To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Battery Chainsaws - What do you like?

Davefr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
11,822
Location
OR
I'd like a new battery chainsaw. My old 40V Kobalt is a piece of ****. It runs so slow you can almost feel each cutter contacting the log. I have gas saws but for simple quick storm cleanup tasks or occasional pruning I'd something to grab and go. On my short list is Makita, Dewalt, Echo and Stihl. They're all about $300 with battery and charger. Milwaukie is around $500 which is too high. (I don't have batteries or can share the platform with any of them). Then there are the $150 no names ones on Amazon that have surprisingly good reviews. (some look almost identical to the name brands)

I'm leaning Makita because they're both a chainsaw company and power tool company and maybe their 18v battery platform could be useful for future tools vs. orphan batteries in the case of Stihl or Echo. What say you? TIA
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

dogdog

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
12,711
I have the Kobalt 80v seems ok, haven’t cut anything with it yet. There is a YouTube comparison test on this I think.
 

dr_clyde

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Messages
6,436
Location
Holland, MI
I just bought the Milwaukee and it is a ROCK STAR. I am accustomed to Stihl pro grade saws and I'm extremely impressed with this saw. You're not going to be felling massive trees nor will you be cutting cords of firewood with it, but I've used it for a fair amount of downed tree cleanup and yard maint. stuff.

If you don't' want into the M'kee system, then I'd go with the Makita for the reasons you mentioned. Stihl stuff is really nice, my dad has some, but the batteries are $$$.

I would urge you to reconsider the M'kee stuff though, I am slowly buying more and more stuff from them and I find myself wondering why it took me so long. Their cordless offerings are incredible.
 

autobon7

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 27, 2010
Messages
730
My workplace has a Milwaukee and its been outstanding. Had it for a couple of years now. Seems to have good runtime with batteries 8.0 and higher.
 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
DeWalt all day long. Outperforms similar gas models...

Cuts much faster than Milwaukee, Ryobi, etc


Watch this video and see for yourself...




Round 2 video he puts the DeWalt which won round 1 easily against the chainsaw mfg's electric models. The only one it didn't beat soundly was an Echo

See for yourself and Goodluck
 

Sneezer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 14, 2019
Messages
328
Location
DFW, TX
I have the Kobalt 80V one and it has done well for me, although I have only used it to cut down two small dead trees. I got mine as a display model for 30 bucks though when Lowes stopped selling them in store a couple years ago.
 

dogdog

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
12,711
I have the Kobalt 80V one and it has done well for me, although I have only used it to cut down two small dead trees. I got mine as a display model for 30 bucks though when Lowes stopped selling them in store a couple years ago.
they still sell then online orders only. The 80v stuff.
 

Sneezer

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 14, 2019
Messages
328
Location
DFW, TX
they still sell then online orders only. The 80v stuff.
Yeah, I know, but they don't get discounted as much anymore. That 80V firesale was great, picked up the chainsaw, hedge trimmer, blower, weed whacker and a backpack blower along with batteries for super cheap. Probably spent less than $150 total.
 

nafterclifen

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
525
Location
Poconos, PA
Dewalt 20v works good. BUT...it uses oil like crazy and it leaks oil. And having to press the safety switch before you can pull the trigger and cut gets really old and annoying real quick.
 

Crazyjake8493

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 26, 2014
Messages
3,953
Location
Upstate NY
I've had the Milwaukee 18v chainsaw since it came out and it's been great with either a 9ah or 12ah battery. Serves my purpose enough for a homeowner that I sold my Stihl gas saw. No more mixed gas necessary here, just some ethanol-free gas for the mower and generator.
 

Buckaroo5

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2012
Messages
820
Location
Central Ohio
Ego 56V here. Lots of power and run time. Although I have both Milwaukee 12V & 18V hand tools, I have settled on the Ego platform for garden tools.
 

ATC

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
8,268
Location
VA
LOOOOVE my Milwaukee! My MS180 collects dust on the shelf now...


M18chainsaw.jpg
 

Renegade1LI

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 11, 2018
Messages
4,938
Location
long island ny
I have had great luck with the dewalt 60volt, cuts great, great run time with the flexvolt batteries. Keep a spare chain and a couple batteries and can cut for hours.
 

Attachments

  • C7E1DF55-2C2C-4065-839A-CEC3CFFFDB68.jpeg
    C7E1DF55-2C2C-4065-839A-CEC3CFFFDB68.jpeg
    840.4 KB · Views: 28
  • 17E4C108-A687-413D-B2EC-C19E258ADE04.jpeg
    17E4C108-A687-413D-B2EC-C19E258ADE04.jpeg
    960.2 KB · Views: 26

toolmanmark

Active member
Joined
Jan 2, 2011
Messages
31
Ego 56V here. Lots of power and run time. Although I have both Milwaukee 12V & 18V hand tools, I have settled on the Ego platform for garden tools. same
Same here. Milwaukee and Ego. I have 18" chainsaw, string trimmer and blower. Chainsaw is great.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Buckgnarly

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
7,651
Location
VT
Milwaukee here, GREAT for 80% of the stuff I cut. Still need the gas for big or long jobs, but the Milwaukee has more than lived up to expectations.
 

subroc

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
781
Location
Dover, NH
I have a Dewalt 20v chainsaw with a 12" blade. I would characterIze it as a light duty limbing saw. I live in a development. Lots aren't that big. The saw gets used mostly for cleaning up any dead limbs that fall from trees, yard clean up, overgrowth control, limbing as needed and occasionally for cutting up construction materials. This saw is plenty of saw for my needs. If I had different needs I might have a different saw.
 

Rinspeed

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2020
Messages
1,819
Location
NY
I'm leaning Makita because they're both a chainsaw company and power tool company and maybe their 18v battery platform could be useful for future tools vs. orphan batteries in the case of Stihl or Echo. What say you? TIA






After researching it for a couple weeks I went with the Makita 36V that came with four batteries. We use it mostly on the Grizzly for clearing trails and what not and always have it when we are camping. I was a little skeptical at first but it has by far exceeded our expectations.
 

redragoon

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2018
Messages
296
Location
Greenville SC
I bought the 40V Greenworks 16" because I already had some of their hedge trimmers.
Managed to clean up a 40' pine tree that fell at the back of the property. Not as powerful as other brands, but it cut through everything on a single battery charge.
If I ever need more power, I'll get a gas one.
 

Rabid Badger

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 2, 2018
Messages
1,338
I'm leaning Makita because they're both a chainsaw company and power tool company and maybe their 18v battery platform could be useful for future tools vs. orphan batteries in the case of Stihl or Echo. What say you? TIA

Trust your instincts. You want the XCU07, with the heavier duty bar retention.


Or, if you can wait a couple months the new XGT is even more of a beast.

 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
Just to add...

If you're ever going to get into a cordless platform then you definitely need to look af the big 3.
Dewalt, Makita or Milwaukee

The DeWalt 60v 16" saw is clearly the best of the bunch.
I've got a Husqvarna 16" gas that just screams and the DeWalt 60v saw outperforms it just like the Stihl it out performed in the video above.

Some things to consider....
Price?
The DeWalt 60v 16" can be had with battery and charger for $329
Get a ****** battery and it's still under your ceiling @ $399

Milwaukee no matter what is costing you $450

Makita has sinilar deal to DeWalt @ $329

If you ever think you might need or want an electric string trimmer again the DeWalt absolutely outperforms the other trimmers.

***Other notes to consider***
Availability of other items
DeWalt and Milwaukee are much more readily available. All the box stores have broad inventory plus places like ACE Hardware even have a good selection of DeWalt and Milwaukee.
Makita has a presence there but it's a much smaller presence in those stores.

Country of origin...
If that's important to you (it means a lot to me)
DeWalt makes many cordless power tools in the USA.
Not the entire lineup but a good amount are made right here. Drills/hammer drills, drivers, impact guns, (their new dcf891 is king. Tons of power in a semi compact size) reciprocating saws, grease guns, Made in USA.

Milwaukee only makes a cordless vacuum in the USA. Of all their tools they're only doing one that's made in USA

Makita makes absolutely everything in Asia. 100 percent of their tools are Asian made.
I used to be a Makita guy but switched everything over to DeWalt because of the COO which I hadn't realized until last year.
Sonething that's important to me.

If you think you'll never ever need or want other cordless power tools then buy an Echo electric which was the only saw (gas or electric) that ran with the DeWalt.

Good luck in your endeavor
 

Mohawk Dave

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 7, 2012
Messages
5,068
Location
SoCal
My M18 is awesome when comparing the ease of use to a gas saw... And I've had and used many gas Stihls. I take the M18 in the truck when camping now... But wouldn't use it for logging all day of course, it is slower than a big gas saw as expected and that's ok.

Recently got the M12 Hatchet... That little thing kicks **** for limbing trees and big hedges on my property.
 

Rabid Badger

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 2, 2018
Messages
1,338
Makita makes absolutely everything in Asia. 100 percent of their tools are Asian made.
I used to be a Makita guy but switched everything over to DeWalt because of the COO which I hadn't realized until last year.
Sonething that's important to me.
Makita has factories around the world, including one in Buford, Georgia.

You keep making this claim despite being called out multiple times. Why is that?
 

dr_clyde

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Messages
6,436
Location
Holland, MI
Makita is also a Japanese company, so it makes sense that most of their tools are made in Asia. You know, where Japan is. And yes, they have a Georgia plant that makes primarily grinders, IIRC.

It's also pretty comical that DeWalt touts their Made in USA claims when a large majority of the SBD line is imported. I'm sure they have some assembly plants here and that's great and all, but do people really think that SBD is making battery cells and winding motors in hometown USA? Are the plastic clamshells molded here? Where are the MOSFETs and battery controllers made? What about the chucks and gears for the drills? The battery chargers? There's SO MANY parts in modern power tools that it is pure naivety to assume Joe Blue Collar is actually making cordless drills in Texas or wherever. More like industrial LEGO, just assemble all the premade parts and slap a sticker on it. Who actually takes the raw stock and makes parts? They don't list a COO for all the components for everything.

Hell, the US only has one SMALL lithium mine in Nevada. No matter what tools you buy, pretty much guaranteed the batteries have Australian or Chinese lithium in the cells.

It's a global world, and while I like supporting USA manufacturing as much as anyone, we're kidding ourselves if we think these tool building jobs are anything more than assembling imported parts in a big warehouse factory. Dewalt themselves say it on the sticker. Made in USA With Global Materials. From their website: "We’re proud to make select products in the U.S.A. with global materials. We source raw materials and components from around the world when they are either not available in the United States or not viable to purchase based on cost, quality, or availability." They pretty much give themselves an out based on whatever factor they deem relevant.

Assembled in the USA is a step in the right direction, for sure, but I can't help but feel deceived. I know better. There is a big difference between cutting gears and molding parts (high skilled labor) and screwing together pre-made parts in final assembly (low skilled labor). If we really want manufacturing prowess and clout, we need to have jobs where skilled tradesmen make the components to supply the assembly plants, not just buy all the bits from the lowest bidder overseas and pay someone $15/hr to screw it together.

I am a big supporter of USA manufacturing, as I am myself a USA manufacturer. But I'm pretty certain DeWalt's claims, while legally true, are pretty much pure marketing **** designed to take advantage of patriotism and general flag waving/chest thumping.
 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
Makita has factories around the world, including one in Buford, Georgia.

You keep making this claim despite being called out multiple times. Why is that?
Called out?
What cordless power tool(s) does Makita make in the USA.
What cordless power tool(s) aside from a vacuum does Milwaukee make in the USA?

Trust me when I tell I wish all three made everything here but that's not that case.

If you know of any cordless tools made in the USA aside from what I mentioned please post them up.

I've yet to find anything. People like pointing to "brand x" just built a million square foot facility in Timbuktu, USA.
Ok...and they're making what there?

Accessories? Milwaukee makes some accessories here. Not sure about Makita's accessories.

Actual cordless tools made in USA..... please let me know.
 

Rabid Badger

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 2, 2018
Messages
1,338
Called out?
What cordless power tool(s) does Makita make in the USA.

Yeah, called out. And you're trying to weasel out of your BS the same way you always do.

This is the statement you made:

Makita makes absolutely everything in Asia. 100 percent of their tools are Asian made.

That is false. You know it. You keep saying it.

Who cares if they only make industrial-grade corded grinders at the Buford facility? That's what they built the factory for.

Are they employing Americans? Yes.

Are they doing actual manufacturing rather than assembly? Yes.
 
OP
D

Davefr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2010
Messages
11,822
Location
OR
Thanks fellas!! Appreciate the advice. It's "analysis/paralysis" but I'm going to order the Makita.
- With Makita the battery platform might be useful for future power tools. (vs. Stihl, Echo, Ego etc)
- Makita really looks well built under the chain brake cover. (metal vs plastic). It should because they are also a real chainsaw company.
- Makita has the best safety switch. Dewalt's is horribly placed.
- Makita has among the highest chain speed and a respectable cutting speed. High chain speed is good for smaller wood, pruning, storm cleanup, etc. I don't care to win a cutting race. I still have my gas saws for the big stuff.
- Milwaukie has their head up there *** with pricing and much slower chain speed. (probably better torque for bigger wood). Milwaukies saw is almost $150 higher with battery and charger.
- Makita's tools have never let me down.
 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
Makita has factories around the world, including one in Buford, Georgia.

You keep making this claim despite being called out multiple times. Why is that?
Called out?
What cordless power tool(s) does Makita make in the USA.
What cordless power tool(s) aside from a vacuum does Milwaukee make in the USA?

Trust me when I tell you I wish all three made everything here but that's not that case.

If you know of any cordless tools mfg in the USA from Makita and Milwaukee (aside from what I mentioned) please post them up.
 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
Yeah, called out. And you're trying to weasel out of your BS the same way you always do.

This is the statement you made:



That is false. You know it. You keep saying it.

Who cares if they only make industrial-grade corded grinders at the Buford facility? That's what they built the factory for.

Are they employing Americans? Yes.

Are they doing actual manufacturing rather than assembly? Yes.
I specifically saud cordless tools. If you look at any post on the USA subject I try to mention cordless tools. Why? It's a cordless world.

Now if it upsets you nobody makes anything cordless in USA aside from some of DeWalt's offerings and a Milwaukee vacuum...
It bothers me as well.

I say again...you keep stating it's not true so please post up any cordless USA made tools outside of what I've mentioned.

I welcome the info!!
 

KnurledNut

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
8,108
Location
n/a
I have a Dewalt 20v chainsaw with a 12" blade. I would characterIze it as a light duty limbing saw. I live in a development. Lots aren't that big. The saw gets used mostly for cleaning up any dead limbs that fall from trees, yard clean up, overgrowth control, limbing as needed and occasionally for cutting up construction materials. This saw is plenty of saw for my needs. If I had different needs I might have a different saw.
:beer:
I was hoping this would get a mention here, but refrained since it didnt fit the OPs needs.
Type 2 of the DCCS620 fixed some of the common problems that plagued the initial release.
With the 14” Oregon upgrade and Flexvolt batteries, this is a great little saw!
The top handle design allows for single-handed use, working at height, etc.
Its not as fast as the bigger saws, but cuts fine and is not fatiguing for all day use.
 

subroc

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
781
Location
Dover, NH
:beer:
I was hoping this would get a mention here, but refrained since it didnt fit the OPs needs.
Type 2 of the DCCS620 fixed some of the common problems that plagued the initial release.
With the 14” Oregon upgrade and Flexvolt batteries, this is a great little saw!
The top handle design allows for single-handed use, working at height, etc.
Its not as fast as the bigger saws, but cuts fine and is not fatiguing for all day use.

What were the changes between type 1 and type 2? Mine is a type 1. Anyway, there is always something bigger and better available. After I made the above post I watched a couple YouTube's on this saw just to see if others had the same or a similar opinion of the saw. One had a 14" Oregon bar upgrade. I doubt I have a need to make the change but see the utility of it and for not a whole lot of money.
 

KnurledNut

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
8,108
Location
n/a
What were the changes between type 1 and type 2? Mine is a type 1. Anyway, there is always something bigger and better available. After I made the above post I watched a couple YouTube's on this saw just to see if others had the same or a similar opinion of the saw. One had a 14" Oregon bar upgrade. I doubt I have a need to make the change but see the utility of it and for not a whole lot of money.
The revision fixed a lot of the legit issues people complained about on Amazon.
I had a Type 1 as well. The switches could permanently fail, as mine did, rendering the tool an expensive paperweight. Sometimes they would cut out when the tool was hot, and start working again after cooling down.
The initial tool-less bar clamp design was changed.
And IIRC something with the bar oil cap.
I talked with a Dewalt tech about some of the changes, but thats been some time ago.
Im a Makita guy, but Dewalt does seem to make upgrades to tools when needed.

The extra length of the 14” bar makes a big difference IMO, and i would recommend it.
 

Xcursion88

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
785
Everyone here can read and knows what you said.
If I didn't put "cordless" behind every power tool statement forgive me because at some point in that paragraph I would've stated the word cordless and if you don't know that's what I meant you're simply arguing and trying to pick some one sided fight.

That said you still haven't shown any USA made CORDLESS power tools by Makita or Milwaukee (other than the vacuum I stated)

Echoing again I welcome the information and wish the list was a country mile long.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom