To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Why do electricians leave

To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

35Ford

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 4, 2020
Messages
140
Location
Central MA
These days it's more like 65 cents a foot, but your point is still valid. It's still less than an hour of the electricians time.
Yikes! I hope you're not paying .65/ ft. Current price here for 14/2 is $355.75 / 1,000 bought in 250' coils. 1,000 ft reels are usually a few dollars more. 12/2, $.51
 

472scout

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 18, 2010
Messages
1,276
Location
back 40
Does said electrician make more money if he goes fast and sloppy or slow and precise? Hello.
 

William Payne

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
7,671
Location
Wanganui, New Zealand
no NFPA/NEC 70 code prohibits this so the only no-no youre referring to comes from the thumb rules book of codes, edition 2025.

Yeah I figured as much. When I had my house wiring redone I had a really fussy electrician who even proceeded to ring up another electrician who had done prior work just to let them know what he thought of their work. Haha man that was embarrassing at the time. Some of his rules that he talked about the honestly might have just made up.
 

theoldwizard1

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 22, 2011
Messages
43,106
Location
SE MI
Why do electricians leave so much wire hanging out of the box? The electrician working at my new home leaves anywhere from 1 to 2 feet hanging out of the electrical box. I am paying for time and materials, so it irks me that he is so wastefull.
Better too much then too little.
IMHO, 1' is reasonable. 2' is a waste !

I am also the guy who believes that using 20A breakers and 12 AWG for the entire house is a waste. Use 20a breakers and 12 AWG where required by code or logical (workshops/garage). I am not a NEC expert, but there are many "best practices" (not required by NEC) for kitchen wiring that are simply a waste.
 

theoldwizard1

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 22, 2011
Messages
43,106
Location
SE MI
after fighting with changing switches & receptacles in my circa 1950 home with extremely short wire tails and often having to add to them and then fight with the small boxes & additional marrettes, I wouldn't complain. :lol_hitti
Been there, done that.

No big heartache.
 

wow1

Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2024
Messages
15
When we wire a job we leave it long because any damage
is usually at the end so then we have enough to cut off and the damage.
 

dcg9381

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 20, 2018
Messages
11,640
Location
Austin, TX
Why do electricians leave so much wire hanging out of the box? The electrician working at my new home leaves anywhere from 1 to 2 feet hanging out of the electrical box. I am paying for time and materials, so it irks me that he is so wastefull.
Last house I built, a kitchen cabinet was built for the oven. Unfortunately, the pig-tail on the oven had to be in a particular place and I didn't specify the exact position of the drop in the cabinet.. It necessitated moving the drop over about 1'.

Due to the electrician leaving a foot of wire on both ends, we were able to accommodate the change without me having to pay to run a new drop of 6ga wire.

I'm much more interested in what the panel looks like AFTER it's wired than leaving 1-2' of wire hanging out of the box.
 

sparky 1971

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2018
Messages
7,967
Location
Central Iowa
I don't leave loops because I don't see the point but that's nothing more than my opinion which, in the old days when combined with a quarter, would get you a phone call. When pulling wire I make an attempt at leave about 6" on one cable and a foot on the other (out of the box for both) for pigtails. That being said, there are some pulls that are a PITA, whether it's around a corner, a long distance, or overhead, resulting in too much getting pulled; that gets left and scrapped because the cost to pull it back is more than the cost of the wire. And..I'm lazy.
 

JohnX14

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 2, 2014
Messages
550
Location
Boston 'burbs
Ridiculous, off the wall advice to people that genuinely are asking for guidance from people that shouldn't be allowed near anything more involved then a screwdriver. Edit: seriously, I hope the post before me was sarcasm
I thought I replied several days ago, yes my post was meant as sarcasm. I should have added an emoji or something.....sorry.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

fitter30

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2019
Messages
2,966
Location
Peace Valley,mo
Electricians have an inherent need to be wasteful.
They always leave a swallow or two of beer in the bottle or a bite of an Egg Mcmuffin behind. They often drive their work vans around just to waste gas. They donate to losing political candidates buy their wives jewelery, throw socks away when there's only one small hole in the heel or buy hunting licenses when they know they can't shoot worth a damn. .
I don't know what makes them this way.
:)
Glad i was pipefitter that ran hvac sevice. Three things i looked forward to everyday breaks , lunch and going home. Two people were the only ones with problems on the job, my boss and the customer. Starting time was a given and going home was my choice. Last job i had lasted 40 years. And if your mind forgets your feet will remember.
 

SouthernIllinois

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 14, 2024
Messages
1,658
The parsimonious folks who built my house back in the '80s carefully strung every wire run banjo string tight using an elven wire stretcher, and every fixture, switch, and outlet was installed with not one extra millimeter of length by a crew of agile, bony fingered gnomes with child-size hands. .........So a bit of extra wire length is a good thing. Leave 'em alone.
^^ This

My Dad's place we bought was built in 1996.
Whoever wired it must have gotten a bonus for every 1/6th of an inch of wire they saved.

When we remodeled it I replaced every outlet and switch - what a PIA because of how tight they ran the wiring.
 

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,054
Location
Southeastern Pa
^^ This

My Dad's place we bought was built in 1996.
Whoever wired it must have gotten a bonus for every 1/6th of an inch of wire they saved.

When we remodeled it I replaced every outlet and switch - what a PIA because of how tight they ran the wiring.
Yea but they still cut a foot and half off before making the connection......
 

LOW1

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 20, 2018
Messages
2,635
Location
ontario
Wasted wire? On the scale of things to complain about in house construction that one doesn’t rank very high in my book. Relax.
 

Skooterj

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2021
Messages
749
Location
Indiana
I know the joke is the electricians don't know how to use a broom, but when I built my house, he was actually the best sub at cleaning the job site. He would even clean up after the other subs. But I was paying him for the job, so I didn't care if he used 1000 extra feet of wire and spent 100 extra hours doing it. But really, if you leave 2 feet of wire laying out of every outlet in a house, what is that 100 extra feet total? So $40-60? What's that, the cost of labor if one of the tails gets scraped by a drywall saw and the electrician needs to repair the tail because he doesn't already have the extra wire sitting there?

And you think a little cable is wasteful, just wait to you see how much your roofer cuts off the shingles, how many full sheets of drywall that could be patched together from the cut offs and how much window casing and baseboard is lost because the finish carpenter won't take the time to cut finger joints into every scrap and glue them together.
 

mm08822

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 13, 2012
Messages
5,872
Location
NJ
I know the joke is the electricians don't know how to use a broom, but when I built my house, he was actually the best sub at cleaning the job site. He would even clean up after the other subs. But I was paying him for the job, so I didn't care if he used 1000 extra feet of wire and spent 100 extra hours doing it. But really, if you leave 2 feet of wire laying out of every outlet in a house, what is that 100 extra feet total? So $40-60? What's that, the cost of labor if one of the tails gets scraped by a drywall saw and the electrician needs to repair the tail because he doesn't already have the extra wire sitting there?

And you think a little cable is wasteful, just wait to you see how much your roofer cuts off the shingles, how many full sheets of drywall that could be patched together from the cut offs and how much window casing and baseboard is lost because the finish carpenter won't take the time to cut finger joints into every scrap and glue them together.
When my house was built 30+ yrs ago, I was travelling for work so I had limited visits to the build. It's a tract build so the subs weren't top shelf.

After the roof was put on, and siding started, I visited. All of the roofing debris, some siding scraps, etc. were laying next to/in to the foundation excavation only partially backfilled.

I pulled all of that debris out of hole and put it in the garage to make sure it didn't get bulldozed into the hole.

Builder's super was pissed. (Hmmf, I wonder who did that.) Planting bushes later wasn't full of surprizes.
 
Last edited:

AA/FC

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 9, 2010
Messages
2,080
My grandfather and his brother owned a large commercial HVAC company in the 1950's through the 1980's. My grandfather's brother, Earl, was a real penny pincher..... In the early 1990's I was an apprentice in the HVAC business and one of the old journeyman that I was working with at that time had worked previously at my grandfathers company many years earlier. He said to me one day.... "Let me tell you a funny story about your grandfather's brother, Earl."

This old journeyman was working on a job site one day when Earl came to visit the job to see how things were going.... While Earl was standing nearby, this old journeyman happened to drop a sheet metal screw(s) on the floor while working up on a ladder... He didn't think anything about it and just grabbed another screw out of the pouch on his tool belt and kept working. Earl saw this (remember he's half owner of the company) and he said to the journeyman: "do you know how much those screws cost?" And the journeyman replied: "NO, I don't, but I do know that you can't afford to pay me to get down off this ladder to pick up the screw and then climb back up the ladder to keep working." Earl paused for a minute and then said: "you're right! But I can afford to pick up the screw(s) myself!" He then proceeded to walk around the job site and pick up all the dropped sheet metal screws to save himself some money. lolol.
 

ehcsrop

Active member
Joined
Aug 15, 2024
Messages
34
Location
Lakewood, CA
And you think a little cable is wasteful, just wait to you see how much your roofer cuts off the shingles, how many full sheets of drywall that could be patched together from the cut offs and how much window casing and baseboard is lost because the finish carpenter won't take the time to cut finger joints into every scrap and glue them together.
Or plan the yield. At least run through the house and make all the long cuts first. But I've seen and done worse. At least I can say I learned while many times not so much for others. I'd be surprised if you can't make a max yield cut list on a phone now.
 

RetiredSparky

New member
Joined
Apr 26, 2026
Messages
1
Why do electricians leave so much wire hanging out of the box? The electrician working at my new home leaves anywhere from 1 to 2 feet hanging out of the electrical box. I am paying for time and materials, so it irks me that he is so wastefull.
Cut it too short, you get yelled at. Cut it too short, you get fired!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom