To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Are Fluke Multimeters Worth The Substantial Extra Money?

oni888

Active member
Joined
Oct 5, 2022
Messages
25
Location
ravenna OH
I still miss my Simpson 260. I lost it in the mid ‘80s.
i left one on the rear bumper of my service truck. was in a slow speed zone in town and heard something fall. looked in mirror and saw it in the road. pulled over, started to run to get it, car comes along, wont wait for me and hits it dead center. leather case and everything busted all to hell. left it in the street.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

AJHD

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 4, 2020
Messages
3,037
Location
AZ
At least in my experience analog multimeters are still useful to adjust rapidly changing voltage readings that may be fluctuating as you're making an adjustment. Even the best digital VOMs have issue with the bar graph responding. Railroad instrumentation guys still use them for that purpose.

An oscilloscope is the best tool IMO for those sorts of adjustments.

Why would you use the bar graph when you have a digital display (digits)? I usually don't even notice the graph, it's small and usually under the digits out of your focus.

Some meters have better response times than others (faster update). I don't know if that effects the graph. You also need a good set of leads.

I think it's interesting there are jobs/professions that still exist where an analog meter or an almost "analog way" of using a digital meter offer some advantage. I can't say it's something I've encountered in the automotive or equipment world.
 

BrandonV

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2023
Messages
4,030
Location
Arizona
Why would you use the bar graph when you have a digital display (digits)? I usually don't even notice the graph, it's small and usually under the digits out of your focus.

Some meters have better response times than others (faster update). I don't know if that effects the graph. You also need a good set of leads.

I think it's interesting there are jobs/professions that still exist where an analog meter or an almost "analog way" of using a digital meter offer some advantage. I can't say it's something I've encountered in the automotive or equipment world.

Dave Jones probably explains it better than I can. The comments have a lot of people talking about why they prefer the needle movement versus the bar graph.

 

ronkz650

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
221
Location
Denver, CO
Back in 1979 we had the Simpson and B&K analog meters at work, as at the time of course there were no other options. They work, but hook up accidentally to voltage while in ohm range, fry time, drop one time= good luck, probably damaged. We got the Flukes in 1981 I believe, and for all intents and purposes the use of old meters was over. Yea, sometimes you can use an old analog meter though with better results. I still used one up to 2013 when I gave up working for some applications, but not many. Fragile, not overly accurate. Fluke meters I have had, and still have many, most are nearly indestructible for the most part, even if used 12hrs a day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jr5

BrandonV

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2023
Messages
4,030
Location
Arizona
He has his own brand of multimeter?

It's just a rebranded Brymen BM235. Brymen makes some solid budget meters and because of the value he is proud to stand behind them.

Brymen rebrands their meters for Matco & Greenlee as well.
 

Citation

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2016
Messages
3,221
Location
Indy
It's just a rebranded Brymen BM235. Brymen makes some solid budget meters and because of the value he is proud to stand behind them.

Brymen rebrands their meters for Matco & Greenlee as well.
He has at least two meters. The smaller meter is based on the same family as the Bryman BM257 but I think it was originally a configuration that was unique to Jones. Since then I think that configuration was then sold as the BM235. The large meter I believe was a custom design by Jones (not based on an existing meter family). I think it is also mfrs by Bryman.
 

bradthefixer

Active member
Joined
Nov 2, 2022
Messages
29
We don't have the Ford Edge in the UK unfortunately.

Does this car have a keyless entry system?

Are you 100% sure it's the speakers popping?
Sorry for the delay. Has a keyed door lock and a fob for lock/unlock, also no remote start. Keyless entry? Are you referring to the touch pad on the outside driver door? No touch pads on this car. I'm 99 percent certain I heard pop/crack from a speaker though not loud enough to know which speaker. But I'm 100 percent certain I heard something. I The think the Edge is very nice sturdy suv. I have two of them, one 2012 with a drain and one 2009 without. Thanks very much for the reply.
 

spanimal

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
52
I went through a phase not too long ago to find the perfect multimeter for mobile mechanic professional use.

Bought a load of used Flukes, some Brymens and a couple others.

My conclusion?

For professional use in view of customer, there is only Fluke and nothing else. I simply sold more work with the Fluke 287s graphing display and made more money. Plain and simple. Loads of tradies recognise the brand and even loads of office workers seem to have IT backgrounds in certain parts of Western Sydney. All will recognise the Fluke as something only an absolute professional would invest in.

The 287 was fast enough to graph multiple significant events a second when a car battery is dead and flicking the dash lights on several times a second...the squiggly lines shown to a customer works miles better than a battery test report. It just sells the image of a modern technician over a bush mechanic in repairing an electronics heavy modern vehicle.

Me personally...the 287s low contrast display irks me to no end. I personally fell for the 87V...just the right size to separate itself from all the cheapies without going oversized like the 287 was. The Fluke 28II was awesome for a piece of mind in stormy weather but a bit too big to work out of the fluke soft case same applies to the 287.

Which reminds me. I need to work out of the soft case to keep the meter spotless in view of the customer so they know that I baby this expensive Fluke thingy...like I will baby their expensive Car thingy.

If I can find a larger Fluke branded case I may substitute the Fluke 87v with the 28ii for it's better durability. Otherwise on a stormy day I revert back to my Uni T 210E...it's the one meter I will always have at hand.

Speed is the most important thing when time is money and Flukes are fast - we need the speed to trust our meter when deep in diagnostics - you ask a question and it replies immediately with an answer, no one has time for a pause to think about it.

Brymens are ****** fast too. The Brymen 867 I used was confidence inspiring fast also, however there was nothing it could offer me more than the Flukes. The size was imposing and good for customer presence, but the value adding brand recognition is absent. That 500,000 count on the Big Brymen is of exactly zero use in my profession. And why is it so ****** big? If it had IP67 then I would understand why it needed to be huge. Or if it graphed like the 287...

I also had the smaller 257 Brymen - that's the Brymen I would recommend. The size was so welcome...compact and seemed to do everything the Fluke 179 did...but was smaller and, well, cuter...more adorable. I really liked that one...now if they put Auto Hold on that and a Fluke badge on it...well it'd be amazing.

The Brymen 257 had a useable bar graph, which to me is a must have, so all the meters I selected had a very good bar graph...but why are Flukes the only ones it seems with Auto Hold? When doing measurements and sometimes I need to take photographic evidence, it's impossible without Auto Hold. Min Max just will not do as I can't go to a lower voltage than max value and hold that with Min Max.

So I had a lot of meters but there was something missing that I wanted...to see the measurements as I sat in the driver's seat to toggle ignition and instruments. Enter the EEVBlog 121GW. Now that is a wonderful meter.

You see, something always bugged me about Brymens. The 121GW made me recognise what it was. It was the rubbish cheap plastic input jacks on all the Brymens. They look and feel cheap, end of story. The 121GW jacks looks nice and shiny, same as my 87V...a look and feel of quality. The knob is nice and big and feels nice to select, just like the Fluke. All the Brymens selector knobs are too stiff and tiny...and feels less luxurious...or more cheap.

The Brymens remind me of Gearwrench...overhyped on the internet yet for its price, they can feel cheap.

So the TLDR of it is as follows;

A professional should have a Fluke and a Uni T 210E. A Fluke because you should let your customers know that you spared no expense in the pursuit for perfection... Average Joe knows what Fluke represents. Average Joe knows it's expensive....just like Snap On. Average Joe thinks you're very successful and suspects it's because you are good at what you do.

A hobbyist who has time to enjoy the process of hobbying around should buy the EEVBLOG 121GW - the internet has no idea sometimes, and has done this awesome little meter Injustice. It does ****** everything accurately and feels like a quality unit. It's the true hobbyist meter - I can't recommend it enough. It will do everything in a pinch including data logging and remote work capability. 50,000 count and Auto Hold...not as fast in the Auto Hold as Fluke, but it has it and it works. It's compact and cute and adorable also.

What about the UNI T? Well what about it?That Uni T 210E ... Well... it's the GOAT obviously. Doesn't everyone already have one?
 

CoogarXR

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
6,860
Location
Ohio
I went through a phase not too long ago to find the perfect multimeter for mobile mechanic professional use.

Bought a load of used Flukes, some Brymens and a couple others.

My conclusion?

For professional use in view of customer, there is only Fluke and nothing else. I simply sold more work with the Fluke 287s graphing display and made more money. Plain and simple. Loads of tradies recognise the brand and even loads of office workers seem to have IT backgrounds in certain parts of Western Sydney. All will recognise the Fluke as something only an absolute professional would invest in.

The 287 was fast enough to graph multiple significant events a second when a car battery is dead and flicking the dash lights on several times a second...the squiggly lines shown to a customer works miles better than a battery test report. It just sells the image of a modern technician over a bush mechanic in repairing an electronics heavy modern vehicle.

Me personally...the 287s low contrast display irks me to no end. I personally fell for the 87V...just the right size to separate itself from all the cheapies without going oversized like the 287 was. The Fluke 28II was awesome for a piece of mind in stormy weather but a bit too big to work out of the fluke soft case same applies to the 287.

Which reminds me. I need to work out of the soft case to keep the meter spotless in view of the customer so they know that I baby this expensive Fluke thingy...like I will baby their expensive Car thingy.

If I can find a larger Fluke branded case I may substitute the Fluke 87v with the 28ii for it's better durability. Otherwise on a stormy day I revert back to my Uni T 210E...it's the one meter I will always have at hand.

Speed is the most important thing when time is money and Flukes are fast - we need the speed to trust our meter when deep in diagnostics - you ask a question and it replies immediately with an answer, no one has time for a pause to think about it.

Brymens are ****** fast too. The Brymen 867 I used was confidence inspiring fast also, however there was nothing it could offer me more than the Flukes. The size was imposing and good for customer presence, but the value adding brand recognition is absent. That 500,000 count on the Big Brymen is of exactly zero use in my profession. And why is it so ****** big? If it had IP67 then I would understand why it needed to be huge. Or if it graphed like the 287...

I also had the smaller 257 Brymen - that's the Brymen I would recommend. The size was so welcome...compact and seemed to do everything the Fluke 179 did...but was smaller and, well, cuter...more adorable. I really liked that one...now if they put Auto Hold on that and a Fluke badge on it...well it'd be amazing.

The Brymen 257 had a useable bar graph, which to me is a must have, so all the meters I selected had a very good bar graph...but why are Flukes the only ones it seems with Auto Hold? When doing measurements and sometimes I need to take photographic evidence, it's impossible without Auto Hold. Min Max just will not do as I can't go to a lower voltage than max value and hold that with Min Max.

So I had a lot of meters but there was something missing that I wanted...to see the measurements as I sat in the driver's seat to toggle ignition and instruments. Enter the EEVBlog 121GW. Now that is a wonderful meter.

You see, something always bugged me about Brymens. The 121GW made me recognise what it was. It was the rubbish cheap plastic input jacks on all the Brymens. They look and feel cheap, end of story. The 121GW jacks looks nice and shiny, same as my 87V...a look and feel of quality. The knob is nice and big and feels nice to select, just like the Fluke. All the Brymens selector knobs are too stiff and tiny...and feels less luxurious...or more cheap.

The Brymens remind me of Gearwrench...overhyped on the internet yet for its price, they can feel cheap.

So the TLDR of it is as follows;

A professional should have a Fluke and a Uni T 210E. A Fluke because you should let your customers know that you spared no expense in the pursuit for perfection... Average Joe knows what Fluke represents. Average Joe knows it's expensive....just like Snap On. Average Joe thinks you're very successful and suspects it's because you are good at what you do.

A hobbyist who has time to enjoy the process of hobbying around should buy the EEVBLOG 121GW - the internet has no idea sometimes, and has done this awesome little meter Injustice. It does ****** everything accurately and feels like a quality unit. It's the true hobbyist meter - I can't recommend it enough. It will do everything in a pinch including data logging and remote work capability. 50,000 count and Auto Hold...not as fast in the Auto Hold as Fluke, but it has it and it works. It's compact and cute and adorable also.

What about the UNI T? Well what about it?That Uni T 210E ... Well... it's the GOAT obviously. Doesn't everyone already have one?
This guy 'meters, lol. Nice review.
 

SteadyC

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
475
Location
CA
Fluke used to be worth the extra cost. Now, they're just as Chinese as the junk brands.

I bought a Mac-branded Fluke 88 (not 88V) in the middle-1990s. I think I paid $375 for it. I eventually had to replace the leads, so add another $30-ish. Add one hatefully-expensive fuse, some batteries, sales tax... Maybe I've got $500 in the thing altogether.

I've had it 29 years. I've paid $17.25 (probably less) per year of ownership.

About every five or seven years, I have to pull the display out, and run a pencil eraser over the contacts to get all the segments of the display to work at full darkness.

Fluke_88.jpg



Fluke_88_display.jpg
Have the same one. bought new as well.
 

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,817
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
Sorry for the delay. Has a keyed door lock and a fob for lock/unlock, also no remote start. Keyless entry? Are you referring to the touch pad on the outside driver door? No touch pads on this car. I'm 99 percent certain I heard pop/crack from a speaker though not loud enough to know which speaker. But I'm 100 percent certain I heard something. I The think the Edge is very nice sturdy suv. I have two of them, one 2012 with a drain and one 2009 without. Thanks very much for the reply.
I would hook up a breakout box to the OBD socket and wait to see if any communication network activity coincides with the drain, on Fords generally you should have a stable draw of below 35 milliamps when the car is asleep and very little volt drop (if any) across the fuses.

We do have issues with Ford BCMs over here, screen wash wicks up the wires from faulty washer pumps and damages the BCMs

Faulty door handles on "keyless entry" systems can wake up the BCM intermittently

PCM/TCMs flooded with rain water can also cause issues (they put them in dumb positions like wheel arches).
 

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,817
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
I went through a phase not too long ago to find the perfect multimeter for mobile mechanic professional use.

Bought a load of used Flukes, some Brymens and a couple others.

My conclusion?

For professional use in view of customer, there is only Fluke and nothing else. I simply sold more work with the Fluke 287s graphing display and made more money. Plain and simple. Loads of tradies recognise the brand and even loads of office workers seem to have IT backgrounds in certain parts of Western Sydney. All will recognise the Fluke as something only an absolute professional would invest in.

The 287 was fast enough to graph multiple significant events a second when a car battery is dead and flicking the dash lights on several times a second...the squiggly lines shown to a customer works miles better than a battery test report. It just sells the image of a modern technician over a bush mechanic in repairing an electronics heavy modern vehicle.

Me personally...the 287s low contrast display irks me to no end. I personally fell for the 87V...just the right size to separate itself from all the cheapies without going oversized like the 287 was. The Fluke 28II was awesome for a piece of mind in stormy weather but a bit too big to work out of the fluke soft case same applies to the 287.

Which reminds me. I need to work out of the soft case to keep the meter spotless in view of the customer so they know that I baby this expensive Fluke thingy...like I will baby their expensive Car thingy.

If I can find a larger Fluke branded case I may substitute the Fluke 87v with the 28ii for it's better durability. Otherwise on a stormy day I revert back to my Uni T 210E...it's the one meter I will always have at hand.

Speed is the most important thing when time is money and Flukes are fast - we need the speed to trust our meter when deep in diagnostics - you ask a question and it replies immediately with an answer, no one has time for a pause to think about it.

Brymens are ****** fast too. The Brymen 867 I used was confidence inspiring fast also, however there was nothing it could offer me more than the Flukes. The size was imposing and good for customer presence, but the value adding brand recognition is absent. That 500,000 count on the Big Brymen is of exactly zero use in my profession. And why is it so ****** big? If it had IP67 then I would understand why it needed to be huge. Or if it graphed like the 287...

I also had the smaller 257 Brymen - that's the Brymen I would recommend. The size was so welcome...compact and seemed to do everything the Fluke 179 did...but was smaller and, well, cuter...more adorable. I really liked that one...now if they put Auto Hold on that and a Fluke badge on it...well it'd be amazing.

The Brymen 257 had a useable bar graph, which to me is a must have, so all the meters I selected had a very good bar graph...but why are Flukes the only ones it seems with Auto Hold? When doing measurements and sometimes I need to take photographic evidence, it's impossible without Auto Hold. Min Max just will not do as I can't go to a lower voltage than max value and hold that with Min Max.

So I had a lot of meters but there was something missing that I wanted...to see the measurements as I sat in the driver's seat to toggle ignition and instruments. Enter the EEVBlog 121GW. Now that is a wonderful meter.

You see, something always bugged me about Brymens. The 121GW made me recognise what it was. It was the rubbish cheap plastic input jacks on all the Brymens. They look and feel cheap, end of story. The 121GW jacks looks nice and shiny, same as my 87V...a look and feel of quality. The knob is nice and big and feels nice to select, just like the Fluke. All the Brymens selector knobs are too stiff and tiny...and feels less luxurious...or more cheap.

The Brymens remind me of Gearwrench...overhyped on the internet yet for its price, they can feel cheap.

So the TLDR of it is as follows;

A professional should have a Fluke and a Uni T 210E. A Fluke because you should let your customers know that you spared no expense in the pursuit for perfection... Average Joe knows what Fluke represents. Average Joe knows it's expensive....just like Snap On. Average Joe thinks you're very successful and suspects it's because you are good at what you do.

A hobbyist who has time to enjoy the process of hobbying around should buy the EEVBLOG 121GW - the internet has no idea sometimes, and has done this awesome little meter Injustice. It does ****** everything accurately and feels like a quality unit. It's the true hobbyist meter - I can't recommend it enough. It will do everything in a pinch including data logging and remote work capability. 50,000 count and Auto Hold...not as fast in the Auto Hold as Fluke, but it has it and it works. It's compact and cute and adorable also.

What about the UNI T? Well what about it?That Uni T 210E ... Well... it's the GOAT obviously. Doesn't everyone already have one?

As crazy as this post is.......... (my customers definitely don't care about multimeters)

I have come to a very similar conclusion, an old Fluke 112 and a Uni T 210e is what I carry in my van (I carry a scope too)
 

CS454

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 10, 2014
Messages
668
I'm just setting aside pennies for a Simpson 260 to compliment my 88v since I'm bougie like that

PicoScope would be nice too...next year
 

Chilliwack Murray

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2012
Messages
1,506
Location
Chilliwack BC
I don't think that's a factual statement.

We all have preferences, but I don't see how a decent 4 digit digital multimeter would "tell you less" than an analog meter does. By design, there is only so much an analog meter can show.

Care to elaborate or provide some examples?
'Less' is a poor choice of words, but a cheap anlogue meter will tell you things that would require an expensive digital scope meter otherwise.

The sweep of a large analogue meter needle will show stability issues you will never see on a digital, even with a high speed barbraph. By nature, even a cheap analogue will provide a true rms reading and distorted waveforms have very little impact on their accuracy. Most digital meters can provide wildly variable readings under these conditions.

There is however, no way to make an analogue, meter remotely as safe and idiot proof or as accurate in all environments as a high quality digital meter can be so the digital goes to work and my analogues live on my home workbench.
 

Dakotadadv8

Well-known member
Joined
May 30, 2021
Messages
1,489
Using Klein MM from Home Depot $50 in 2015 that have worked fine for my DIYer projects. Time to upgrade to Fluke in 2024 from Lowes for $250 to $350 I believe you get what you pay for.
 

spanimal

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
52
As crazy as this post is.......... (my customers definitely don't care about multimeters)

I have come to a very similar conclusion, an old Fluke 112 and a Uni T 210e is what I carry in my van (I carry a scope too)

I wish to add a scope meter to my mobile setup also, I was looking at the Owon handheld scope but unsure which speed to get. I want to see the Can bits and PWM signals. Is 40mhz enough or just go all out for the 200mhz units...or stay away from these meters all together?

WRT customers....I don't think they care about multimeters per se, but I noticed a lot of tradesman customers take notice of the Fluke branded meters. Likewise demographics in certain areas in Sydney of Australia means that a lot of people have done IT, and they all know what a Fluke is.

Branding is important in sales, always has been.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

spanimal

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
52
I have a Fluke 87.3, a 114, and a Hioki pen DMM. Happy with all 3.
Nice. I scored a new 87.2 (a rare original 87 with a CAT rating) a few months ago. I want to get a mint 87.3 to round up the 87 collection...I am also on the lookout for a mint 88 original model. That particular series of meters works so well.

Although I can't say if they are worth it for a hobbyist.
 

BrandonV

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2023
Messages
4,030
Location
Arizona
As crazy as this post is.......... (my customers definitely don't care about multimeters)

I feel like its certain customer bases. So in industrial work when I call the elevator guy I'm a little freaked out when he's using the $20 budget meter from the big box store. Does the meter do the job? Sure.

Most people wouldn't care or notice.
 

AJHD

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 4, 2020
Messages
3,037
Location
AZ
'Less' is a poor choice of words, but a cheap anlogue meter will tell you things that would require an expensive digital scope meter otherwise.

The sweep of a large analogue meter needle will show stability issues you will never see on a digital, even with a high speed barbraph. By nature, even a cheap analogue will provide a true rms reading and distorted waveforms have very little impact on their accuracy. Most digital meters can provide wildly variable readings under these conditions.

There is however, no way to make an analogue, meter remotely as safe and idiot proof or as accurate in all environments as a high quality digital meter can be so the digital goes to work and my analogues live on my home workbench.

It's just honestly something over my head and beyond both my knowledge level and experience. Not sure I've ever owned or used an analog meter. Nor do I think I would ever do anything that would require one.

I will watch the Dave Jones videon when I get the chance. The EEVblog is the only electronics channel I still watch or subscribe to. Believe it or not many years ago I had an interest in electronics engineering and actually went to school for EE. But I only lasted one semester before literally switching course, and 99% of my electronics knowledge has faded beyond basic troubleshooting in an automotive/equipment environment.

On topic... I can't comment on accuracy or anything of that sort, but I've always used Fluke meters. I've owned several other meters and various test equipment, but my go to has been and is still my Fluke 115... Funny story, I found out during a machine electrical class at CAT my Fluke had a blown fuse on the amps circuit, no idea when or how that happened or how long it had been like that.

I also have a Fluke 101 as a quick pocket style meter. I've always wanted a Fluke 87V, but never wanted to spend the money on it. I'd rather buy an AC/DC clamp meter.
 

BrandonV

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 9, 2023
Messages
4,030
Location
Arizona
Another plus for Fluke I forgot to add is that I've rarely ever seen any meters come back from calibration adjusted. It seems like the Flukes keep their calibration more than other meters (which some don't even have calibration procedures available).
 

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,817
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
I wish to add a scope meter to my mobile setup also, I was looking at the Owon handheld scope but unsure which speed to get. I want to see the Can bits and PWM signals. Is 40mhz enough or just go all out for the 200mhz units...or stay away from these meters all together?

WRT customers....I don't think they care about multimeters per se, but I noticed a lot of tradesman customers take notice of the Fluke branded meters. Likewise demographics in certain areas in Sydney of Australia means that a lot of people have done IT, and they all know what a Fluke is.

Branding is important in sales, always has been.

Darren Quinn a British technical trainer has reviewed the Owon.

 

JD6619A

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Messages
255
Fluke 88-5 here came with the automotive kit. I'll eventually get a clamp meter, maybe the one with the head thats removeable but they are spendy. my 88-5 is 15 years old. No issues as of yet. I have had Snap on, blue point, mastercraft, greenlee, klein, some knock off brand from Rona (ideal maybe?). My Dad used to have those Swing needle type meters from Micronta, never liked them personally. I I had a go to for quality, reliability etc. Fluke. Their repeatability in performance speaks for itself.
 

threewood

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
419
Location
Yuma, AZ
Well, worth is a relative term. Expensive for what they are but the consensus is that they are a great multimeter. I can spend up for something I can rely on.

I recently bought a 116 as I was getting tired of going back and forth from the shop and garage with my 15 year old Uei, which I like and still works correctly.

20231206_170149.jpg

My trusted Uei...
20230701_133359.jpg
 

dchawk81

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
14,407
Retired IT Guy, have always used Fluke equipment in the IT world. Generally they were way more advanced and tougher than the competition, but the IT world is an always moving target, where state of the art today is throw away 8 years from now.

Im now looking to upgrade my 10 year old home digital multi-meter. I do general, automotive and appliance troubleshooting and repair. In my mind, this world has not / does not change much.

How do the below listed units compare in performance and reliability? Is the Fluke worth the 6-8 times the price over the others? If you have a better suggestion than these, what do you own or would buy today?

Fluke 116 or 117
or
Astro AI TRMS 6000
or
Kaiweets 6000
What's wrong with using the 10 year old one? 🤔
 

dchawk81

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
14,407
I've said it before, but if I'm being honest, I carry fluke equipment in my mobile bags not only because it's good stuff, but because it's kind of a status symbol. If you hire a guy to diagnose a half million dollar machine and he pulls out an orange harbor freight freebie meter, you would probably tell him to hit the road lol. So it garners a little respect in that regard.

But for around the house? Unless you are taking critical measurements, I would just get whatever is middle-of-the-road. While fluke meters are great, they are probably a little overkill for the home gamer. There are a million other "good" meters out there.
I hear this argument for a lot of tools but I'm not sure I can buy in.

If I hire someone to do something, it's probably because I don't know how to do it myself and therefore don't know enough to criticize his methods or his tools. Assuming I'm even there to see it.
 

CoogarXR

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
6,860
Location
Ohio
I hear this argument for a lot of tools but I'm not sure I can buy in.

If I hire someone to do something, it's probably because I don't know how to do it myself and therefore don't know enough to criticize his methods or his tools. Assuming I'm even there to see it.
I guess I should have set the scene a little better. I wasn't talking about home owners and residential work. I do support for IT and PLC/Automation. So I'm typically walking into a group of people who are stressed out, have an expensive problem, and paid an expensive person (me) to help.

In my world, when I get called into a job, it's because the existing crew is stuck. Either they are swamped with work and need backup, or they have a problem they can't figure out and call me. So everyone I whip my meter out in front of knows exactly what a Fluke meter is.
 

rooster59

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
965
Location
Land of the Pines
Some of the cheaper multimeters have gotten much better in the last 10 years. A Fluke will have higher quality test leads. If a reading of 120.4 volts or 122.3 volts is good enough, you don't need a Fluke. If you set up your meter to measure amps and hook it directly to your car battery (don't do this), your smoking lump of goo set you back $20, go buy another, lesson learned.
 

Gurp

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2014
Messages
366
Location
So.Ohio
I have both a amazon Ex-tech and a fluke at home.
honestly for everything home and hobby related they are both fine except testing capacitors in my furnace and A/C bnit. the fluke has a setting for microfarads as the Ex-Tech does not.

Other that that I prob grab the EX-Tech more often not at home due to its more comfortable in my hand. although this is a very subjective choice.

I I cant remember what the fluke costed me (used) but the Ex-Tech was right around 20bucks, Cheap enough my old lady ordered me a second one when one of my leads broke. Now I have one in my mobile bag.
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,667
Location
Fargo, ND
I used to sell Fluke, UEI and Fieldpiece. I never heard one complaint from a customer that bought a Fluke, other than the price. On the other hand I got the, "They are junk!" comment often about UEI and Fieldpiece.

I also worked on HVAC and bought nothing but Fluke. If fact I bought my first Fluke meter in the late 80's and when I cleaned out my dad's garage it was in his tools and still works. I have 3 or 4 Fluke meters in the shop right now. When I did HVAC service I bought a UEI and it lasted me about a year, never again. I replaced it with a Fluke.

Fluke may be a bit over kill for the homeowner that needs a meter to check power a couple times a year, but if it gets used fairly often, buy a Fluke.
 

Lassen Forge

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
15,311
Location
The romantic hills of central Umbria, Italy,
I still miss my Simpson 260. I lost it in the mid ‘80s.

i left one on the rear bumper of my service truck. was in a slow speed zone in town and heard something fall. looked in mirror and saw it in the road. pulled over, started to run to get it, car comes along, wont wait for me and hits it dead center. leather case and everything busted all to hell. left it in the street.

****, I did exactly that, except instead of having an azzole run it over I dropped it 4 stories onto concrete. Same result... except I was able to tape it together and somehow it still worked, shattered case and all. (But I did have that happen with my first gen iPad I had just set up for work... sonsabitch... )

I eventually found a 260 on fleabay for not too much soldi that worked fine... by then I had newer machines, but there are some things that Simpson was just good at.
 

cdods

Well-known member
Joined
May 7, 2009
Messages
159

tool_scrounge

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 20, 2010
Messages
4,206
Location
Southern California
if you hunt around you can still find quite serviceable Fluke meters for cheap. This one cost about $40 With leads and case. It was probably more of an excuse to go for a nice drive 😛image.jpg
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom