To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Which Workbench?

cody1325

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 17, 2024
Messages
1,075
Location
Southwest Virginia
In the basement workshop, I previously had a rather large "tanker" desk. I decided to restore it and move that to the room that's the other 75% of the basement and put my computer on it. It's exactly 60-inches wide.

The way the shop was organized, you couldn't really get anything but the lap drawer open, and it was a pain in the **** getting anything you dropped under the workbench out. In addition, space was poorly utilized--just a crude homemade shelf attached to the wall and semi-supported by the desk top and holes drilled in a piece of fiber board to form a crude pegboard. In addition, a crude "extension" made from scraps and old kitchen counter cut-offs also housed a maybe 20 gal. horizontal air compressor--in poor condition and something I actively avoid using.

First place I checked was Harbor Freight.

The Yukon has pegboard as a part of it, and a built-in light. Some drawers too, and among my cheapest local options at $129.

But, steel work top and I'm not sure how well it would work with a small (3-inch) vise.


58695_W3.jpg

The woodworking table would really suit what I do down there well. However, I feel like I could (with some help) probably make my own, and get a good cast iron woodworking vise to go on the side.

Exactly the same size as the old desk, but for my uses--the vise is on the wrong side. I did remove an "extension" bolted to the side of an adjacent book case (and made from scraps) in order to get the desk pulled out, so it may still work.

Also, I don't think I'd be putting my Kennedy chest on that.


58832_W3.jpg

Lowe's here has a couple, but nothing I really liked--and virtually all "out of stock" for shipping/pickup or in store





As for building one. I'm pretty sure I could scrounge up enough wood around here to build one perfectly suited to my needs. I'd like a butcher block top on it, which would probably end up being the expensive bit...
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

GrayFlattop

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,038
Location
Chicago
In the basement workshop, I previously had a rather large "tanker" desk. I decided to restore it and move that to the room that's the other 75% of the basement and put my computer on it. It's exactly 60-inches wide.

The way the shop was organized, you couldn't really get anything but the lap drawer open, and it was a pain in the **** getting anything you dropped under the workbench out. In addition, space was poorly utilized--just a crude homemade shelf attached to the wall and semi-supported by the desk top and holes drilled in a piece of fiber board to form a crude pegboard. In addition, a crude "extension" made from scraps and old kitchen counter cut-offs also housed a maybe 20 gal. horizontal air compressor--in poor condition and something I actively avoid using.

First place I checked was Harbor Freight.

The Yukon has pegboard as a part of it, and a built-in light. Some drawers too, and among my cheapest local options at $129.

But, steel work top and I'm not sure how well it would work with a small (3-inch) vise.


58695_W3.jpg

The woodworking table would really suit what I do down there well. However, I feel like I could (with some help) probably make my own, and get a good cast iron woodworking vise to go on the side.

Exactly the same size as the old desk, but for my uses--the vise is on the wrong side. I did remove an "extension" bolted to the side of an adjacent book case (and made from scraps) in order to get the desk pulled out, so it may still work.

Also, I don't think I'd be putting my Kennedy chest on that.


58832_W3.jpg

Lowe's here has a couple, but nothing I really liked--and virtually all "out of stock" for shipping/pickup or in store





As for building one. I'm pretty sure I could scrounge up enough wood around here to build one perfectly suited to my needs. I'd like a butcher block top on it, which would probably end up being the expensive bit...
What’s stopping you from mounting the top of the wood bench 180 degrees from what is shown?
 

evh

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
155
Location
Midwest
I would also check FB Marketplace. I just picked up a nice 4 drawer metal craftsman with a 1 3/4" butcher block top on it for $60. Built much better than what I could buy new in most cases at any reasonable price.
 

mike93lx

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
37,356
Location
Richmond, VA
In the basement workshop, I previously had a rather large "tanker" desk. I decided to restore it and move that to the room that's the other 75% of the basement and put my computer on it. It's exactly 60-inches wide.

The way the shop was organized, you couldn't really get anything but the lap drawer open, and it was a pain in the **** getting anything you dropped under the workbench out. In addition, space was poorly utilized--just a crude homemade shelf attached to the wall and semi-supported by the desk top and holes drilled in a piece of fiber board to form a crude pegboard. In addition, a crude "extension" made from scraps and old kitchen counter cut-offs also housed a maybe 20 gal. horizontal air compressor--in poor condition and something I actively avoid using.

First place I checked was Harbor Freight.

The Yukon has pegboard as a part of it, and a built-in light. Some drawers too, and among my cheapest local options at $129.

But, steel work top and I'm not sure how well it would work with a small (3-inch) vise.


58695_W3.jpg

The woodworking table would really suit what I do down there well. However, I feel like I could (with some help) probably make my own, and get a good cast iron woodworking vise to go on the side.

Exactly the same size as the old desk, but for my uses--the vise is on the wrong side. I did remove an "extension" bolted to the side of an adjacent book case (and made from scraps) in order to get the desk pulled out, so it may still work.

Also, I don't think I'd be putting my Kennedy chest on that.


58832_W3.jpg

Lowe's here has a couple, but nothing I really liked--and virtually all "out of stock" for shipping/pickup or in store





As for building one. I'm pretty sure I could scrounge up enough wood around here to build one perfectly suited to my needs. I'd like a butcher block top on it, which would probably end up being the expensive bit...
"butcher block" counter sections are not too bad. Floor and Decor has good pricing.

I vote diy
 

whateg01

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
11,187
Location
doo dah, kansas, usa
generally, if you're putting a vise on it, my experience says you want mass. But you aren't going to be sticking a 9" Ford in a 3" vise, so maybe that's not a big deal. For the money, a sheet of mdf cut in half and doubled makes a pretty solid top. 2x4 framework is pretty cheap. You could go nuts on joinery or buy a set of brackets.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

iforgot

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2025
Messages
6
I bought this workbench about 10 years ago. I liked it so much that I bought another one 5 years ago. It has a vise mounted on it. It has easily supported a Kennedy toolbox. I admit that I had to secure the bench to the wall because sometimes I get a bit aggressive with things held in the vise.
 

evh

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
155
Location
Midwest
I had that same Harbor Freight Wooden workbench you showed in your original post. I used it for about 10+ years. It is a very sturdy bench and I had a 4" bench on the left-hand side. I recently got rid of it and replaced it with the Craftsman bench I mentioned in my earlier post.

1758753825542.png
 

Mandres

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2006
Messages
1,151
I would also check FB Marketplace. I just picked up a nice 4 drawer metal craftsman with a 1 3/4" butcher block top on it for $60. Built much better than what I could buy new in most cases at any reasonable price.

+1, I just this week picked up an older White Gate birch woodworking bench with two vises on marketplace. It was $50, less than the cost to build one out of cheap 2x4s. I'll sand it down and refinish it and use it forever.
 

CraigStu

Well-known member
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
4,009
Location
Blacksburg, Va
I bought butcher block in 6' x 36"(?) for my lathe. I bolted it to the studs in the wall w/ heavy angle brackets and used black iron pipe for the 2 legs to the floor. I was able to get a combination of pre threaded pieces, unions, caps etc so that all the joints left a little loose let me adjust the height perfectly. I also have my large vise on the end. Having it bolted to the wall makes gorilla vice work easy as long as I don't push up.
 

Aaron_W

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
2,889
Location
Northern California
I've looked at both of those HF workbenches. The first seems pretty worthless as a workbench, feels flimsy. It might be ok for something really light duty like electronics work, but I wasn't impressed.

The second one, the wooden one has promise. I'm more of a build a workbench guy, but I've almost bought that one a few times simply because it is probably cheaper than buying the materials. If you do a search online you can turn up a ton of modifications improving it. Quite a few combine two into one bench for added width, double set of drawers etc.


I prefer to build a workbench, so as others have mentioned find a set of plans you like and make one you will really like instead of settling for "eh it will work". Ripping a sheet of plywood or OSB in half and doubling makes a sturdy top supported by 2x4s and 4x4s makes for a simple and solid workbench. I like to screw a couple pieces of tempered hardboard (HDF) on top which can be replaced as needed for wear and tear.

Looking for something used is another solid choice, I've done that a couple of times. Find a nice solid table, desk, workbench and modify to your liking. Hard to beat going that way with the price of lumber as many are offered cheap or even free when people just want the space they occupy.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom