Wright or Snapon sockets

[Yankee]

Looking at replacing my old G series Craftsman 1/4 drive sockets (SAE and Metric)

Looking for a noticeable upgrade. Have decided either Snap on or Wright. I have a Wright set at work, but never seen the Snap on first hand.

I don’t mind spending the extra $$ as long as I can see a difference in quality.

I’m leaning towards Snapon, but not sure if there really is a difference between the two.

I know “a nut don’t see the brand that’s turning it”.... this is more of a “ I want the best and don’t mind spending more, as long as I see a difference”

Anyone have both that can tell me literally they see a difference between the two?

 

[1982fxr]

Current production Wright 1/4” have the ball detent right?

I think I’ve read on here that some of the old ones didn’t...?

 

[Yankee]

Yep, my work Wright set has a detent. (The Craftsman doesn’t)

 

[Empty Pockets]

I have a lot of Wright, you won't be disappointed

 

[Wamsutta]

Proto makes some nice 1/4 drive sockets too.

If money is no object, MAC sockets with the "R" at the end of he part number are super primo.

 

[Yankee]

I have a lot of Wright, you won't be disappointed

I have a Wright 1/4 drive metric at work and and all three drives ratchets and see the quality in Wright... but the Snapon ratchets blows Wright’s away.... just was t sure if the sockets were the same....

 

[ADSR]

Williams USA = Snap-On, just much cheaper.

https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=220196

 

[plinker]

If you have the Wrights at work, you know what to expect. The Snap-on should then meet or exceed said expectations. Up to you if the extra($) for the Snap-on is worth it.

My sets of 1/4 chrome sockets contain S-K, Snap-on & Craftsman/Allen. Have not had problems with any of them.

 

[Yankee]

If you have the Wrights at work, you know what to expect. The Snap-on should then meet or exceed said expectations. Up to you if the extra($) for the Snap-on is worth it.

That’s the delima, I don’t know what the Snapon look like.

Williams USA = Snap-On, just much cheaper.

I want to make sure I get USA and it seems like most Willliams are
Made overseas, which is a deal breaker for me...

 

[Yankee]

Proto makes some nice 1/4 drive sockets too.

If money is no object, MAC sockets with the "R" at the end of he part number are super primo.

Thanks for the input, but heart is set in either Wright or Snapon. Seems like the only thing I’ve ever liked from Stanley is their tape measures....

 

[ADSR]

call them before you order?

http://www.toolsdelivered.com/

 

[cjarvis]

Williams tools with alphanumeric item #'s are mfg in USA. Those with numeric item #'s only are mfg in Taiwan.

 

[Fedwrench]

Thanks for the input, but heart is set in either Wright or Snapon. Seems like the only thing I’ve ever liked from Stanley is their tape measures....

That's too bad. Current Proto chrome sockets have excellent chrome, are nicely finished inside & out, nice large size markings, and have a wider range of sizes in metric than Wright offers. They're also US Made.
However, it's your purchase, enjoy

 

[Yankee]

That's too bad. Current Proto chrome sockets have excellent chrome, are nicely finished inside & out, nice large size markings, and have a wider range of sizes in metric than Wright offers. They're also US Made.
However, it's your purchase, enjoy

Yeah I know.... I should keep my mind open... let’s put it this way......

My 1/4 I use more than anything. What is the “best” out there....

 

[Fedwrench]

Yeah I know.... I should keep my mind open... let’s put it this way......

My 1/4 I use more than anything. What is the “best” out there....

I can't answer for you because what I like, may not be what you like. pick up a socket you own, examine it. What do you like about it? What don't you like about it? How would you make it better?
No compare your notes and find something that matches all or as many of your parameters as possible

 

[nelstomlinson]

I have Wright and Snap-on sockets, and I'm very pleased with both. Buy the Snap-on semi-deeps, and the rest Wright, maybe.

 

[Yankee]

I can't answer for you because what I like, may not be what you like. pick up a socket you own, examine it. What do you like about it? What don't you like about it? How would you make it better?
No compare your notes and find something that matches all or as many of your parameters as possible

I appreciate all the input, that’s what I love about this site. Problem is I can’t see what Proto or Snapon or Mac , etc look like so that’s why asking what others have liked or experienced.

Thanks for the input!

 

[Yankee]

I have Wright and Snap-on sockets, and I'm very pleased with both. Buy the Snap-on semi-deeps, and the rest Wright, maybe.

Only really have a need for shallow. (Or at least right now) since you have both and would have to choose, which would you pick?

 

[Snapped-off]

Have you looked at USA-made Williams sockets? They're literally identical to my Snap-on sockets.

I wasn't too impressed with the 3/8 Wright sockets I had. The quality didn't seem to match the wrenches.

If you're set on Wright or Snap-on, I would choose Snap-on; but I am a biased kool-aid drinker.

 

[crf450x]

I only have experience with snap on and sk. I know that's not what you asked about but I can't tell any functional difference between them. Sk is less money by a long shot. The big set that comes with shallow/deep sockets and a ratchet is around $150.

 

[Tinner]

Williams USA = Snap-On, just much cheaper.

https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=220196

Because it looks the same it is the same.

 

[ADSR]

Because it looks the same it is the same.

Until I see proof they're not, I'm calling them the same.

 

[ADSR]

Williams USA is an excellent value

Agreed. Here's a Williams rolling out of the stamp at the snap-on factory....

 

[WittHay]

I only have experience with snap on and sk. I know that's not what you asked about but I can't tell any functional difference between them. Sk is less money by a long shot. The big set that comes with shallow/deep sockets and a ratchet is around $150.

My parts place always has this catalog with SK sets for sale. I am thinking about getting a 1/4" set. They look very Snap-on like to me. The Proto seem just a hair thicker or bigger than the Snap-on, more industrial like Gray and I assume Wright

 

[Wamsutta]

I can't vouch for Wright because don't have any of their sockets, but I can vouch for Snap-on. I have some of their 1/4 drive sockets and I am very impressed by them.

 

[Tinner]

Until I see proof they're not, I'm calling them the same.

Until I see proof that they are or aren't I'm not calling them one or the other. I have a Snap-on set at work that has 2 Williams pieces in it. They do look the same, but that proves nothing, nor does a couple seconds of some video, other than they are made in the same factory.

 

[ADSR]

Until I see proof that they are or aren't I'm not calling them one or the other. I have a Snap-on set at work that has 2 Williams pieces in it. They do look the same, but that proves nothing, nor does a couple seconds of some video, other than they are made in the same factory.

Well, I'm going to take the dealers word for it. He said they're made exactly the same, except for the extra polishing stages that make snap-on shine like jewelry.

EDIT: found the thread...

https://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showpost.php?p=3340720&postcount=21

 

[T45]

Yeah I know.... I should keep my mind open... let’s put it this way......

My 1/4 I use more than anything. What is the “best” out there....

Truly the best? IMHO I will throw out Hazet. Practically the best in the US are snap-on. There is no reason to buy something else than these two if you only need one set and "cost" is no object.

Don't forget HRC hardness, tolerances (both on hex and square), and other un-0bservable things are the key features of 1/4 drive tools. Hazet are 25mm with knurling. SO are 22mm tall with HRC at the higher end of any brand, and come in a 28mm optional variant (mid-deep).

What matters to people that use them alot vs people that just need their bases covered for DIY use is going to be probably pretty different.

If you were issued proto or wright (etc) at work of course I'm sure you'd also be happy. Its just a matter of whose dime and who's time you are on.

good luck whatever you choose.

 

[shawndp]

I have the Snap On Chrome shallow and deep 1/4 sets and they are extremely good... I can not think of a time when I have been disappointed with them. They will grab on to beaten up bolts that I feel like I am pushing my luck with (use the 12 and 13 a lot) and do their job. Yesterday i used the 14mm to pull the starter off a Rav 4 because I was being lazy and clearance issues. I have never seen or touched a Wright tool in my life, but given my level of satisfaction with my SO set, I do not really have the desire to. All the best!

 

[Htscheg]

Snap on for me, that said pick what you like and can afford!

 

[Mr_B]

Out of wright or snapon I prefer the snapon but hard justify the cost for 1/4 drive sockets.
would only buy sockets on rails rather than whole set unless you benefit from a set .
same quality or better can be had from likes of koken or stahlwille for 3rd of the price ...

 

[nelstomlinson]

Only really have a need for shallow. (Or at least right now) since you have both and would have to choose, which would you pick?

I'd choose on price, which would probably lead me to Wright. Both are great tools, but since I am not on a Snap On driver's route, Snap On's business model doesn't add value for me.

I have SK chrome semi-deeps in 1/4", Snap On chrome semi-deeps in 3/8" and Wright deeps in 1/2", all bought new in the last few years. All are solid performers, and I unhesitatingly recommend whichever of those you like.

The semi-deeps are my go-to sets unless I have to use a shallow or a deep, and that's rare.

 

[texchappy]

How about getting one socket in each and using them a while. Then you’d be able to tell first hand without a huge investment. Doing that led me to Nepros and Williams USA FWIW.

 

[Davefr]

If you want financing or to be pampered by a SO dealer then buy SO.

If those services aren't important, then buy Wright (or Proto, SK, Williams, etc). There's very few reasons to pay SO prices when you don't need their services offering.

 

[pi_guy]

I do not believe that any other manufacturers match the variety offered in 1/4 drive more than Snap ON.
For 40 years I have been very happy with the flex sockets there is nothing else that matches them. They did discontinue the deep flex sockets but if you have a set they are not replaceable with any other tool made.

 

[DadsTools]

The Snap-On looks more like jewelry to me. If eye candy is important, then it's hard to beat Snappy. If quality is the most important, then I think any of the top USA mfrs being mentioned in here will work great. I personally lean toward SK, but a lot of that is personal bias. But in the end, it's only a 1/4" drive, which if used as intended, isn't going to experience much abuse.

 

[neonlazer]

Never had an issue with my USA Williams! The ONLY possible negative is they do not offer USA made 1/2 chrome 6 point. I bought the impact version since most of the time that's what is needed.(I'm OCD about my sockets being the same..minus my large Sunex axle socket set lol)

 

[The Fall]

Just picked up some Wright deep well impacts (3/8" drive). While impacts (and not chrome), they're nice. Well worth the extra cost. And made in USA.

 

[HanShotFirst]

Looking at replacing my old G series Craftsman 1/4 drive sockets (SAE and Metric)

Looking for a noticeable upgrade. Have decided either Snap on or Wright. I have a Wright set at work, but never seen the Snap on first hand.

I don’t mind spending the extra $$ as long as I can see a difference in quality.

I’m leaning towards Snapon, but not sure if there really is a difference between the two.

I know “a nut don’t see the brand that’s turning it”.... this is more of a “ I want the best and don’t mind spending more, as long as I see a difference”

Anyone have both that can tell me literally they see a difference between the two?

Yankee,

Let me see if I can give you some food for thought.


Are you a pro-wrench turner? If you are, then service and warranty are going to be important. How important can only be answered by you.

#1
To my way of thinking, SnapOn is ONLY justified due to the warranty and the fact that the warranty station comes to me (service); which makes warranty for a broken socket a whole lot quicker and easier. THAT is what justifies the existence of tool trucks, and the price you pay for those tools. The HUGE difference in price is not the product, but the level of service that comes with the product.

#2
So if you’re ONLY considering Wright or SnapOn, I really think you’re doing yourself a disservice by not considering US made Williams if your warranty path will be via mail rather than truck (Personally, I’d be looking at Wright, Williams, Proto, and SK…but that’s just me)

#3
If I had such a conundrum, here’s how I would go about making my decision…
See if one of the tool houses can help you out with a sample of each; then you can physically lay eyes on the one’s you’re considering

I would call Harry J Epstein and tell them to send me a 12mm ¼” socket from Wright, Williams, Proto, and SK. Tell them you’re trying to decide on those vs. SnapOn, and that you would like to have the option of returning the sockets un-used when your decision is made. Next, order a 12mm ¼” from SnapOn and just know you’re going to keep it. Now do a side by side by side comparison and make your decision. Now I have no idea if HJE would agree to this, I’m just making a mental leap based on their history of outstanding customer service, which makes me think if anyone is going to do it, HJE is the place that would make it easy for you.

If you find value in this approach, the number for HJE is 800-821-5503...and maybe ask for Jori (he posts here, and he's a GREAT guy). But I have been happy with anyone I have talked to at HJE.

#4
I personally wouldn’t have such a conundrum, because I’m a BIG fan of the SK ¼” sets. Not only do I love their ¼” sockets, but I absolutely LOVE the old school SK ¼” ratchet (it’s my favorite of the SK’s). So I personally would just dig deep and buy the big SAE/Metric SK set complete with ratchet, short & deep sockets, and accessories. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000FAPVTK/?tag=atomicindus08-20

It sounds like you just want short sockets though…this is the set I have: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0002NYC9U/?tag=atomicindus08-20
Mine were my grandfathers, so mine were purchased probably in the 1950’s (or earlier) and I absolutely LOVE them. After 60+ years of service, none have broken, no chrome is flaked, but they have taken on a “patina” from years of use that has turned the chrome from a highly polished look, to more of a matte look. To me, they look like sockets should look after 60 years of service.

 

[pi_guy]

The Snap-On looks more like jewelry to me. If eye candy is important, then it's hard to beat Snappy. If quality is the most important, then I think any of the top USA mfrs being mentioned in here will work great. I personally lean toward SK, but a lot of that is personal bias. But in the end, it's only a 1/4" drive, which if used as intended, isn't going to experience much abuse.

Except the others do not offer the same products. If quality was more important you would pick SO.

I have abused my 1/4 well past what is expected. I have undone 9/16 header nuts where a 3/8 drive did not fit.
I run race cars I use 1/4 95% of the time with the exception of gearbox and wheel nuts and I still take the bulk of the gearbox apart with 1/4 inch.
Short 1/4 go up to 5/8ths
No I do not replace 1/4 sockets very much, the only ones I have warrantied is the flex sockets they been abused and when they are limp and fall over they are replaced. 3 or 4 times for 7/16 and 10mm ones.

Does SK replace flex sockets when they are limp?