Wright or Snapon sockets

[Mr_B]

^ he only on about basic 6 point sockets and to be fair for 1/4 drive huge amount of brands well up to the task . If on about chrome swivels then yes snapon pretty much the leader .
What I don't like about the wrights is they polished and no knurl so get bit slippery at times, snapon bit better but once again highly polished, stahlwille are one of my favourite, have koken myself and they done almost 3 decades no breakages to sockets, will bust drive square or fastener first and no way round off even at 14mm 9/16 sizes .
I wouldn't by either OPs choices but if that all he willing opt for then would go snapon as ergonomically little better .

 

[DadsTools]

Except the others do not offer the same products. If quality was more important you would pick SO.

I have abused my 1/4 well past what is expected. I have undone 9/16 header nuts where a 3/8 drive did not fit.
I run race cars I use 1/4 95% of the time with the exception of gearbox and wheel nuts and I still take the bulk of the gearbox apart with 1/4 inch.
Short 1/4 go up to 5/8ths
No I do not replace 1/4 sockets very much, the only ones I have warrantied is the flex sockets they been abused and when they are limp and fall over they are replaced. 3 or 4 times for 7/16 and 10mm ones.

Does SK replace flex sockets when they are limp?

Oh, here we go again....the Great God Snap-On. Say one thing that in the remotest sense doesn't proclaim Snappy as the best of the best of the best of the best of the best in everything everything everything everything and the true believers are ready to burn you at the stake for sacrilegious heresy. Give us a flippin' break.

For pity sake, the OP has been using Craftsman. What in the world do you think he's been doing with them? And what kind of unusual configuration do you think he's looking for if he's been using CM? Perhaps he's considering Wright because he's already found they have everything he wants? Why don't you ask the OP what his intended application is before ranting about floppy U sockets? Does Craftsman replace flex sockets when they're limp? If so, maybe he should stick with them, right? Besides, if SO are so good, why do they keep going limp? For the difference in the price of the entire set, especially the ones never warrantied, you could probably buy a whole box of the flexes that keep wearing out. So the SO truck guy will warrant for wear and tear when others might not--he SHOULD because he's still way ahead of you on the money game. You're not getting something for nothing, you already paid and paid and paid SO for it and then some.

I'm telling you, some (thankfully not all) make it sound just like a religion. Oy!

 

[nelstomlinson]

``Does Craftsman replace flex sockets when they're limp?''

Yes, they do. I have SK, Craftsman and Snap On flex sockets. None have gone limp, but Craftsman is the one brand that I am confident will replace anything if I'm not satisfied. The downside is that today they will probably replace it with Chinese junk.

I've never tried to warranty SK stuff, so I have no opinion. I've never found a Snap On driver willing to warranty anything, period.

 

[ChevyEFI]

Until I see proof that they are or aren't I'm not calling them one or the other. I have a Snap-on set at work that has 2 Williams pieces in it. They do look the same, but that proves nothing, nor does a couple seconds of some video, other than they are made in the same factory.

So the OP wants "better" with no idea what features need to be better.

And you know of differences in products while being unable to substantiate.

Wrench puns aside, that's quite a good combo.

My parts place always has this catalog with SK sets for sale. I am thinking about getting a 1/4" set. They look very Snap-on like to me. The Proto seem just a hair thicker or bigger than the Snap-on, more industrial like Gray and I assume Wright

I have had my 3/8" SK set 20 years and my 1/4" SK set(s) over 15yrs. They aren't going to suddenly fail and make the higher cost of other sets a better value, if cost matters. And they have left them largely the same for decades because they work. If you like the set they come in (no skips, save 4.5mm) and the plastic box suits you, go for it. Add a knurled spinner knob (I like SO) and roto ratchet, and you'all be able to access and turn many, many bolts.

 

[WittHay]

So the OP wants "better" with no idea what features need to be better

I had my 3/8" SK set 20 years and my 1/4" SK set(s) over 15yrs. They aren't going to suddenly fail and make the higher cost of other sets a better value, if cost matters. And they have left them largely the same for decades because they work. If you like the set they come in (no skips, save 4.5mm) and the plastic box suits you, go for it. Add a knurled spinner knob (I like SO) and roto ratchet, and you'all be able to access and turn many, many bolts.

I know exactly what I want and that why the SK set caught my eye. I like the shorter 1/4 sockets like what Snap-on/SK makes vs. the newer slightly longer sockets like GearWrench and Napa. Have some Proto 1/4 drive 12-point sockets, good sockets but the wall thickness just seems bigger than the Snap-on or old Craftsman

Lastly the price in can 10 piece SAE socket set SK $78.70 vs. Snap-on $154.95

 

[JohnDeere1]

I have Wright and Snap on and it's not Apple's to Apple's ,Wright sockets are thicker and designed for industrial use and Snap on is for auto repair what both have in common are strong quality steel, USA made, beautiful chrome, lifetime warranty as well as easy warranty 1 phone call, differences like I said thick vs thin as well as length or height and most of all Price. Snap on offers more sizes and styles.

I love all my Wright tools I have alot but also have alot of Snap on and I don't consider them equals but both are great were talking 1/4 there will not be a noticeable difference between your Craftsman I own many 1/4 I own them in every truck brand and industrial brand and nothing stands out to me so what one might me shinier than the other but none is going to out perform the other in any way want me to prove it I can lol. Buy whatever you want but just don't expect any difference in performance and who cares about chrome you can see your face off all them some just have different hues.
Snap on is not all that special to me I have a ton of it I like my matco tools equal as well as my Wright or Williams USA which by the way are just like the snap on very subtle difference. I Can take pics of the different sockets if you want just name the brands to compare or you want to see but looks don't matter and all are quality I'd just go by price.

 

[DadsTools]

I have Wright and Snap on and it's not Apple's to Apple's ,Wright sockets are thicker and designed for industrial use and Snap on is for auto repair what both have in common are strong quality steel, USA made, beautiful chrome, lifetime warranty as well as easy warranty 1 phone call, differences like I said thick vs thin as well as length or height and most of all Price. Snap on offers more sizes and styles.

I love all my Wright tools I have alot but also have alot of Snap on and I don't consider them equals but both are great were talking 1/4 there will not be a noticeable difference between your Craftsman I own many 1/4 I own them in every truck brand and industrial brand and nothing stands out to me so what one might me shinier than the other but none is going to out perform the other in any way want me to prove it I can lol. Buy whatever you want but just don't expect any difference in performance and who cares about chrome you can see your face off all them some just have different hues.
Snap on is not all that special to me I have a ton of it I like my matco tools equal as well as my Wright or Williams USA which by the way are just like the snap on very subtle difference. I Can take pics of the different sockets if you want just name the brands to compare or you want to see but looks don't matter and all are quality I'd just go by price.

Yep, this.

 

[Yankee]

thanks all for your replies.....I decided to go with Wright. Price and this comment

I have Wright and Snap on and it's not Apple's to Apple's ,Wright sockets are thicker and designed for industrial use and Snap on is for auto repair what both have in common are strong quality steel, USA made, beautiful chrome, lifetime warranty as well as easy warranty 1 phone call, differences like I said thick vs thin as well as length or height and most of all Price.[/COLOR]

I prefer the beefer style sockets, I never seen Snap on so knowing this now, I know I would like the Wrights better.....

I did kinda go overboard..... what initially was a replacement set for my 1/4 shallows, I ended up replacing everything I have... (1/4, 3/8 and 1/2. metric, standard, shallow and deep.......)

I'll send photos when all comes in....

 

[L.Cheapo]

thanks all for your replies.....I decided to go with Wright. Price and this comment

I have Wright and Snap on and it's not Apple's to Apple's ,Wright sockets are thicker and designed for industrial use and Snap on is for auto repair what both have in common are strong quality steel, USA made, beautiful chrome, lifetime warranty as well as easy warranty 1 phone call, differences like I said thick vs thin as well as length or height and most of all Price.[/COLOR]

I prefer the beefer style sockets, I never seen Snap on so knowing this now, I know I would like the Wrights better.....

I did kinda go overboard..... what initially was a replacement set for my 1/4 shallows, I ended up replacing everything I have... (1/4, 3/8 and 1/2. metric, standard, shallow and deep.......)

I'll send photos when all comes in....

There are times when the beefier style presents a problem. The only socket I could get for the front axle nuts on my truck on an "I need it right now" basis was a Wright socket. A fine socket, indeed. But the walls were too thick to fit in the hub. So I had to run to a machine shop and get them to turn it down so it would fit in the hub.

That ended up being one expensive socket. Still have it!

 

[panknuckshovel]

Never had an issue with my USA Williams! The ONLY possible negative is they do not offer USA made 1/2 chrome 6 point. I bought the impact version since most of the time that's what is needed.(I'm OCD about my sockets being the same..minus my large Sunex axle socket set lol)

Set WSSD-11hrc is 1/2" 6 point USA

 

[MaverickDMD]

I own Craftsman G, Snap On and Wright sockets. The Craftsman G's are really good sockets.

The reason I bought the Wrights is because I couldn't find any more Craftsman G series without buying one at a time - too frustrating to source a whole uniform set.

The reason I bought the Snap Ons is because I bought the Wrights. Wrights are good sockets but I couldn't get past the difference in the chrome colour from the G's - too blue/cheap looking IMHO.

The Snap Ons are the perfect shade match and are very similar in build to the G's. So I'd go with the Snap Ons to ensure you'll be happy. Either is of course a good choice, but I feel your pain with the Craftsman G's.

 

[Tennessee Cattleman]

Snap on chrome finish is better than Wright, the chrome finish on SK is better than Wright, pretty close to Snap-on. Wright tools are very good, just not the best chrome finish.

 

[1982fxr]

thanks all for your replies.....I decided to go with Wright. Price and this comment

I have Wright and Snap on and it's not Apple's to Apple's ,Wright sockets are thicker and designed for industrial use and Snap on is for auto repair what both have in common are strong quality steel, USA made, beautiful chrome, lifetime warranty as well as easy warranty 1 phone call, differences like I said thick vs thin as well as length or height and most of all Price.[/COLOR]

I prefer the beefer style sockets, I never seen Snap on so knowing this now, I know I would like the Wrights better.....

I did kinda go overboard..... what initially was a replacement set for my 1/4 shallows, I ended up replacing everything I have... (1/4, 3/8 and 1/2. metric, standard, shallow and deep.......)

I'll send photos when all comes in....

Can’t wait for these pics...

 

[ADSR]

I own Craftsman G, Snap On and Wright sockets. The Craftsman G's are really good sockets.

The reason I bought the Wrights is because I couldn't find any more Craftsman G series without buying one at a time - too frustrating to source a whole uniform set.

The reason I bought the Snap Ons is because I bought the Wrights. Wrights are good sockets but I couldn't get past the difference in the chrome colour from the G's - too blue/cheap looking IMHO.

The Snap Ons are the perfect shade match and are very similar in build to the G's. So I'd go with the Snap Ons to ensure you'll be happy. Either is of course a good choice, but I feel your pain with the Craftsman G's.

Growing up in , there was a Wright tool truck I saw every day going to school.

 

[1950mercury]

Wright deep sockets do not have shallow broaching, if that matters to you. Sk 1/4 sockets quality control is ****.

 

[Yankee]

We’ll some of it has come in. Was going to post pictures once it’s all in but here are a few. Totally satisfied. While I’m sure Snap On’s chrome is better, these sockets scream quality......

 

[ADSR]

^^ Very nice purchase, sir.

 

[Yankee]

Wright deep sockets do not have shallow broaching, if that matters to you. Sk 1/4 sockets quality control is ****.

Sockets 17mm and 11/16 and smaller the broaching is about a quarter of the socket depth....

 

[Yankee]

Broaching..

 

[yamaha0343]

Once you get to the level of Snap On, Wright, USA Williams, SK, and Proto sockets, you're doing well either way.

 

[Yankee]

Everything is in with the exception of one 1/2 extension.

I know I was originally was looking at just 1/4, but I figured you only live once so why not just do it all and be done with it.....

A couple of things to mention... I was surprised Wright doesn't make any 1/2 drive metric 6 point sockets..

Also on the 1/2 drive deep metrics, they make a 26mm but not a 27mm...

As stated before, I'm extremely satisfied with the quality, and worth every penny.

I took another picture to show how "beefy" these are (it's the 1/2" drive 3/4 socket) I know for some that they want as thin as possible, but I guarentee your not going to split this thing.....