To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Electrical grid question

930dreamer

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
22,928
Location
Amarillo,TX and Stinnett,TX
Don't make this political please.
Because of the major Texas wildfire my shop Utility provider now disconnects power during high wind/fire danger. So this weekend no power. Time to move or is a diesel generator in my future?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

larry4406

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
18,975
Location
Northern Virginia
How far would you have to move to get to a different provider?

Isn't Texas almost their own grid?

I think I would be going the generator route assuming you like your shop and location.
 

mike93lx

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
37,362
Location
Richmond, VA
What do you need power in a fire event? That will dictate the approach?

Well for fire control? Beer fridge?
 

Walkers

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2021
Messages
3,912
Location
Cave Creek Az
Don't make this political please.
Because of the major Texas wildfire my shop Utility provider now disconnects power during high wind/fire danger. So this weekend no power. Time to move or is a diesel generator in my future?
Sounds like a good generator and a transfer switch are in your future! If you move, don’t move to California.
 

MBfreak

MEMBER EMERITUS
Joined
Dec 10, 2010
Messages
2,301
Location
Linkoping , Sweden
Sorry for the lambasting.
Most US utilities are underfinanced, not properly regulated and use ancient switchgear and protection systems.
The medium voltage ( 4-72 kV) polebased bare conductor distribution nets are totally dangerous.
Ola
 
Last edited:

Leaflessshadetree

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
7,144
Location
Don't ask.
How much power do you need (want) during these events? How often do they occur?
Generator choices start at around $1000 (with everything needed for minimal needs in a small house).
 
OP
9

930dreamer

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
22,928
Location
Amarillo,TX and Stinnett,TX
Why not LP or NG a powered generator instead of diesel? Fuel stays good in storage (LP) or you’re hooked to the NG line (if available).
No LP or NG without adding a tank. I have a handful of three phase machines that I run through a phase converter. Seems this is starting to be three steps forward and two back. I do have a 60k vintage Cummins project generator that probably isn't cost effective to fix. The shop is the only priority.
 
Last edited:

PelicanPines

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
38,104
Location
New Jersey, USA, Earth, My own reality
I live on the Jersey Shore... when we have a hurricane "coming"... they shut our power down prior to the storm taking place. I went the generator route. I got a small one... to only power what I need at a moment in time. In hind sight... I wish I went whole home power with a transfer switch. I muddle thru... with my little Honda.

You need to decide... do i need to run the 3 phase stuff... or just keep my beer cold.
 

JeepYJ

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 25, 2015
Messages
8,897
No LP or NG without adding a tank.
Something to think about when adding a backup generator is having its own dedicated fuel supply and how much fuel you’d need to have on hand in the event of an emergency. Running a generator from a bull storage tank that you use for other equipment may be work just fine, unless your tank is low and you need the generator. Say you have a 1,000 gallon tank and it’s down to 200 gallons when the power goes out. Do you have enough fuel on hand to meet all your needs for the expected time you’ll be out of power?
Setting up a 250 or 500 gallon LP tank exclusively for the generator would give you plenty of fuel to run for a long time with no worries. When the power comes back on call to have the tank topped off again and you’re all set for the next event.
 
OP
9

930dreamer

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
22,928
Location
Amarillo,TX and Stinnett,TX
This is kind of an odd situation, in that this is an hour away from our main residence. So the priority is nil if I not there. If I'm out there regardless of the weather I want power.
 

mike93lx

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
37,362
Location
Richmond, VA
This is kind of an odd situation, in that this is an hour away from our main residence. So the priority is nil if I not there. If I'm out there regardless of the weather I want power.
If there is a fire warning and high winds, is that the right place to be?

Again, how much power do you need? Can you make due with a solar panel portable battery pack?
 

PelicanPines

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
38,104
Location
New Jersey, USA, Earth, My own reality
If there is a fire warning and high winds, is that the right place to be?

Again, how much power do you need? Can you make due with a solar panel portable battery pack?
I did this as well ... I have enough battery to power my medical equipment and my WIFI for days without the sun. I have 2 x solar panels (still in their box)... and that small generator to charge the battery too.

I am saying all this "Small Stuff" because if you are dismissing what I am doing without thought... you need to go massive D Generator and not look back. To be honest... I would go with propane with a dedicated tank. But that's me.

One side note ... I know you don't have it... but I have NG. but AGAIN during a storm... it's a possibility for them to SHUT down the NG here. They did during Sandy in a small area of the town.
 

dave*99

Well-known member
Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
4,247
Location
Coastal NJ
I live on the Jersey Shore... when we have a hurricane "coming"... they shut our power down prior to the storm taking place. I went the generator route. I got a small one... to only power what I need at a moment in time. In hind sight... I wish I went whole home power with a transfer switch. I muddle thru... with my little Honda.

You need to decide... do i need to run the 3 phase stuff... or just keep my beer cold.
When did this start? I had power all through hurricane Sandy despite 30" of water on the ground and a flooded house. I have not had any shutdowns at all. How many shutdowns have you had? My poco is ACE.
 

PelicanPines

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
38,104
Location
New Jersey, USA, Earth, My own reality
When did this start? I had power all through hurricane Sandy despite 30" of water on the ground and a flooded house. I have not had any shutdowns at all. How many shutdowns have you had? My poco is ACE.
I am right on the bay side near the water. During Sandy... the power went out Sunday Afternoon before the storm hit. Not for any "outage"... it was SHUT OFF to prevent problems with downed wires. Thankfully... I live above the flood zone but for a short time... during Sandy... I was "water front". We didn't get power back for 6 days which is fast considering only 3 houses were "down" here after they turned the power back on. It pays living next to a Town VIP... A tree took out a transformer that tripped the next 3 telephone poles down the line. We each have our own telephone pole transformer here. If one trips... it sets off all of the transformers down stream... until the one that tripped is reset.

Thousands here were without power for weeks during Sandy,

We are ACE too... We had our power shut off twice. Once during Sandy and once during that 20,000 acre fire started by the flare the fighter jet dropped. Mind you... we were a direct hit for Sandy... it hit us with a 10 foot surge on top of high tide at the time.
 

dave*99

Well-known member
Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
4,247
Location
Coastal NJ
I am right on the bay side near the water. During Sandy... the power went out Sunday Afternoon before the storm hit. Not for any "outage"... it was SHUT OFF to prevent problems with downed wires. Thankfully... I live above the flood zone but for a short time... during Sandy... I was "water front". We didn't get power back for 6 days which is fast considering only 3 houses were "down" here after they turned the power back on. It pays living next to a Town VIP... A tree took out a transformer that tripped the next 3 telephone poles down the line. We each have our own telephone pole transformer here. If one trips... it sets off all of the transformers down stream... until the one that tripped is reset.

Thousands here were without power for weeks during Sandy,

We are ACE too... We had our power shut off twice. Once during Sandy and once during that 20,000 acre fire started by the flare the fighter jet dropped. Mind you... we were a direct hit for Sandy... it hit us with a 10 foot surge on top of high tide at the time.
I'm on the bay. If they had shut off our power, all the wire nuts in all the JB's in my crawl space would not have burned off.....
Many were without power but all due to storm damage. Not an intentional shut down.
They (NJNG) did shut off our Natural Gas for 2 weeks. They sawed off your pipe entering your house and left it to you to reconnect to their new meter and "customer valve"
 

wyliesdiesels

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
19,983
Location
Modesto, CA
Don't make this political please.
Because of the major Texas wildfire my shop Utility provider now disconnects power during high wind/fire danger. So this weekend no power. Time to move or is a diesel generator in my future?
wow thats nuts. just like here in cali.

id say get a diesel generator
 

rlitman

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2010
Messages
24,578
Location
Long Island
...
One side note ... I know you don't have it... but I have NG. but AGAIN during a storm... it's a possibility for them to SHUT down the NG here. They did during Sandy in a small area of the town.
NG shutdown isn't done a lot, but a few situations come to mind. Sandy's NG shutdowns (that I'm aware of) were all due to flooding. Both flooding of gas infrastructure, but more importantly flooding of gas furnaces requires inspection and care when the service is turned back on. Entire neighborhoods have burned from mistakes like this, but if you're far from a flood zone, this isn't likely to affect you.

The big power outage in Texas was primarily due to a NG grid failure caused by the cold snap. That took a huge proportion of the state's NG generation offline, and while I have not read reports of it affecting at-home NG service, I wouldn't be too surprised if it did. Even if it didn't happen, it surely was uncomfortably close to a complete NG grid failure across Texas, so if you're in Texas, maybe NG isn't the best power backup option.
 

PelicanPines

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
38,104
Location
New Jersey, USA, Earth, My own reality
NG shutdown isn't done a lot, but a few situations come to mind. Sandy's NG shutdowns (that I'm aware of) were all due to flooding. Both flooding of gas infrastructure, but more importantly flooding of gas furnaces requires inspection and care when the service is turned back on. Entire neighborhoods have burned from mistakes like this, but if you're far from a flood zone, this isn't likely to affect you.

The big power outage in Texas was primarily due to a NG grid failure caused by the cold snap. That took a huge proportion of the state's NG generation offline, and while I have not read reports of it affecting at-home NG service, I wouldn't be too surprised if it did. Even if it didn't happen, it surely was uncomfortably close to a complete NG grid failure across Texas, so if you're in Texas, maybe NG isn't the best power backup option.
Our fire dude... said ... they shut the gas off to prevent gas leaks in the days/weeks after the storm. The good news... if the NG main 1000 feet up the road goes ... it's a 12" line I think... goes up... Pelican Pines will be renamed Seagull Coal.

All that said.. yea... it's why I would go with Propane (dedicated).. given the choice.
 

ericm

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 17, 2016
Messages
1,963
Location
Southern Oregon
Don't make this political please.
Because of the major Texas wildfire my shop Utility provider now disconnects power during high wind/fire danger. So this weekend no power. Time to move or is a diesel generator in my future?

Moving is probably not going to help unless you move out of the US. Once the utilities here in California got away with this, they are all going to try it. Here when they shut down for safety, it's a couple days at least before the turn power back on. They have to inspect the lines first.

Most people here have propane generators. We're all already on propane because we're rural. The drawback is that when there's an outage you go through propane FAST, especially if you run the generator 24/7. And since everyone's using their propane, the propane delivery companies run behind. So they might not get to you before you run out.

Most generator installers will recommend a larger generator than you really need, probably because they don't want a call back when you can't run your AC, pool pump and two ovens all at once. But most of the time you're using a fraction of the max and the generator is not running at its most efficient output. It can get costly.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

mike93lx

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
37,362
Location
Richmond, VA
Moving is probably not going to help unless you move out of the US. Once the utilities here in California got away with this, they are all going to try it. Here when they shut down for safety, it's a couple days at least before the turn power back on. They have to inspect the lines first.
Most of the US doesn't every experience natural disasters that would justify shutting down utilities.
 

JeepYJ

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 25, 2015
Messages
8,897
Moving is probably not going to help unless you move out of the US. Once the utilities here in California got away with this, they are all going to try it. Here when they shut down for safety, it's a couple days at least before the turn power back on. They have to inspect the lines first.

Most of the US doesn't every experience natural disasters that would justify shutting down utilities.
Yes most of the US has no issues with powerlines starting wildfires.
What does the utility company gain when they aren’t selling their product and service? If there’s no chance of being held responsible for starting a natural disaster I don’t see why “all” are going to try it.
 

wyliesdiesels

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
19,983
Location
Modesto, CA
Moving is probably not going to help unless you move out of the US. Once the utilities here in California got away with this, they are all going to try it. Here when they shut down for safety, it's a couple days at least before the turn power back on. They have to inspect the lines first.

Most people here have propane generators. We're all already on propane because we're rural. The drawback is that when there's an outage you go through propane FAST, especially if you run the generator 24/7. And since everyone's using their propane, the propane delivery companies run behind. So they might not get to you before you run out.

Most generator installers will recommend a larger generator than you really need, probably because they don't want a call back when you can't run your AC, pool pump and two ovens all at once. But most of the time you're using a fraction of the max and the generator is not running at its most efficient output. It can get costly.
only certain PoCos in california are doing this though. namely Profit gouge and Execute and SoCal Edison

The smaller ones like SMUD, Roseville, MID(my PoCO), TID, Merced ID, etc dont do this because they properly maintain their infrastructure.

This is why Profits gone elsewhere needs to be put out of business and their infrastructure given to not for profit Co-ops who do a far better job for far cheaper. MIDs rates are 250% lower than Pacific Graft and Extortions rates
 

ericm

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 17, 2016
Messages
1,963
Location
Southern Oregon
Most of the US doesn't every experience natural disasters that would justify shutting down utilities.

All of the west and a lot of the south is subject to wildfires. Much of the rest of the country gets tornadoes or hurricanes.

only certain PoCos in california are doing this though. namely Profit gouge and Execute and SoCal Edison

yea that's the vast majority of customers though.

The smaller ones like SMUD, Roseville, MID(my PoCO), TID, Merced ID, etc dont do this because they properly maintain their infrastructure.

I so wish we were served by a coop.

One of the neighbors built a house recently and put in solar and batteries. We get week long outages in the winter when it's dark and raining so they put in a generator port. Every couple days the batteries get low and they run a gas generator for a couple hours to top them up. In the summer they don't need the generator during outages as the solar puts out enough. I think this is the best solution but it's only cost effective if you have a lot of outages or need the power in your house to stay on seamlessly.
 

JeepYJ

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 25, 2015
Messages
8,897
Never heard of power being shut off because of a tornado. Those are generally really isolated events. Even large tornadoes have a very small impact area.
 

LopezBart

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 13, 2023
Messages
2,519
Location
Lopez Island, WA
This happens because of the fire risk caused by poorly maintained power lines/right of ways. With "increasing shareholder value" the watchword of corporate America, many execs are heavily incentivized to increase the stock price . This means that "overhead" - maintenance, training, inspections, etc. get short shrift, so the money thus redirected can be called. "profits".
 

walta

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 13, 2017
Messages
2,308
Location
Dutzow Missouri
This happens because of the fire risk caused by poorly maintained power lines/right of ways. With "increasing shareholder value" the watchword of corporate America, many execs are heavily incentivized to increase the stock price . This means that "overhead" - maintenance, training, inspections, etc. get short shrift, so the money thus redirected can be called. "profits".
Seems to me the way most utilities are regulated cutting cost decreases shareholders value in the long run as the regulators limit profits to some percentage of revenues. The higher the costs are the higher the higher the rates will get set makes the highest revenues so with the same percentage of a bigger pie equals more value for the shareholders. I am sure it is much more complicated in reality.

The power must be cut when the poles and wires are allowed to remain in service past their expiration date. If a fire starts because of outdated equipment the lawyer have a field day.

Walta
 
Last edited:

ratflinger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
322
Location
South Central Texas
Don't make this political please.
Because of the major Texas wildfire my shop Utility provider now disconnects power during high wind/fire danger. So this weekend no power. Time to move or is a diesel generator in my future?
Yeah, due the fault of those A-holes that bought SPS you are screwed. Let's just turn off power instead of maintaining our delivery infrastructure. I think you'd better get a generator, cheaper now than later. With luck they will be sued out of existence. This problem never appeared when SPS owned everything, they took care of stuff. Excel is about nothing but profit, just like PG&E. At least down here CPS is till owned by San Antonio, they take care of ****. Just a few months ago they inspected every pole in my subdivision and replaced any that were substandard.
 

Debcrow

Well-known member
Joined
May 14, 2019
Messages
4,012
Location
New Mexico
Profits are one side of the story.
Being able to maintain right of ways and build new infrastructure meets strong resistance from regulations and public opinion.
To be safe, turning off the power is a available option. AGAIN, LETS NOT MAKE THIS political!!! It's just a fact of the way things are.
 

cannuck

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 30, 2021
Messages
4,592
Location
Rural SK
930: what power do you require? We have 2 off-grid sites (storage structure at best bud's farm and eventual shop and everything else site on my farm). We each have pull-behind portable gensets with multiple 3 ph output and healthy single phase options. His is an ultra high hours 24kW from a long past project and mine us an ultra low hour 20 kW 208 and 120/240. Neither cost more than $5 grand (his literally nothing, mine at auction). I have a 240 feed to a construction panel, and it is used to heat and charge parked vehicles and work in my little shop but the generator is meant to run a cement tower for making concrete - without the need to run a dedicated feed a 1/4 mile. Many "events" are served by ability to tow a power source to the site. The way you find them is keep your ear to the ground and pitch a deal any time you see a potential machine that can fit your needs. Be prepared to do some minor repairs - as even a simple failure can take one out of the big buck price bracket.
 

ratflinger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
322
Location
South Central Texas
Profits are one side of the story.
Being able to maintain right of ways and build new infrastructure meets strong resistance from regulations and public opinion.
To be safe, turning off the power is a available option. AGAIN, LETS NOT MAKE THIS political!!! It's just a fact of the way things are.
The only one mentioning politics is you. Demanding that power companies maintain their infrastructure instead of just turning off the power is the right thing to do. In my many years on this planet I've never had my power turned off because something bad might happen somewhere. Until recently if there was a potential issue the power company took the initiative to proactively fix it. Now it's all Why bother to fix it, we can just turn off the power in the name of Public Safety.
 
OP
9

930dreamer

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
22,928
Location
Amarillo,TX and Stinnett,TX
The lawyer has stated the poles have termites/rot damage that's why they failed. There's been utility trucks with new poles everywhere for weeks, does that mean they totally dropped the ball?
 
Last edited:

bwringer

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
10,245
Location
Indianapolis
If you need three-phase power for big machines, that's gonna be a big ol' expensive generator. But you'd only need this to work while people are there and running the machines, so you might not need as much fuel on hand if it's not going 24/7.

I'm guessing you might need two generators: a smaller setup (powered by gasoline or propane) for things like lights, computers, fart fans, beer coolers, router, etc. and a separate heavy-duty generator, maybe diesel, for the times you need to power the machinery. And do you need this to fire up automatically even if no one is there, or can it wait until someone shows up?

And then there's the question of monitoring; since you don't live there, some sort of camera/monitor system on a battery backup with a wireless (cellular) data connection would help keep you apprised.

To clarify, is this more of a personal shop, or a commercial shop, like a repair, fabrication, or manufacturing facility? Is it just you, or are there employees who will need to be able to work if the power goes out?
 
OP
9

930dreamer

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
22,928
Location
Amarillo,TX and Stinnett,TX
If you need three-phase power for big machines, that's gonna be a big ol' expensive generator. But you'd only need this to work while people are there and running the machines, so you might not need as much fuel on hand if it's not going 24/7.

I'm guessing you might need two generators: a smaller setup (powered by gasoline or propane) for things like lights, computers, fart fans, beer coolers, router, etc. and a separate heavy-duty generator, maybe diesel, for the times you need to power the machinery. And do you need this to fire up automatically even if no one is there, or can it wait until someone shows up?

And then there's the question of monitoring; since you don't live there, some sort of camera/monitor system on a battery backup with a wireless (cellular) data connection would help keep you apprised.

To clarify, is this more of a personal shop, or a commercial shop, like a repair, fabrication, or manufacturing facility? Is it just you, or are there employees who will need to be able to work if the power goes out?
Strictly my hang out shop. Phase converter needs 50 amp 240v to run. Until I decide if this building will get new metal or another one built everything is temporary.
 

ratflinger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
322
Location
South Central Texas
The lawyer has stated the poles have termites/rot damage that's why they failed. There's been utility trucks will new poles everywhere for weeks, does that mean they totally dropped the ball?
Well someone dropped it. When they inspected the poles around here they dug down about 10" all around every pole. The assumption was that they were looking for subsurface rot or insect damage.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom