Farmall:
I picked your post to respond to, because I think it's most relevant.
Perhaps this wasn't the place to make this post, but I stand by my statements. I have been in marketing for 25+ years, and I can tell you with absolute certainty that this IS a BIG DEAL. I was not and am not trying to bash SK as a brand, but am STATING A FACT that this was handled unbelievably poorly by them. You need to do no more than read this thread to see how many people have been disappointed by them so far. Pages and pages of 'nothing yet' or similar comments.
SK screwed up BIG TIME in ONE area - communication:
Did *YOU* get a response saying that your request had been received? I didn't.
Did *YOU* get a response saying that you were or were not eligible for this promotion? I didn't.
Did *YOU* get a response saying that they were overwhelmed and needed more time to fulfill the offer? I didn't.
At this point I have no idea whether I will or won't even get a catalog?!
My point in all this is that they did a NICE thing with the offer, but totally blew it on the execution!!! I am pretty sure that any goodwill they intended to generate has now been neutralized - i.e. they wasted their time, effort, and money.
You and others are also correct that nobody is going to die if they don't get a free hat. My post - perhaps worded a bit strongly because I am passionate about expectations in sales and marketing - was that this whole mess could be used as a case study in Marketing 101 on how NOT to do a promotion.
And to others who asked, essentially, "what harm was done" - the answer is that the ability to trust SK to follow through has been called into question. I realize that they are building or rebuilding the brand, and I not only applaud them for that -
I wish them great success. I am considering them for future tool purchases, but - like others - am watching to see how things play out.
This just wasn't handled well, and I hope they are able to get their marketing act together.
Sorry if I wasn't clear or some people misunderstood my post. I'll get off my 'marketing excellence' soapbox now, and go back to being a tool nerd. Maybe I can find a hot deal to post next, instead of a diatribe.