im not a fan of spray paint on vises its just not durable enough however if you are looking for original wilton color the closet match is rustoleum spray paint, i have not found a store bought enamel that matches the wilton color yet. I think the origional color of wilton is muh IMO, its your vise if you want a different color thats 100% ok. When I redo my vises they are degreased, resurfaced and sanded if needed. I then apply 6 light coats of high gloss enamel paint to build it up to a thick durable finish, if you put on medium or heavy coats you will have run problems and improper curing causing cracking. A properly applied high gloss enamel finish looks great, is really durable and easy to clean