
The only Carlyle I own is a set of torx sockets. They are very well made and work perfectly. I also have a few random Napa wrenches that have treated me well. I feel that Napa is the only big box auto parts store left that sells all around good quality hand tools. Not to be confused with Joe's Auto Parts & Junk Yard down on route 80 in bumbville who still sells SK or Wright.
i love the look of the torx bits and they are pretty beefy
Are the Carlyle tools USA made or Tiawan?
Never seen this brand out here. Whats it close to quality and price wise?
They're comparable to GearWrench in quality and price.
I actually think the Carlyle tools are nicer and better quality than Gearwrench, but also a little more pricey. However, NAPA often has 10% discounts available that makes the Carlyle tools very attractive. Given the choice between Carlyle and Gearwrench, I'd go for Carlyle every time.
That says a lot.
I was looking to buy some Carlyle mid-length sockets this week, but they must have just about doubled in price since the were introduced. I just couldn't bring myself to pull the trigger...
That being said, I do like the Carlyle tools I do have...
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Thanks for the feed back guys. I use gearwrench ratchets daily and love them. I have never used one of their sockets or spanners, as there not everywhere here. You blokes from the states are lucky with your choice in hand tools.
NAPA here *****!
We do not have this brand in our canadian NAPA's
Are the Carlyle tools USA made or Taiwan?
NAPA here *****!
We do not have this brand in our canadian NAPA's
from two previous threads.
I emailed Napa a Canada recently to ask if there was any plans to bring the Carlyle line north.
Their response was that Carlyle was exclusive to the US and that the Ultra Pro line we get here in Canada is the same thing.
From what I have seen I do not believe this to be true.
Some of the filler is indeed the same, and the screw drivers look similar, but Ultra Pro does not have hex bolsters. But the hard line is not the same.
Why would napa not bring Carlyle to Canada? I think it would do well here.
After reading the other Napa thread, i'm still curious if anyone knows who makes the Ultrapro tools from Napa in Canada? I've bought a few of their sockets and they seem like great quality....and i've read others have had good experience with their tools. Napa in Canada do sell the Evercraft line of tools as well, but the Ultrapro seems like the higher end line they sell.....just no idea who makes em? anyone?
Don't really know, but I doubt they're from a single vendor, I'm pretty sure they rebrand different items from different manufacturers. I know their feeler gauges last time I saw them were marked KD Tools, but came in UltraPro packaging. Crosspein hammer I believe may have been Garant. Ratchets and sockets I'm really not sure, the ratchets just don't quite look like or have the same tooth counts as most of the other manufacturers that seem to do a lot of the private branding.
I'm more curious about the sockets, ratchets, wrenches....that kind of stuff. I'll snap a pic of a few of the sockets i got, maybe someone can ID them as another rebrand. Just pulled out their torque wrench we have here at work, and on the case it says Imported for UAP Inc.....on the wrench itself its made by Norbar.
I emailed them.....i'll post up if i get a reply.
After sending a few emails, then joining their FB site and posting on there to get their attention, i finally received a reply. Not the answers i wanted, but a reply is better than nothing i guess after all the questions i sent.
Anyways, in short, they won't and can't share details regarding the manufacturing of their professional hand tool line.
If anyone else has any info on where they're made, or by who, please post up. Thanks.
Are the Carlyle tools USA made or Tiawan?

I was looking to buy some Carlyle mid-length sockets this week, but they must have just about doubled in price since the were introduced. I just couldn't bring myself to pull the trigger
The mid length 3/8 sockets are in the second quarters real deal flyers. I believe they were under 40 per set of metric and sae each.
Huh. I was checking the price online and they were about $3-5 off. Too rich for what are going to be sorta duplicating my Snappy 12 point middies.
Our local NAPA don't carry most of the Carlyle in stock and even the main distribution warehouse don't have them so it has to be special order, paid upfront and wait 3-4 weeks. I avoid NAPA and go straight to Snap On online or get SO off Ebay. And the NAPA managers wonder why the local residents don't bother buying Carlyle.
BK13,
Here is the link to NAPA's 2nd quarter Real Deals catalog page with the Carlyle 3/8" drive mid-length socket sets (go to page 22): LINK . The metric set is $43.99. That's not a bad price at a little over $3 a socket.
Dave
Apparently, I have a bit of a 'thing' for mid-length/semi-deep sockets... when I found out Carlyle was introducing some, it was inevitable that I was going to pick some up...
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Carlyle 3/8" MM
SO 3/8" MM
SO 3/8" SAE
Sunex 3/8" SAE
SO 1/4" MM
![]()
Snap On/Carlyle... the NAPA stuff is just a little longer...
[![]()
![]()
![]()
Same here. I have tried to buy a few things of need and wanted to try Carlyle. Ended up buying elsewhere because Napa here doesn't really support Carlyle whatsoever
Have you tried different NAPA stores in the Cleveland area? It seems that not all NAPA stores are created equal as some seem to be corporate stores and others tend to be more like private stores. I've never been able to get a good handle on why that are not all the same.
Anyway, my local NAPA in SE Ohio (small town) carries a pretty full line of Carlyle tools behind the counter and if they don't have a particular tool in stock they can have it by the next morning. Same deal for the small-town NAPA that I deal with in Virginia .... they carry a reasonable stock of Carlyle in the store and can get other tools by the next day.
The Carlyle sockets that I've bought have all been quite nice.
I experienced this when their zero offset boxed wrenches, small crimper/stripper, and comfort grip breaker bars were first advertised. To be fair though, I've seen a number of tool truck flyers over the years has stuff on sale that the dealer didn't have.