View thread (33 replies)
G

GarageMac

Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2009
Messages
7
Awesome!

$100 in 1957 is about $850 today. Anyone want to do the work to see what these total from Snap On now?
 
S

sselander

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2008
Messages
2,041
Location
CT
57 years later, nothings changed ...

"In ratchets, however, I think you can do just as well with SK at a lower price. SK is an admirable line of good quality. While most of the line doesn't match Snap-On's, the price tags are much more attractive."
 
R

Russ G

Active member
Joined
Dec 14, 2013
Messages
35
Location
Interlake area, Manitoba
Snap on makes nice stuff, no doubt about it. I can't justify the price though. I buy Mastercraft Maximum brand marketed by Canadian Tire. The tools feel just as nice in my hand and are covered by a lifetime warranty. I have only had to get one piece replaced and I just took it to customer service and got the replacement off the shelf. Nobody said well...you must have done this or you must have had a pipe on it or whatever. That was an interesting article. I love old magazines like that.
 
C

C96

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 30, 2013
Messages
1,251
Nice article Ryan, forgot how much simpler life was back then (especially the tool requirement for general auto repair). I wonder if the mechanics of that era realized how easy they had it when working on an engine. You pop the hood and it was as if the engine were on a stand waiting for you. Large engine compartments, basic technology, easy access to everything as if designed with the mechanic in mind. Now, pop the hood and…. Oh ****, just a big plastic box, plastic covers, shrouding, disguises, where the hell is the engine? Can’t even slip a piece of paper between the fender well and engine anymore….:( Lol.

All the specialty tools required now days just to accomplish minor repairs is mind boggling. :willy_nil
 
M

malibu101

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 1, 2005
Messages
3,908
Location
Walnutport PA
I like the 2nd page that shows a
"complete Snap-On socket wrench kit (that) is a must for doing full-bore automotive work.".

That was a comprehensive socket kit of the time. :wtf:

How did the Snap-On man of the era stay in business when a guy only needed a few basic tools. :lol:
Instead of always needing a new tool for new models or access in todays crowded engine bays. :willy_nil
 
J

joel63

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
1,909
Location
Central FL
sselander said:
57 years later, nothings changed ...

Snap On back then, Snap On today --- SK back then, Sk today --- good quality tools still lead the pack.

All factors taken into account, price is always a prime consideration. And will always be. <--------- joel63



"In ratchets, however, I think you can do just as well with SK at a lower price. SK is an admirable line of good quality. While most of the line doesn't match Snap-On's, the price tags are much more attractive."
Click to expand...


In the early 60's I was a fan of Williams, which were in my machine shop class, but I was nowhere in a position to buy tools.

Thanks Mr. Ryan for the little look into yesteryear.
:beer:
 
Last edited:
L

lilredex

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 29, 2006
Messages
5,956
Location
Toronto
Was there in '57, and I can assure you most mechanics of the day were always working on a collection like that. DIY-ers like me, had a whole lot less. More like a hammer, screw driver and a pair of pliers. Tool choices were very limited then and Expensive, If guys like Canadian Tire and Princess Auto had a been around then with their current offerings...........history would look a lot different!!
 
L

littlebritishcar

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Messages
102
Location
Napa. CA
Pretty cool. It said that most pros have about $1,000 dollars invested in their tools. That is $8,409 when adjusted by the annual consumer price index from 1957 to 2012.

My dad and grandfather always told me, "home mechanics but Craftsman and Pros buy Snap-On or Proto but no self-respecting man buys cheap Japanese ****." I guess Japanese **** has been replaced with Chinese junk.
 
T

trainer

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 28, 2005
Messages
2,019
Location
Northern Ontario, Canada
lilredex said:
Was there in '57, and I can assure you most mechanics of the day were always working on a collection like that. DIY-ers like me, had a whole lot less. More like a hammer, screw driver and a pair of pliers. Tool choices were very limited then and Expensive, If guys like Canadian Tire and Princess Auto had a been around then with their current offerings...........history would look a lot different!!
Click to expand...


I agree!
As far as tools go, Right now is the "good old days"
You can buy lifetime- guaranteed tools in just about any price range.
The used market is more accessible than ever because of ebay and craigslist.

Even some of the cheap stuff can be quite servicable if you dont abuse it.
 
N

Nader

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
113
Location
East of Seattle
I have a similar kit of vintage Snap-On tools that I picked up at a garage sale. Lately, I've been using it exclusively to make repairs on my older cars, and have rarely had to go to my bigger box of tools. Old, simple cars are nice that way. Ignore that newer, reliable 4-Runner in the background.
 

Attachments

  • box1.jpg
    box1.jpg
    136.7 KB · Views: 224
  • box2.jpg
    box2.jpg
    143.8 KB · Views: 187
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
G

gigamel

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 7, 2012
Messages
189
Considering how Snap-On tools has gained weight and thickness over the years, this is a really funny comment:

"The cheap wrench will be thicker and heavier than better ones. This extra thickness will make the wrench unusable in many parts of the car"

Now a days the thickness of the open end of a 17mm Snap-On combination wrench is 8mm (5/16") making it impossible to do a proper brake job on GM Lucas brakes. They used to be 7,5mm (19/64")

All the top tier brands 16mm 1/2" sockets measures between 22,1 and 22,8 mm a cross the socket end - that includes Craftsman!

A Snap-On shallow chrome 16mm 1/2" socket is a whopping 23,8 mm (15/16") - rendering it useless on BMW M43 engines. To put that in perspective a Nepros 17mm(!) 1/2" socket comes in at only 23,3 mm!

In the good old days the Snap-On 16mm socket was 23,0mm (29/32")

It is like Snap-On used to make tools for the mechanics (like the other brands) - now Snap-On make tools for the share-holders - overbuild tools they never have to warrant :sad:

I totally agree with the comment above that "the good old days" for tools are right now - but for Snap-On "the good old days" really seems to be the good old days - decades ago. :dunno:

So Nader, hold on to your beautiful vintage Snap-On set - it's the best Snap-On will ever make. :thumbup:
 
R

Ronny

Active member
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Messages
30
I only use snap ons special brake wrenches, those things that look like pocket knives. :beer:
I served my Apprenticeship in the early 1970's and tools back then were seriously expensive. Even so we were paid a tool allowance by the company as part of our "contract" as Apprentices. We were expected to show our tool collection on occasion to show we were actually buying tools,not spending it on booze,women etc. I still have all of the tools i bought back then with brands such as Stahlwille and Hazet. But we also made a lot of things,most of which i still use today ,such as drill jigs,depth gauge sets,etc etc . A premium paid back then served me well for all these years.
A good source of tools has been estate sales where i have come across some really nice gear and i feel sad the former owners descendants place so little value on them ,especailly as these same tools probably helped clothe and feed them.
 
J

jkwilson

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Messages
758
Location
SW Indiana
C96 said:
You pop the hood and it was as if the engine were on a stand waiting for you. Large engine compartments, basic technology, easy access to everything as if designed with the mechanic in mind. Now, pop the hood and…. Oh ****, just a big plastic box, plastic covers, shrouding, disguises, where the hell is the engine? Can’t even slip a piece of paper between the fender well and engine anymore….:( Lol.
Click to expand...

I remember rebuilding the carburetor on my dad's 77 GMC truck with a straight six. I was able to stand on the ground next to the engine to do most of the work.

Now you drop a socket and hope it somehow finds its way through to the floor and doesn't get stuck on some kind of shield.
 
N

n8n

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
3,607
Location
Curtis Bay, MD
sselander said:
57 years later, nothings changed ...

"In ratchets, however, I think you can do just as well with SK at a lower price. SK is an admirable line of good quality. While most of the line doesn't match Snap-On's, the price tags are much more attractive."
Click to expand...

I had to chuckle at that as well, as I'm more of an "Advanced hobbyist" The shop foreman at my friend's shop is a total Snap-On snob, and I love me some SK. Some things never change.
 
A

Adam.C

Banned
Joined
Jan 29, 2013
Messages
1,490
Recently seeking similar advise, I turned to the web pages of community colleges and vo-tech schools. Their automotive programs often specify tools required for their classes. Here in the US, the requirement is still full sets of sockets and wrenches in inch and metric sizes.

Modern car makers are using an ever increasing variety of screw heads. Most schools recommend full sets of torx, allen, and inverse torx sockets. Of course we know there are other types of torx as well as "secure" versions of torx and allen.


Styling, and aero reqts have driven car bodies to the point that some fasteners are no longer readily accessible. It seems to me no self respecting shade tree mechanic should be without swivel sockets, ratcheting box wrenches, and wobble extensions. I have short and long versions of just about every tool I own to aid accessibility.

No question cars are more complicated today than they were 50 years ago. They are much better performing, longer lasting, and safer as well. But I would be loathe to offer this same advice to "hot rodders" today or even pro mechanics today. A good first set of "basic" tools seems to be EVERYTHING. Then add more when car makers reinvent the hex head bolt again, or come up with a way to form sheetmetal around the engine and call it a body.
 
2

2jz4me

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 25, 2011
Messages
114
Location
se indiana
Sweet, I'm going to print that coupon and get 50% off at JC Whitney!

I will of course send the $.25 to cover part of the shipping for the catalog.:lol:
 
Last edited:
J

jkwilson

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Messages
758
Location
SW Indiana
Last edited:
L

Lassen Forge

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
15,185
Location
The romantic hills of central Umbria, Italy,
Ronny said:
... I served my Apprenticeship in the early 1970's and tools back then were seriously expensive. Even so we were paid a tool allowance by the company as part of our "contract" as Apprentices... I still have all of the tools i bought back then with brands such as Stahlwille and Hazet. But we also made a lot of things,most of which i still use today ,such as drill jigs,depth gauge sets,etc etc . A premium paid back then served me well for all these years.
Click to expand...

About the same time I started building my collection and "went to work" - same era --grins--... I had to "make do" with Craftsman for a lot of my gear, but back then they were good quality - they could do most jobs, and not break or bork them up, and I can't tell you the number of their wrenches I've either filed down to a thin-jaw (for brake or euro-spec work) or heated and bent for a specific application... and they kept on working - because I couldn't afford Snap-on (I still have a lot of those, and they still work well)... Of course now, I wouldn't buy or trust the Sears Crapshoot brand with a 10 foot pole on anything I work on...
 
K

Kev442

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2009
Messages
5,386
Location
Wi
It is pretty amazing how few tools a guy needed back then. My Dad was a grease jockey in HS, an airplane mechanic in the Navy and employed as a repairman from '59-62. His sole ratchet set from '59-76 was a Williams 3/8ths. In '76 he needed to do a head job on a '67 Belvedere and bought a SK 1/2" set. I doubt he ever touched the 1/2" set again. Not needed to wrench on lawn mowers, etc the rest of his life. He gave me the SK set two years ago, it's like new.
 
R

rodm1

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 17, 2008
Messages
2,270
My dad whose a GM tech in the 60's and it's surprising how few tools he had. His tools probably would fit in a small craftsman top box.
 
C

chicane

Well-known member
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
553
Location
Central Virginia
Lassen Forge said:
About the same time I started building my collection and "went to work" - same era --grins--... I had to "make do" with Craftsman for a lot of my gear, but back then they were good quality - they could do most jobs, and not break or bork them up, and I can't tell you the number of their wrenches I've either filed down to a thin-jaw (for brake or euro-spec work) or heated and bent for a specific application... and they kept on working - because I couldn't afford Snap-on (I still have a lot of those, and they still work well)... Of course now, I wouldn't buy or trust the Sears Crapshoot brand with a 10 foot pole on anything I work on...
Click to expand...

I have used Craftsman's Professional line hand tools for years. I have a Craftsman's Professional chest as well, it was so heavy it nearly destroyed my truck taking it home. Craftsman's Professional are excellent quality and I would put them up against ****-On or any of that over priced BS.
 
L

LifeLongWNYer

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2013
Messages
1,231
Location
South of Rochester, NY
Two comments from me.

First of all, the needs for wrenches is now doubled since America has coddled those who want to convert us to metric sizes. Now we need to have a full set of metric tools.

My uncle sold farm machinery when I was just a kid and he gave me a SK 1/4" ratchet set for Christmas one year. Except for a socket that I left under a girlfriends hood years ago, I still have it and think of Uncle Harry every time that I use it. Some of you guys mentioned SK, are they still in business, and if so, who carries the line now?

Great post, thanks!


.
 
N

n8n

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
3,607
Location
Curtis Bay, MD
LifeLongWNYer said:
Two comments from me.

First of all, the needs for wrenches is now doubled since America has coddled those who want to convert us to metric sizes. Now we need to have a full set of metric tools.

My uncle sold farm machinery when I was just a kid and he gave me a SK 1/4" ratchet set for Christmas one year. Except for a socket that I left under a girlfriends hood years ago, I still have it and think of Uncle Harry every time that I use it. Some of you guys mentioned SK, are they still in business, and if so, who carries the line now?

Great post, thanks!
Click to expand...

Yes, and pretty much you have to buy online... they have a 'dealer locator' on their web site but it's returned nothing but Grainger anywhere I've tried. Amazon and Tooltopia usually have OK pricing however.
 
M

metlmunchr

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
1,278
Snap on pricing is past insane. Working on my wife's car recently and needed a 7mm 1/4" drive flex socket to get to one of the screws that holds the cover over the coil packs and plugs.

Checked at the local NAPA, O'Reilly, and Advance and none of them had it. Sears site showed they had a couple of them in stock at about $7 Sears is 15 miles from my house and there's a Snap on peddler who lives a couple miles away. Looked up online to check the Snappy price, figuring if it was anywhere near reasonable I'd get one from him rather than waste an hour going to Sears. $40 for that socket from Snap on, and if you'd like a set of them covering 5.5 mm to 15 mm that's only $460. Went to Sears for the $7 socket which was made in the US.

Between hand tools, power tools, measuring tools, and machine tools I've got north of $300,000 worth of tools I use to make a living. But, other than for bragging rights, the logic of buying 1/4' drive sockets at 40 bucks apiece just goes right over my head.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!