60 gallon and 5 HP.

 

[zkling]

Don't waste your money on any compressor at HF.

Just watch CraigsList or a Moving Sale and get yourself a decent oil-splash compressor. If all have is 120 volt, then look for something in the 20 to 30 gallon range like a Sears, CH, etc.

This ^ Post your location (city) and we can help you browse through your local craigslist. You and everyone surrounding your compressor while in use will be thankful.

 

[kenfain]

You're gonna want oil lube type. Preferably slow running. It'll be much more quiet. You'll like it much better than the old one. A large 110v. will probably be your best bet. I look at Cl. a lot. And I know that it might take awhile, but probably less than a month goes by before I see a great deal on an old, but in good shape, compressor. My advice, just be patient, check, two, three times a day. Buy an older American made quality unit.

 

[Major Ramifications]

If you absolutely must buy an inexpensive new compressor, I would suggest something from Campbell Hausfeld (they make most of the Husky units at Home Depot also). They are a good company and parts are available and reasonable.
Even a reconditioned CH unit has a one year warranty.

 

[Adamski]

Thanks for the help guys. There isn't much around here available as far as used goes, but I'll keep an eye out.

Thanks
Adam