First post here and please excuse me if I have breached protocol here by resurrecting a 4 month old thread.
My preference is to buy American made hand tools. I was in the military signing my life away in 1976 and finally retiring from the US Army Reserves in 1998. Over the years, I accumulated tools here and there, mostly based on need and what I would afford. There was a day when the pickings were pretty good for "Made in the USA", but that has changed.
Knowing that the Chinese military controls just about every "private" company in China, and the ethical standards of the Chinese that seem to require taking a good recipe and then changing the ingredients where cheaper and corner cutting rules the day in the name of quantity versus quality, I try like hell to stay away fron Chinese product.
These days, I look for US made for other reasons. The economy is so far in the crapper, that anything that keeps jobs here is a good thing. Once a job goes overseas, it is not coming back (if companies want to bring the overseas income back into the US, they are taxed to hell on it, plus, some countries, like India, actually prohibit you from taking earnings out of the country). That is strong incentive for companies to keep that money offshore, and invest the earnings there versus here.
And truth be told, if foreign companies had to follow all of our labor, enviromental and business laws, the product they produced would likely be unaffordable by the time it reached here. That was the original concept behind tarriffs on imports, but we cannot begin to utter the "T" word in this "global economy"
I served this country to protect it, not to make it easy for some shithole country to grow their economy and turn the tables on us.
So I buy American whenever I can.
I came to this site recently and found that a member here had run into the same issue that led to my search - looking for a 3/8 socket repair kit on a Cornwell ratchet. The ratchet in question was used, unforutunately, by another (one day I will learn not to lend tools out), and by the time I got it the works were so shot to **** that they were useless. Not Cornwell's fault, and I could not honestly say it was not abused (because I think it was). So I figure just get a replacement kit and I would do it myself.
And my experience is pretty much the same as the one laid out here:
http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=83729&highlight=cornwell+ratchet+repair+kit
I am not going to send the thing back, since I do not think it would be entirely honset to receive a "free" replacement out of one that was trashed.
Now I fully understand the whole dealer protection thing. Where a company protects its dealers by agreeing not to compete with them for sales. But on a repair part?
Which brings me full circle to the Buy American mentality. I want to buy goods made here. Hell, I'll even save them the money and trouble by fixing the thing on my own, and buying the parts to do it.
But you can't. One of the big inducements to buy American is the thought, real or imagined, that you are getting a better product. And the fact that most of the US companies support that with lifetime warranties says a lot. If that lifetime warranty starts being watered down with exceptions and conditions, the value just isn't there. And it does not do wonders for the resale value of these items either. I imagine some people buy US made with the thought that if they ever have to sell it, they will not take a bath.
So, here is what I don't understand: Why would any company in the US today discourage people from buying their US product made by US workers, forcing people to have no option but to support economies like that of China? I mean, come on - I own a Ford F250 Diesel, and while I have to buy the truck from a dealer, I can get Ford spare parts just abut anywhere. I do not have to take it to a dealer to get repaired - I can actually do it myself.
And speaking of the auto industry, there was a time when Asian product was mocked as inferior to American made. Now days, the tables have turned. Car buyers now look at "quality" as a standard set overseas, with American manufacturers struggling to reclaim that throne. Good luck.
I was always a buy American guy without question when it came to hand tools, but when I get no love from the US companies versus a promise from an Asian competitor who will love me long time in meeting my "needs", well...a man needs his lovin.
Sorry for the lengthy post. It is just sad to see business that could remain here and continue to employ people here in the US forced overseas forever by some very shortsighted BS - for the want of a nail, the shoe was lost; for the want of the shoe, the horse was lost; for the want of a horse, the battle was lost; and for the want of a battle, the war was lost.
Jim