Get both!!! Some days you might like the feel of chrome and other days you might like the feel of plastic/rubber.
I like comfort grips and some hard handles. I do feel though that no one brand does it right though. Some are just too big and bulky. The Snap on shape is great but, the rubber stays dirty when it gets dirty and is a little on the fragile side, tearing easily. Matco has a nice grip but, i feel it's too big in 1/2 drive but, that's just me.
If a tool truck brand was smart, they would take the Mac red rectangular screwdriver handle material (the stuff with a little grain to it so it doesn't slip when covered in ATF) and make in the shape of the current snap on comfort grip handle. I think then we would have a winner.
